1989 年伯克希尔完整年报

完整年报 · 原文约 33896 词
译文与英文原文逐段对齐可在本页展开英文,也可打开发布者原址核对上下文。
打开来源正文

[第 1 页]

[PAGE 1]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

1989 年

年报

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. 1989 ANNUAL REPORT

[第 2 页]

[PAGE 2]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司及其子公司从事多项业务活动,其中最重要的是通过多家子公司在全国范围内开展的财产险与意外险及再保险业务。保险子公司的投资组合中包括对多家其他上市公司的大量持股。此外,伯克希尔·哈撒韦还出版《布法罗斯闻》——一份在纽约州北部发行的日报与周日版报纸。伯克希尔的若干子公司还开展与保险业务无关的大量商业活动,其中包括:费奇海默兄弟公司制服的制造与销售、科比家用清洁系统、喜诗精品巧克力糖果的制造与销售;此外还有《世界百科全书》及其他参考资料的出版发行;家居用品零售和精美珠宝零售。在加利福尼亚州帕萨迪纳,西科金融公司(一家上市公司,伯克希尔持股 80.1%)的子公司开展储蓄贷款业务。斯科特-费泽金融集团为伯克希尔全资子公司,为《世界百科全书》和科比产品的买方提供融资。伯克希尔各业务单元的运营决策由各单元经理做出。投资决策及所有其他资本配置决策由沃伦·E·巴菲特与查尔斯·T·芒格协商后,为伯克希尔及其子公司做出。巴菲特先生任伯克希尔董事会主席,芒格先生任副主席。

business activities. The most important of these is the property and casualts ostrance BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. and its subsidiaries engage in a number or aiverse and reinsurance business conducted nationwide through a number of subsidiaries. ages of other publicly traded companies. Investment portfolios of insurance subsidiaries include meaningful ownership percent- newspaper circulated in upstate New York, and a number of Berkshire subsidiaries Additionally, Berkshire Hathaway publishes the Buffalo News. a daily and Sunday conduct substantial business activities unrelated to the insurance business. These include: systems and of See's fine chocolate candy: also, the publication and distribution of World the manufacture and distribution of Fechheimer Bros. uniforms, of Kirby home cleaning the retailing of fine jewelry. A savings and loan business is conducted in Pasadena, Book encyclopedias and other reference materials: the retailing of home furnishings and owned subsidiary of Berkshire. The Scott Fetzer Financial Group, 100% owned by California by a subsidiary of Wesco Financial Corporation, a publicly traded and 80.1% Berkshire, provides financing for buyers of World Book and Kirby products. managers. Investment decisions and all other capital allocation decisions are made for Operating decisions for the various Berkshire business units are made by unit Berkshire and its subsidiaries by Warren E. Buffett, in consultation with Charles T. Munger. Mr. Buffett is Chairman and Mr. Munger is Vice Chairman of Berkshire's Board

[第 3 页]

[PAGE 3]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

1989 年年报

目录

公司业务活动 内封页

与所有者相关的经营原则 2

五年间隔选定财务数据 4

董事长致股东的信* 5

独立审计师报告 26

合并财务报表 27

管理层讨论 40

伯克希尔各业务板块合并财务报表——未经审计—— 45

股东指定捐赠 52

西科金融公司年报致股东信 54

互助储蓄银行退出美国储蓄机构联盟的辞职函 71

过去五年选定财务数据 72

普通股数据 72

公司董事与高管 内封底

*版权 © 1990 沃伦·E·巴菲特

保留所有权利

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. 1989 ANNUAL REPORT TABLE OF CONTENTS Business Activities Of The Company.. ...Inside Front Cover Owner-Related Business Principles ..2 Selected Financial Data At Five Year Intervals ..4 Chairman's Letter* ..... ..5 Independent Auditor's Report... . 26 Consolidated Financial Statements.. 27 Management's Discussion 40 Combined Financial Statements - Unaudited - for Berkshire's Business Groups 45 Shareholder-Designated Contributions ..52 Annual Report Letter - Wesco Financial Corporation. ..54 Mutual Savings' letter of resignation from U.S. League of Savings Institutions ...71 Selected Financial Data For The Past Five Years....... ...72 Common Stock Data........................ .........72 Directors and Officers of the Company ...Inside Back Cover *Copyright © 1990 By Warren E. Buffett All Rights Reserved

[第 4 页]

[PAGE 4]

在 1983 年的年报中,董事长致股东的信里包含了一些“与所有者相关的经营原则”。由于这些内容至今仍具现实意义,现将它们重印于本页和下页。

鉴于新股东众多,有必要在此总结一下我们在经理人与所有者关系上遵循的主要经营原则:

  • 尽管我们的法定形式是公司制,但我们的心态是合伙制。查理·芒格和我将我们的股东视为所有者合伙人,将自己视为管理合伙人。(由于我们持股规模巨大,因此无论好坏,我们也都是控股合伙人。)我们不把公司本身视为我们商业资产的最终所有者,而是把公司视为一个通道,我们的股东通过它来拥有这些资产。
  • 与这种所有者导向相一致,我们的董事会成员均为伯克希尔·哈撒韦的主要股东。至少四个家族持有伯克希尔股票,且持股超过其家族净资产的 50%。我们所食即我们所烹。
  • 我们的长期经济目标(受制于下文提到的几项条件)是,让每股内在商业价值的平均年增长率最大化。我们不依据规模来衡量伯克希尔的经济意义或业绩表现;我们以每股的进步来衡量。我们确信,未来每股价值的提升速度将会放缓——大幅扩大的资本基础必然会带来这一结果。但如果我们的增速未能超过美国大公司的平均水平,我们将会感到失望。
  • 为达成这一目标的首选路径是,直接持有一组多元化的企业,它们能产生现金流,并能持续获得高于平均水平的资本回报。我们的次优选择是,通过我们的保险子公司,主要采取购买可交易普通股的方式,来持有类似企业的部分所有权。单个年份的资本配置,取决于企业的价格和可得性,以及保险业务对资本的需求。
  • 鉴于这种双管齐下的企业所有权模式,以及传统会计的局限性,合并层面的报告收益可能难以揭示我们真实的经济表现。查理和我,无论是作为所有者还是作为管理者,几乎都无视这类合并数字。不过,我们也会向你们报告我们控制的每家主要企业的收益,我们认为这些数字极为重要。这些数字,辅以我们将提供的有关各家企业的其他信息,通常应能帮助你们对它们做出判断。
  • 会计后果不会影响我们的运营或资本配置决策。当收购成本相近时,我们宁愿收购 2 美元按标准会计原则无法报告给我们的收益,也不愿收购 1 美元可报告的收益。这正是我们常面临的选择,因为整家企业(其收益将完全可报告)的售价,常常是小部分股权(其收益将大幅无法报告)按同等比例对应价格的两倍。总体而言,随着时间的推移,这些未报告的收益预计将通过资本利得,充分反映在我们的内在商业价值之中。
  • 我们极少大量举债,即便举债,也尽量将其设置为长期固定利率。我们宁愿拒绝有吸引力的机会,也不愿过度拉高资产负债表的杠杆。这种保守态度牺牲了我们的业绩,但也是唯一让我们感到安心的做法,考虑到我们对投保人、储户、贷款人,以及将异常大比例身家托付给我们的众多股票持有人的信托责任。(正如一句印第安纳波利斯 500 英里大赛冠军所言:“要第一个冲线,首先你得跑完全程。”)

*版权 © 1984 沃伦·E·巴菲特

保留所有权利

Certain OWNER-RELATED BUSINESS PRINCIPLES were included in the Chairman's letter* to Shareholders of Berkshire Hathaway Inc. in the 1983 Annual Report. Because the material remains topical, it is reproduced on this and the following page. With so many new shareholders, it's appropriate to summarize the major business principles we follow that pertain to the manager-owner relationship: shareholders as owner-partners, and of ourselves as managing partners. (Because of the size of our • Although our form is corporate, our attitude is partnership. Charlie Munger and I think of our shareholdings we also are, for better or worse, controlling partners.) We do not view the company itself as the ultimate owner of our business assets but, instead, view the company as a conduit through which our shareholders own the assets. In the case of at least four, over 50% of family net worth is represented by holdings of Berkshire. We • In line with this owner-orientation, our directors are major shareholders of Berkshire Hathaway. eat our own cooking. average annual rate of gain in intrinsic business value on a per-share basis. We do not measure the economic • Our long-term economic goal (subject to some qualifications mentioned later) is to maximize the significance or performance of Berkshire by its size; we measure by per-share progress. We are certain that the rate of per-share progress will diminish in the future — a greatly enlarged capital base will see to that. But we will be disappointed if our rate does not exceed that of the average large American corporation. that generate cash and consistently earn above-average returns on capital. Our second choice is to own • Our preference would be to reach this goal by directly owning a diversified group of businesses insurance subsidiaries. The price and availability of businesses and the need for insurance capital determine parts ot similar businesses, attained primarily through purchases of marketable common stocks by our any given year's capital allocation. conventional accounting, consolidated reported earnings may reveal relatively little about our true economic • Because of this two-pronged approach to business ownership and because of the limitations of performance. Charlie and I, both as owners and managers, virtually ignore such consolidated numbers. However, we will also report to you the earnings of each major business we control, numbers we consider of great importance. These figures, along with other information we will supply about the individual businesses, should generally aid you in making judgments about them. acquisition costs are similar, we much prefer to purchase $2 of earnings that is not reportable by us under • Accounting consequences do not influence our operating or capital-allocation decisions. When standard accounting principles than to purchase $1 of earnings that is reportable. This is precisely the choice that often faces us since entire businesses (whose earnings will be fully reportable) frequently sell for double the pro-rata price of small portions (whose earnings will be largely unreportable). In aggregate and over time, we expect the unreported earnings to be fully reflected in our intrinsic business value through capital gains. oasis. We will reject interesting opportunities rather than over-leverage our balance sheet. This conservatisn • We rarely use much debt and, when we do, we attempt to structure it on a long-term fixed-rate has penalized our results but it is the only behavior that leaves us comfortable, considering our fiduciary large portions of their net worth to our care. (As one of the Indianapolis "500" winners said: "To finish obligations to policyholders, depositors, lenders and the many equity holders who have committed unusually first, you must first finish.") *Copyright © 1984 by Warren E. Buffett All Rights Reserved 2

[第 5 页]

[PAGE 5]

我们绝不会以牺牲股东长期经济利益为代价、按控股权价格去收购整家企业。管理层的“愿望清单”不会由股东买单。我们不会通过收购来分散投资——你们完全可以通过在股票市场直接买入来分散自己的投资组合。我们只会在全面权衡你们通过股票市场直接投资所能获得的价值后,用你们的钱去做我们拿自己的钱也会做的事。

我们认为良好初衷应定期用结果来检验。我们以留存收益创造的每 1 美元市值增幅,来衡量保留利润的决策是否明智。迄今为止,这项检验是达标的。我们会继续以五年为滚动周期来应用这一标准。随着净资产增长,明智地运用留存收益变得越来越困难。

我们只有在收到的企业价值与付出的价值对等时,才会发行普通股。这条规则适用于所有形式的发行——不仅包括并购或公开股票发行,也包括债转股、股票期权以及可转换证券。我们不会以与整个企业价值不符的基础出售你们公司的一小部分——而发行股份本质上就是出售公司的一小部分。

有一点是查理和我共同抱持的态度,你们应当充分了解,而它确实拖累了我们的财务表现:无论价格如何,我们对出售伯克希尔所拥有的任何好企业都毫无兴趣;而对于那些低于平均水准的企业,只要预期它们至少还能产生一些现金,只要我们对它们的管理层和劳资关系还算满意,我们也极不情愿出售。我们希望不再重蹈那些将我们拖入低劣生意的资本配置错误。对于那种靠大笔资本支出就能让差劲企业恢复令人满意的盈利能力的说法,我们会以极大的审慎来应对。(在糟糕的行业里,大笔追加投资通常就像在流沙里挣扎一样徒劳——规划会很诱人,倡议者也会很真诚——但到头来终归如此。)话虽如此,“金拉米”式的管理行为(每一轮都扔掉你最没希望的生意)并不是我们的风格。我们宁愿整体业绩略受影响,也不愿去搞那一套。

在向你们报告时,我们会坦诚相告,着重强调那些对评估企业价值至关重要的有利与不利因素。我们的原则是告诉你们经营事实——如果位置互换,这也是我们自己想知道的。坦诚对我们作为管理者也有好处:在公开场合误导他人的 CEO,最终可能会连自己也骗过去。

尽管我们奉行坦诚政策,但对我们持有的可交易证券,我们只会在法律要求的范围内予以讨论。好的投资想法就像好的产品或收购想法一样,稀少、宝贵且容易被他人争相利用。因此,我们通常不会谈论自己的投资想法。这一禁令甚至延伸到我们已经卖出的证券(因为我们可能再次买入),以及市场误传我们正在买入的股票。如果我们在某些场合否认传闻,却在其他场合说“无可奉告”,那么那些“无可奉告”反而会变成默认确认。

entire businesses at control prices that ignore long-term economic consequences to our shareholders. We • A managerial "wish list" will not be filled at shareholder expense. We will not diversify by purchasing by diversifying your own portfolios through direct purchases in the stock market. will only do with your money what we would do with our own, weighing fully the values you can obtain • We feel noble intentions should be checked periodically against results. We test the wisdom of rolling basis. As our net worth grows, it is more difficult to use retained earnings wisely. value for each $1 retained. To date, this test has been met. We will continue to apply it on a five-year • We will issue common stock only when we receive as much in business value as we give. This rule applies to all forms of issuance — not only mergers or public stock offerings, but stock-for-debt swaps, stock options, and convertible securities as well. We will not sell small portions of your company - and that is what the issuance of shares amounts to - on a basis inconsistent with the value of the entire enterprise. • You should be fully aware of one attitude Charlie and I share that hurts our financial performance: regardless of price, we have no interest at all in selling any good businesses that Berkshire owns, and are very reluctant to sell sub-par businesses as long as we expect them to generate at least some cash and as long as we feel good about their managers and labor relations. We hope not to repeat the capital- that our poor businesses can be restored to satisfactory profitability by major capital expenditures. (The allocation mistakes that led us into such sub-par businesses. And we react with great caution to suggestions in a terrible industry usually is about as rewarding as struggling in quicksand.) Nevertheless, gin rummy projections will be dazzling — the advocates will be sincere — but, in the end, major additional investment managerial behavior (discard your least promising business at each turn) is not our style. We would rather have our overall results penalized a bit than engage in it. business value. Our guideline is to tell you the business facts that we would want to know if our positions • We will be candid in our reporting to you, emphasizing the pluses and minuses important in appraising in private. candor benefits us as managers: the CEO who misleads others in public may eventually mislead himself extent legally required. Good investment ideas are rare, valuable and subject to competitive appropriation • Despite our policy of candor, we will discuss our activities in marketable securities only to the just as good product or business acquisition ideas are. Therefore, we normally will not talk about our and to stocks we are incorrectly rumored to be buying. If we deny those reports but say "no comment" investment ideas. This ban extends even to securities we have sold (because we may purchase them again) on other occasions, the no-comments become confirmation. 3

[第 6 页]

[PAGE 6]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

五年间隔财务数据精选

(除每股数据外,金额单位均为千美元)

196419691974197919841989
收入:
保险保费收入$ 49,983$ 25,258$ 40,427$ 32,592$ 60,574
销售收入及服务收入5,7222,017$ 286,493
已实现投资收益(损失)$ —$ (1,908)$ 7,916$ 24,747$ 140,242$ 394,279
保险集团投资收益10,769114,13669,281250,723
181,949
总收入$ 49,983$ 73,424$ 100,384$ 560,381$ 861,388$ 2,483,892
盈利(亏损):
已实现投资收益前利润$ (2,824)$ 3,863$ (1,340)$ 35,921$ 70,201$ 299,902
已实现投资收益(损失)(1,908)7,9538,38378,694147,575
净利润(亏损)$ (2,824)$ 4,090$ 8,383$ 42,817$ 148,895$ 447,477
每股盈利(亏损):
已实现投资收益前利润$ (2.41)$ 3.92$ (1.37)$ 34.97$ 61.21$ 262.46
已实现投资收益(损失)(2.11)8.566.7168.61127.55
净利润(亏损)$ (2.41)$ 4.15$ 7.19$ 41.68$ 129.82$ 390.01
年末数据:
总资产$ 27,887$ 22,139$ 95,746$ 216,214$ 1,433,863$ 9,459,594
股东权益$ 43,918$ 88,199$ 134,416$ 1,271,761$ 4,925,126
定期债务及其他借款$ 2,5007,41921,830344,9621,007,516
发行在外的普通股股数(千股)1,1389809801,0271,1471,146
每股股东权益$ 19.46$ 44.83$ 90.04$ 335.85$ 1,108.77$ 4,296.01

1964 财年为截至 1964 年 10 月 3 日的 52 周周期。1969、1974、1979 和 1984 年均为截至当年 12 月 31 日临近星期六的财年。

数据按照 1989 年的合并会计政策列报;据此,部分以前年度数据已重述。

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. Selected Financial Data at Five Year Intervals (dollars in thousands, except per share amounts) 1964 1969 1974 1979 1984 1989 Revenues: Insurance premiums earned Sales and service revenues. $ 49,983 $ 25,258 40,427 $ 32,592 5,722 2,017 60,574 $ 286,493 181,949 $ 496,971 $ 1,526,459 Realized investment gain (loss). Investment income, insurance group - (1,908) 7,916 24,747 140,242 394,279 10,769 114,136 69,281 250,723 $ 560,381 $ 861,388 $2,483,892 223,810 Earnings (loss): Total revenues $ 49,983 $ 73,424 $ 100,384 Before realized investment gain (2,824) $ 3,863 (2,824) $ 7,953 4,090 (1,340) 8,383 $ 35,921 $ 42,817 6,896 $ 70,201 78,694 $ 299,902 Net earnings (loss) ... Realized investment gain (loss) 7,043 $ 148,895 $ 447,477 147,575 Earnings (loss) per share: Before realized investment gain Net earnings (loss).. Realized investment gain (loss) $ (2.41) $ 3.92 $ $ (2.11) $ 4.15 8.56 $ 34.97 41.68 6.71 $ 61.21 $ 129.82 68.61 $ 262.46 8.07 $ (1.37) Year-end data: 7.19 $ 127.55 390.01 Total assets. 27,887 $ 22,139 2,500 95,746 216,214 Shareholders' equity Term debt and other borrowings..... 43,918 7,419 88,199 21,830 $ 1,433,863 134,416 $2,297,516 1,271,761 127,104 $ 9,459,594 344,962 4,925,126 1,007,516 Common shares outstanding, Shareholders' equity per in thousands … 1,138 980 980 1,027 1,147 1,146 outstanding share..... $ 19.46 $ 44.83 $ 90.04 $ 335.85 $1,108.77 $ 4,296.01 The 1964 fiscal year was the 52 week period ended October 3, 1964. The years 1969, 1974, 1979 and 1984 were fiscal years that ended on Saturday nearest December 31. and accounting practices; accordingly, certain prior year data have been restated. Data are presented in conformity with 1989 consolidation 4

[第 7 页]

[PAGE 7]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

致伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司股东:

1989 年我们的净资产增长了 15.15 亿美元,增幅 44.4%。过去 25 年来(即现任管理层接手以来),我们的每股账面价值已从 19.46 美元增长到 4,296.01 美元,年复合增长率 23.8%。

然而,真正重要的是内在价值——这个数字表明我们旗下所有业务合理而言值多少钱。如果能完美预见未来,这个数值可以通过计算一家企业所有未来现金流入和流出,再按当前利率折现来得出。按此估值,无论是制造马鞭的厂商,还是经营手机的公司,所有企业在经济意义上都成了等价物。

在伯克希尔账面价值还是 19.46 美元的时候,内在价值还要略低一些,因为当时的账面价值完全绑定在一家纺织企业上,而该企业的实际价值低于账面所记载的数字。如今,我们的大多数企业价值已远超其账面载值。这种从折价到溢价的演变令人欣喜,它意味着伯克希尔内在价值的复利增速要略高于账面价值 23.8% 的年增长率。

看后视镜是一回事,看挡风玻璃是另一回事。我们账面价值的很大一部分由权益证券构成,这些证券除极少数例外,均按当前市场价值记账。到年底,这些证券的定价相对于其自身内在商业价值,已高于过去所见的水平。一个原因是 1989 年股市的活跃。更重要的是,这些企业的优点已得到广泛认可。过去,它们的股价曾经低得不合理,而现在已不是这种情况。

我们将继续持有大部分重仓股,无论其价格相对内在价值是高是低。这种“至死不渝”的态度,再加上这些持股目前所要求的高价位,意味着不能指望它们未来像过去那样大幅推升伯克希尔的价值。换言之,我们至今的业绩得益于“双重收益”:(1)我们的投资组合公司自身实现了非凡的内在价值增长;(2)我们还获得了这些公司的估值从折价转为相对一般企业明显溢价所带来的额外奖励。我们相信投资组合公司未来仍将实现良好的业务价值增长,并将继续从中受益。但我们的“补涨”奖励已经兑现,这意味着未来只能满足于“单重收益”。

我们还面临另一个障碍:在一个有限的世界里,高增长率必然会自我毁灭。如果增长的基数极小,这条规律可能暂时不发挥作用。但当基数膨胀起来,派对就结束了:高增长率最终会为自己铸下锚。

卡尔·萨根曾生动地描述过这一现象,他思索着每 15 分钟繁殖为二的细菌的命运。萨根说:“这意味着每 15 分钟翻一番,每小时翻 96 番。虽然一个细菌仅重约一万亿分之一克,但经过一天放纵的无性繁殖之后,它的后代总重量将堪比一座山……”即使在最糟糕的日子里,查理·芒格(伯克希尔副董事长,我的合伙人)和我也不会把伯克希尔想象成细菌。而且,令我们始终遗憾不已的是,我们也没有找到每 15 分钟就让净资产翻倍的办法。此外,我们丝毫不羞于繁殖——在财务上——公开地去做。然而,萨根的观察仍然适用。从伯克希尔目前 49 亿美元的净资产基础出发,要实现账面价值年均 15% 的增长,将比我们从 2,200 万美元起步时做到年均 23.8% 的增长困难得多。

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. To the Shareholders of Berkshire Hathaway Inc.: is, since present management took over) our per-share book value has grown from $19.46 to $4,296.01, Our gain in net worth during 1989 was $1.515 billion, or 44.4%. Over the last 25 years (that or at a rate of 23.8% compounded annually. businesses are rationally worth. With perfect foresight, this number can be calculated by taking What counts, however, is intrinsic value - the figure indicating what all of our constituent rates. So valued, all businesses, from manufacturers of buggy whips to operators of cellular phones, all future cash flows of a business - in and out - and discounting them at prevailing interest become economic equals. Back when Berkshire's book value was $19.46, intrinsic value was somewhat less because the book value was entirely tied up in a textile business not worth the figure at which it was carried from a discount to a premium means that Berkshire's intrinsic business Now most of our businesses are worth far more than their carrying values. This agreeable evolution at a rate that somewhat exceeds our 23.8% annual growth in book value. value has compounded is represented by equity securities that, with minor exceptions, are carried on The rear-view mirror is one thing; the windshield is another. A large portion of our book value at current market values. At yearend these securities were valued at higher prices, relative to their own intrinsic business values, than has been the case in the past. One reason is the buoyant 1989 once their stock prices were inappropriately low, they are not now. stock market. More important, the virtues of these businesses have been widely recognized. Whereas business value. This 'til-death-do-us-part attitude, combined with the full prices these holdings command, We will keep most of our major holdings, regardless of how they are priced relative to intrinsic the past. In other words, our performance to date has benefited from a double-dip: (1) the exceptional means that they cannot be expected to push up Berkshire's value in the future as sharply as in gains in intrinsic value that our portfolio companies have achieved; (2) the additional bonus we in relation to those of the average business. We will continue to benefit from good gains in business value that we feel confident our portfolio companies will make. But our "catch-up" rewards have been realized, which means we'll have to settle for a single-dip in the future. We face another obstacle: In a finite world, high growth rates must self-destruct. If the base from which the growth is taking place is tiny, this law may not operate for a time. But when the base balloons, the party ends: A high growth rate eventually forges its own anchor. overly ages to on at that reproduce by dividing into two every 15 minutes. Says Sagan: Carl Sagan has entertainingly described this phenomenon, musing about the destiny of bacteria an hour, and 96 doublings a day. Although a bacterium weighs only about a trillionth of a gram, "That means four doublings its descendants, after a day of wild asexual abandon, will collectively weigh as much as a mountain...in think of Berkshire as a bacterium. Nor, to our unending sorrow, have we found a way to Even on bad days, Charlie Munger (Berkshire's Vice Chairman and my partner) and I do not its net worth every 15 minutes. Furthermore, we are not the least bit shy about reproducing — double $4.9 billion in net worth, we will find it much more difficult to average 15% annual growth in financially — in public. Nevertheless, Sagan's observations apply. From Berkshire's present base of book value than we did to average 23.8% from the $22 million we began with. 5

[第 8 页]

[PAGE 8]

税收

1989 年,伯克希尔获得的 15 亿美元收益是在我们计提了约 7.12 亿美元准备金之后实现的,这笔准备金按当时通行的 28% 税率计提。此外,伯克希尔从其五大被投资公司支付的所得税中应占的份额总计约 1.75 亿美元。

很可能将出台一项新会计准则,要求公司按当前税率(无论其具体是多少)为所有已实现收益计提准备金。若税率为 34%,该项规定将使我们的递延所得税负债增加约 7,100 万美元,并使我们的净资产相应减少——这是将 1987 年之前收益的准备金提高六个百分点的结果。由于这项拟议中的规定引发了广泛争议,其最终形式尚不清楚,我们尚未做出此项变更。正如你从第 27 页的资产负债表所见,我们本应面临的税收超过 11 亿美元。其对经审计净资产的影响将是减少 11 亿美元。

另一方面,这种递延所得税负债是否因为其支付只能通过出售股票来触发——而其中大部分股票我们绝无出售意图——而成为一种毫无意义的会计虚构?答案同样是否定的。从经济角度看,这项负债类似于美国财政部提供的一笔无息贷款,其偿还与否完全由我们自行决定(当然,除非国会决定在收益实现前就对其征税)。这笔“贷款”在其他方面也很奇特:它只能用于持有那些特定的、已增值的股票,其规模会随市场价格的每日变动而波动,且会因税率变化而周期性调整。实际上,这项递延所得税负债相当于一笔巨额的、仅在我们决定从一项资产转向另一项资产时才需缴纳的转让税。事实上,我们在 1989 年出售了一些相对较小的持股,在 2.24 亿美元的收益上产生了约 7,600 万美元的“转让”税。

——我们来看一个极端的对比。

假设伯克希尔只有 1 美元,我们用这 1 美元投资了一只证券,年底时价格翻倍,然后被卖出。再想象一下,我们用税后收益在接下来的 19 年里每年重复这一过程,每次都将资金翻倍。到第 20 年底,我们对每次销售利润缴纳的 34% 资本利得税将向政府贡献约 1.3 万美元,而我们自己则剩下约 25,250 美元。这还不赖。然而,如果我们用这 1 美元进行一项奇特投资,该投资本身在 20 年里翻 20 倍,那么我们的 1 美元将增长到 1,048,576 美元。如果我们那时套现,将按 34% 的税率缴纳约 356,500 美元的税,自己则剩下约 692,000 美元。

有趣的是,政府在实际税收收入上(356,500 美元对比 13,000 美元)与我们从第二种场景中获得的收益比例完全相同,都是 27:1——虽然,不可否认,它必须等待才能拿到这笔钱。

我们必须强调,我们之所以青睐长期投资承诺的策略,并非因为上述数学计算。事实上,通过在一项投资与另一项投资之间更频繁地转换,我们有可能获得更高的税后回报。多年前,查理和我正是在做那样的事。

Taxes income taxes. in addition, Berkshire's share of the income taxes paid by its five major investees Our 1989 gain of $1.5 billion was achieved after we took a charge of about $712 million for totaled about $175 million.

  • carry reserves booked at the 28% tax rate that then prevailed.

all gains at the current tax rate, whatever it may be. With the rate at 34%, such a rule would A new accounting rule is likely to be adopted that will require companies to reserve against increase our deferred tax liability, and decrease our net worth, by about $71 million - the result has sparked widespread controversy and its final form is unclear, we have not yet made this change. of raising the reserve on our pre-1987 gain by six percentage points. Because the proposed rule As you can see from our balance sheet on page 27, we would owe taxes of more than $1.1 effect on audited net worth, reducing it by $1.1 billion. its payment can be triggered only by the sale of stocks that, in very large part, we have no intention On the other hand, is this liability for deferred taxes a meaningless accounting fiction because of selling? Again, the answer is no. due only at our election (unless, of course, Congress moves to tax gains before they are realized). In economic terms, the liability resembles an interest-free loan from the U.S. Treasury that comes This "loan" is peculiar in other respects as well: It can be used only to finance the ownership of the particular, appreciated stocks and it fluctuates in size — daily as market prices change and transfer tax that is payable only if we elect to move from one asset to another. Indeed, we sold periodically if tax rates change. In effect, this deferred tax liability is equivalent to a very large of gains. some relatively small holdings in 1989, incurring about $76 million of "transfer" tax on $224 million

  • if

look at an extreme comparison. was then sold. Imagine further that we used the after-tax proceeds to repeat this process in each Imagine that Berkshire had only $1, which we put in a security that doubled by yearend and gains tax that we would have paid on the profits from each sale would have delivered about $13.000 next 19 years, scoring a double each time. At the end of the 20 years, the 34% capital to the single fantastic investment that itself doubled 20 times during the 20 years, our dollar would grow government and we would be left with about $25,250. Not bad. If, however, we made a left with about $692,000. to $1,048,576. Were we then to cash out, we would pay a 34% tax of roughly $356,500 and be Interestingly, the government would The sole reason for this staggering difference in results would be the timing of tax payments.

  • taking in taxes of $356,500 vs. $13,000 — though, admittedly, it would have to wait for its

gain from Scenario 2 in exactly the same 27:1 ratio as we money. because of these mathematics. Indeed, it is possible we could earn greater after-tax returns by moving We have not, we should stress, adopted our strategy favoring long-term investment commitments rather frequently from one investment to another. Many years ago, that's exactly what Charlie and 6

[第 9 页]

[PAGE 9]

我们找到了卓越的企业

如今我们宁愿坚守不动,哪怕这意味着回报略低。理由很简单:与那些我们欣赏并信任的人建立的关系极其罕见且令人愉悦,我们希望这些关系能够带来良好——尽管或许并非最优——的财务结果。考虑到这一点,我们认为放弃与那些我们知道有趣且值得钦佩的人相处的时光,去与那些我们不认识、且人品很可能接近普通人的人相处,实在毫无意义。如果一个人已经富有,那简直就像为了钱而结婚——在大多数情况下是错误,是疯狂。

报告收益的来源

下表显示了伯克希尔报告收益的主要来源。在此呈现中,商誉摊销及其他主要的购买价格会计调整并未计入它们所属的特定业务,而是汇总后单独列示。这一做法让你可以看到我们各项业务的收益,就像我们没有购买它们时本应报告的样子。我在过去的报告中解释过,为什么我们认为这种呈现方式对投资者和管理者来说,比使用公认会计原则(GAAP)更有用,因为 GAAP 要求逐笔业务进行购买价格调整。当然,表中显示的总净收益与 GAAP 审计财务报表中的总净收益完全相同。关于这些业务的更多信息,请参见第 37-39 页的业务分部章节以及第 40-44 页的管理层讨论章节。在这些章节中,你还可以找到进一步的信息。我强烈建议你阅读查理·芒格的信函,该信函从第 54 页开始。此外,我们在第 71 页重印了查理 1989 年 5 月 30 日写给美国储蓄机构联盟的信函,其中传达了相关信息。关于西科金融的业务信息,我敦促你阅读查理的信函。此外,我们在第 71 页重印了查理 1989 年 5 月 30 日写给美国储蓄机构联盟的信函,其中传达了伯克希尔对西科金融收益的份额(000 省略)。

伯克希尔份额净收益
税前收益1989198819891988
(扣除税款和少数股东权益后)
经营收益:
保险集团:
承保$ (24,400)$ (11,081)$ (12,259)$ (1,045)
净投资收益243,599231,250197,779213,642
Fechheimer12,62114,1526,7897,720
《布法罗新闻》46,04742,42927,77125,462
Kirby26,11426,89116,80317,842
内布拉斯加
家具城17,0708,4419,0994,516
斯科特-费泽制造集团33,16528,54218,43917,640
喜诗糖果34,23532,47319,99620,626
通用再保险19,67117,64013,00816,133
西科金融 - 保险以外25,58327,8909,81016,372
世界图书10,65018,0217,37011,674
其他43,25536,63724,61120,198
购买价格会计调整(5,740)(3,387)(6,342)(2,806)
利息费用(42,389)(35,613)(27,098)(23,212)
股东指定捐款(5,867)(7,340)(3,372)(2,806)
其他23,75541,059(4,966)12,863
经营收益393,414418,450277,177313,441
证券销售收益223,810131,671147,57585,829
所有实体总收益$ 617,224$ 550,121$ 447,477$ 399,270

*不包括斯科特-费泽金融集团和互助储蓄与贷款公司的利息费用。

We have found splendid business Now we would rather stay put, even if that means slightly lower returns. Our reason is simple: retain all we develop. This decision is particularly easy for us because we feel that these relationships relationships to be so rare and so enjoyable that we want to will produce good - though perhaps not optimal - financial results. Considering that, we think it makes little sense for us to give up time with people we know to be interesting and admirable for time with others we do not know and who are likely to have human qualities far closer to if one is already rich. average. That would be akin to marrying for money - a mistake under most circumstances, insanity Sources of Reported Earnings amortization of Goodwill and other major purchase-price accounting adjustments are not charged The table below shows the major sources of Berkshire's reported earnings. In this presentation, against the specific businesses to which they apply, but are instead aggregated and shown separately. had we not purchased them. I've explained in past reports why this form of presentation seems This procedure lets you view the earnings of our businesses as they would have been reported to us to be more useful to investors and managers than one utilizing generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), which require purchase-price adjustments to be made on a business-by-business in our audited financial basis. The total net earnings we show in the table are, of course, identical to the GAAP total statements. 37-39, and in the Management's Discussion section on pages 40-44. In these sections you also will Further information about these businesses is given in the Business Segment section on pages urge you to read Charlie Munger's letter, which starts on page 54. In addition, we have reprinted on a GAAP basis. For information on Wesco's businesses, I on page 71 Charlie's May 30, 1989 letter to the U.S. League of Savings Institutions, which conveyed (000s omitted) Berkshire's Share of Net Earnings 1989 Pre-Tax Earnings after taxes and 1988 minority interests) Operating Earnings: 1989 1988 Insurance Group: Underwriting Net Investment Income.. $ (24,400) 243,599 $ (11,081) $ 231,250 213,642 (12,259) $ 197,779 (1,045) Fechheimer.... Buffalo News... 12,621 46,047 14,152 42,429 27,771 6,789 25,462 Kirby. 26,114 26,891 16,803 17,842 7,720 Nebraska Furniture Mart. 17,070 8,441 9,099 Scott Fetzer Manufacturing Group 33,165 28,542 18,439 See's Candies.. 34,235 32,473 19,996 20,626 19,671 17,640 Wesco - other than Insurance 13,008 16,133 World Book 25,583 27,890 9,810 16,372 10,650 18,021 Omer uticase Cice counting Charges.. (5,740) (3,387) (6,342) (2,806) (6,668) (3,372) (2,806) Interest Expense*…. Shareholder-Designated Contributions (42,389) (5,867) (35,613) (27,098) (23,212) (7,340) Other 23,755 41,059 (4,966) 12,863 (3,814) (3,217) perating Earning 393,414 418,450 27,177 ales of Securitie 223,810 131,671 299,902 147,575 313,441 Total Earnings - All Entities 617.224 $ 550,121 $ 447,477 $ 85,829 399,270 *Excludes interest expense of Scott Fetzer Financial Group and Mutual Savings & Loan. 7

[第 10 页]

[PAGE 10]

四个业务板块。

我还请你仔细阅读第 45–51 页的内容。这些页面列示的资产负债表和利润表,是我和查理看待伯克希尔财务数据的方式——我们把财务信息归入四个板块,帮你计算伯克希尔的内在价值。这四个板块是:(1)我们的保险业务,并逐项列明其主要投资仓位;(2)我们的制造、出版和零售业务,剔除某些非经营性资产和购买价格会计调整;(3)我们从事金融类业务的子公司,即互助储蓄公司和斯科特-费泽金融公司;以及(4)一个“其他”类别,包括板块(2)中各公司持有的非经营性资产(主要是可交易证券)、所有购买价格会计调整,以及西科金融和伯克希尔母公司的各项资产与负债。

如果把这四个板块的盈利和净资产加总,得出的数字会与我们在 GAAP 报表上呈现的总额一致。不过我想强调,这种四分类列示并不在审计师的审核范围之内,他们对此未做任何背书。

除了已报告盈利之外,我们还从被投资公司获得可观收益,而标准会计规则不允许我们把这部分盈利列入报表。在第 15 页,我们列出了五家主要被投资公司,1989 年我们从这五家公司收到的股息约为 4500 万美元(税后)。然而,我们享有的这些被投资公司的留存收益,去年合计约 2.12 亿美元,这还不包括 GEICO 和可口可乐实现的大额资本利得。若将这 2.12 亿美元分配给我们,在缴纳额外税款之后,我们自身的经营利润将接近 5 亿美元,而非表格中所示的 3 亿美元。

你必须判断的问题是:这些未分配利润对我们来说,是否与我们已报告的那部分盈利一样有价值。我们的判断是——它们是有同等价值的;甚至认为它们可能更有价值。我们得出“林中两只鸟未必抵得上手中一只鸟”这一结论的原因在于:被投资公司留存的收益,将由才华横溢、以股东利益为导向的管理者去配置,在某些时候,对他们自己的业务而言,这笔资金在他们手中能比在我们手中发挥更好的用途。对于大多数管理层,我不会做出这样的评价,但用在这几个案例中是恰当的。

在我们看来,衡量伯克希尔根本盈利能力的最佳方式是采用“透视盈余”方法:在不计入资本利得的前提下,把我们享有的被投资公司留存的经营利润,追加到我们自身报告的经营利润中。欲使我们的内在业务价值以每年平均 15% 的速度增长,我们的“透视盈余”就必须以大致相同的速度增长。为达到这一 15% 的目标,我们既需要现有被投资公司提供大量助力,也需要不时新增一家被投资公司。

非保险业务

过去,我们把主要的制造、出版和零售业务统称为“七圣徒”。随着 1989 年初收购波仙珠宝(Borsheim's),我们面临的挑战是,要找到一个既有头韵又贴切的名称。我们失败了:姑且把这个群体称为“七圣徒加一”吧。

这个神圣的组合——波仙珠宝、《布法罗新闻》、费奇海默兄弟、科贝尔、内布拉斯加家具城、斯科特-费泽制造集团、喜诗糖果、世界图书——是一批经济特征从优良到卓越的企业集合,其管理者则属于从卓越到卓越那一类。

这些管理者大多不需要靠工作来谋生;他们出现在球场,是因为他们喜欢打本垒打。而这也正是他们实际所做的事情。他们的合并财务报表(包括一些较小规模业务的财务数据)见第 49 页,这些数据恰恰说明了他们的业绩有多么出色。按历史会计基础计算,这些业务的税后利润平均为权益资本的 57%。而且,取得这一回报没有依赖任何净杠杆:现金及现金等价物与计息负债匹配得宜。每当我逐一道出这些管理者的名字——布拉姆金家族、弗里德曼家族和海尔德曼家族、查克·哈金斯、斯坦·利普西、拉尔夫·谢伊——我所感受到的那份自豪,与米勒·哈金斯在宣布他 1927 年纽约扬基队阵容时必定体验到的激动如出一辙。

four segments. Ve reter vou also to pages 45-51 These correspond he way ha he and rained Berkshies finesian datainto statements for: (1) our insurance operations, with their major investment positions itemized; (2) our help you calculate Berkshire's intrinsic value. Shown on these pages are balance sheets and earnings manufacturing, publishing and retailing businesses, leaving aside certain non-operating assets and are Mutual Savings and Scott Fetzer Financial; and (4) an all-other category that includes the non- purchase-price accounting adjustments; (3) our subsidiaries engaged in finance-type operations, which operating assets (primarily marketable securities) held by the companies in segment (2), all purchase- price accounting adjustments, and various assets and debts of the Wesco and Berkshire parent companies. matching those shown on our GAAP statements. However, I want to emphasize that this four-category If you combine the earnings and net worths of these four segments, you will derive totals presentation does not fall within the purview of our auditors, who in no way bless it. standard accounting rules do not permit us to report. On page 15, we list five major investees from In addition to our reported earnings, we also benefit from significant earnings of investees that which we received dividends in 1989 of about $45 retained earnings of these investees totaled about $212 million last year, not counting large capital million, after taxes. However, our share of the gains realized by GEICO and Coca-Cola. If this $212 million had been distributed to us, our own rather than the $300 million shown in the table. operating earnings, after the payment of additional taxes, would have been close to $500 million as those we report. We believe they are - and even think they may be more valuable. The reason The question you must decide is whether these undistributed earnings are as valuable to us for this a-bird-in-the-bush-may-be-worth-two-in-the-hand conclusion is that earnings retained by these investees will be deployed by talented, owner-oriented managers who sometimes have better uses for these funds in their own businesses than we would have in ours. I would not make such assessment of most managements, but it is appropriate in these cases. in which we append our share of the operating earnings retained by our investees to our own In our view, Berkshire's fundamental earning power is best measured by a "look-through" approach, value to grow at an average of 15% per year, our "look-through" earnings must grow at about reported operating earnings, excluding capital gains in both instances. For our intrinsic business the same pace. We'll need plenty of help from our present investees, and also need to add a new one from time to time, in order to reach this 15% goal. Non-Insurance Operations In the past, we have labeled our major manufacturing, publishing and retail operations "The new title both alliterative and appropriate. We failed: Let's call the group "The Sainted Seven Plus Sainted Seven." With our acquisition of Borsheim's early in 1989, the challenge was to find a One." Furniture Mart, Scott Fetzer Manufacturing Group, See's Candies, World Book - is a collection This divine assemblage — Borsheim's, The Buffalo News, Fechheimer Bros., Kirby, Nebraska of businesses with economic characteristics that range from good to superb. Its managers range from superb to superb. they like to hit home runs. And that's exactly what they do. Their combined financial statements Most of these managers have no need to work for a living; they show up at the ballpark because (including those of some smaller operations), shown on page 49, illustrate just how outstanding their performance is. On an historical accounting basis, after-tax earnings of these operations were have matched funded debt. When I call off the names of our managers - the Blumkin, Friedman 57% on average equity capital. Moreover, this return was achieved with no net leverage: Cash equivalents and Heldman families, Chuck Huggins, Stan Lipsey, and Ralph Schey - I feel the same glow that Miller Huggins must have experienced when he announced the lineup of his 1927 New York Yankees. 8

[第 11 页]

[PAGE 11]

我们逐项业务来看:

• 波仙珠宝在被伯克希尔收购的第一年就全面达到预期。销售额显著增长。在迁至现址后的六年里,销售额现在比四年前迁店时好一倍还不止。在迁店之前,销售额也已经翻倍了。波仙的经营管理天才——我这话是认真的——只有一个速度:快进。如果你没去过那里,你就从未见过像波仙这样的珠宝店。因为它在一个地点做巨大的生意,所以能够在所有价格区间维持极其丰富的选择。同样道理,它能把费用率控制在其他提供类似商品的珠宝店的三分之一左右。这种对费用的严格控制,加上其不同寻常的购买力,使它能够提供远低于其他珠宝商的价格。这些低价反过来又带来更大的销量,如此循环往复。最终结果是,在季节性繁忙的日子里,客流量高达 4000 人。我们购买这家企业时没有审计,但所有意外都是好的方面。艾克·弗里德曼不仅是一位卓越的商人、一位伟大的表演家,而且是一位正直的人。“如果你不懂珠宝,就懂你的珠宝商”——这句话无论对你买下整家企业,还是买一颗小小的钻石,都讲得通。

有一个故事可以说明我为什么如此喜欢艾克:每两年我会参加一个非正式团体,聚在一起玩并探讨一些话题。去年九月,我们在圣达菲的毕晓普小屋开会时,邀请艾克、他妻子罗兹和他儿子艾伦过来,给我们讲讲珠宝和珠宝生意。艾克决定让大伙开开眼,所以从奥马哈带来了大约 2000 万美元的特别高档货。我有点担心——毕晓普小屋可不是诺克斯堡——我在他演示前一晚的开幕派对上把我的担心告诉了艾克。艾克把我拉到一边。“看到那个保险柜了吗?”他说。“今天下午我们改了密码,现在连酒店管理层都不知道是什么了。”我松了口气。艾克继续说:“看到那两个腰上别着枪的大个子了吗?他们会整夜守着保险柜。”我现在准备好回去参加派对了。但艾克凑近了些:“而且,沃伦,”他悄悄告诉我,“珠宝不在保险柜里。”有这样的人当我们的合作伙伴,我们怎么可能失手——尤其是他还带着一个能干又精力充沛的家族团队:艾伦、马文·科恩和唐·耶鲁。

• 在喜诗糖果,即便 1988 年已经是创纪录的一年,我们还是实现了 8% 的销量增长。在 1989 年的业绩中,包含了多年来首次出现的出色的同店磅数增长。广告宣传在这个出色的表现中发挥了重要作用。我们将广告总支出从 400 万美元增加到 500 万美元。我们的广告代理商哈尔·里尼合伙公司的文案也百分之百精准地传达了让喜诗与众不同的特质。在我们媒体业务,比如《布法罗新闻》,我们是出售广告。在喜诗这样的其他业务里,我们是广告买家。在购买时,我们践行了出售时所宣扬的理念。在喜诗,我们去年将报纸广告支出增加了两倍多,达到了我记忆中占总销售额比例最高的水平。回报非常出色,我们感谢哈尔·里尼以及方向正确的报纸广告的力量,它们带来了这样的成果。

喜诗的杰出表现已成家常便饭。但查克·哈金斯的经营管理绝非常事。他每天参与生产和销售的方方面面,向我们需要雇用来每年生产和分销超过 2700 万磅糖果的数千名员工传递一种质量和服务的信息。在一家拥有 225 家门店以及大量邮购和电话业务的公司里,要把事情管理得几乎让每位顾客都满意而归,绝非易事。查克让它看起来轻轻松松。

• 内布拉斯加家具城在 1989 年取得创纪录的销售额和优异的利润,但有一件令人遗憾的事。52 年前以 500 美元创办这家公司的 B 夫人——罗丝·布拉姆金——辞职了,原因是她与布拉姆金家族/管理层其他成员在地毯部门的装修和运营问题上存在分歧。

Let's take a look, business by business: • In its first year with Berkshire, Borsheim's met all expectations. Sales rose significantly and to its present location. In the six years are now considerably better than twice what they were four years ago when the company moved Borsheim's managing genius - and I mean that - has only one speed: fast-forward. prior to the move, sales had also doubled. Ike Friedman, huge volume it does If you haven't been there, you've never seen a jewelry store like Borsheim's. Because of the ranges. For the same at one location, the store can maintain an enormous selection across all price jewelry stores offering comparable merchandise. The reason, it can hold its expense ratio to about one-third that prevailing at by its unusual buying power, enable it to offer prices far lower than those of other jewelers. These store's tight control of expenses, accompanied result is store traffic as high as 4,000 people on seasonally-busy days. prices, in turn, generate even more volume, and so the circle goes 'round and 'round. The end We bought the business without an audit, Ike Friedman is not only a superb businessman and a great showman but also a man of integrity. "If you don't know jewelry, know your jeweler" makes sense whether you are buying the whole all of our surprises have been on the plus side. business or a tiny diamond. that gathers to have fun and explore a few subjects. Last September, meeting at Bishop's Lodge A story will illustrate why I enjoy Ike so much: Every two years I'm part of an informal group in Santa Fe, we asked Ike, his wife Roz, and his son Alan to come by and educate us on jewels and the jewelry business. fancy merchandise. I was somewhat apprehensive - Bishop's Lodge is no Fort Knox - and I Ike decided to dazzle the group, so he brought from Omaha about $20 million of particularly me aside. "See that safe?" he said. "This afternoon we changed the combination and now even mentioned my concern to Ike at our opening party the evening before his presentation. Ike took the hotel management doesn't know what it is." I breathed easier. Ike went on: "See those two big fellows with guns on their hips? They'll be guarding the safe all night." I now was ready to rejoin the party. But Ike leaned closer: "And besides, Warren," he confided, "the jewels aren't in the safe." talented and energetic family, Alan, Marvin Cohn, and Don Yale. How can we miss with a fellow like that — particularly when he comes equipped with a • At See's Candies we had an 8% increase in pounds sold, even though 1988 was itself a record year. Included in the 1989 performance were excellent same-store poundage gains, our first in many years. tising expenditures from $4 million to $5 million and also got copy from our agency, Hal Riney Advertising played an important role in this outstanding performance. We increased total adver- & Partners, Inc., that was 100% on the money in conveying the qualities that make See's special. Pao he, that was 10%, In our media businesses, such as the Buffalo News, we sell advertising. In other businesses, such as See's, we are buyers. When At See's, we more than tripled our expenditures on newspaper advertising last year, to the highest we buy, we practice exactly what we preach when we sell. percentage of sales that I can remember. The payoff was terrific, and we thank both Hal Riney and the power of well-directed newspaper advertising for this result. of Chuck Huggins: His daily involvement with all aspects of production and sales imparts a quality- See's splendid performances have become routine. But there is nothing routine about the management and-service message to the thousands of employees we need to produce and distribute over 27 phone business, it is no small trick to run things so that virtually every customer leaves happy. million pounds of candy annually. In a company with 225 shops and a massive mail order and Chuck makes it look easy. • The Nebraska Furniture Mart had record sales and excellent earnings in 1989, but there was in May, after disagreeing with other members of the Blumkin family/management about the one sad note. Mrs. B- Rose Blumkin, who started the company 52 years ago with $500 - quit remodeling and operation of the carpet department. 9

[第 12 页]

[PAGE 12]

你会很高兴地知道,B 夫人仍在继续让霍雷肖·阿尔杰笔下的英雄看起来像是疲劳贫血症的受害者。她在 96 岁高龄时又开了一家新店,卖什么?——还是地毯和家具。而且一如既往,她每周工作七天。

在家具城,路易、罗恩和欧文·布拉姆金继续推动着这家全国规模最大、最成功的家居用品店向前发展。他们是杰出的商人、杰出的管理者,与他们共事令人愉快。从他们的精明程度可见一斑:1989 年第四季度,地毯部门在奥马哈市场的消费者份额达到 75.3%,高于上年同期。

内布拉斯加家具城和波仙珠宝遵循着完全相同的成功公式:(1)在单一地点提供无与伦比的商品深度与广度;(2)行业内最低的运营成本;(3)最精明的采购,部分得益于巨大的采购量;(4)毛利和由此产生的价格远低于竞争对手;(5)友好的个性化服务,家族成员随时在场。

奥马哈是唯一一个由家居用品店占据广告投放榜首的城市。许多零售商在 1989 年削减了广告版面采购;我们在喜诗糖果和内布拉斯加家具城的经验表明,他们犯了一个重大错误。

• 《布法罗新闻》在 1989 年继续在三个方面表现突出:首先,在所有大都市报纸中,无论是平日版还是周日版,《新闻报》的家庭渗透率——即当地家庭每天购买该报的百分比——都位居第一。其次,在“新闻版面”——报纸用于新闻而非广告的部分——所占比例方面,《新闻报》位居前二十名,使其新闻内容比任何同类美国报纸都更为丰富。第三,在许多大报利润下滑的这一年,《新闻报》连续第七年创下利润纪录。

在某种程度上,这三方面是相互关联的,尽管高比例的新闻版面本身会显著降低利润。然而,一个容量大且编排合理的新闻版面能吸引广泛的读者群,从而提高渗透率。高渗透率反过来又使报纸对零售商特别有价值,因为它能让他们通过一个“扩音器”与整个社区对话。一份低渗透率的报纸对许多广告客户来说吸引力要小得多,并最终会在广告费率和利润上受到损害。

需要强调的是,我们出色的渗透率既非偶然,也非自动得来。《新闻报》的主场伊利县人口一直在下降——从 1970 年的 111.3 万人降至 1980 年的 101.5 万人,再到 1988 年的估计 96.6 万人。但发行量数据却呈现出不同的情况。1975 年,在我们推出周日版之前不久,一份历史悠久的布法罗报纸《信使快报》在伊利县的周日销量为 20.75 万份。去年——在人口至少下降 5% 的情况下——《新闻报》的平均销量达到了 29.27 万份。我相信,在美国其他任何主要的周日市场,都没有出现过在渗透率增长上能与此接近的情况。

当取得这样的成就——并且当一份报纸在其本地获得无与伦比的认可度时——说明有人做对了。在这个案例中,主要功劳显然属于我们的长期编辑默里·莱特,他每天都能打造出一份信息丰富、实用且有趣的产品。功劳也应归功于发行部和生产部:一份报纸如果因为生产问题或发行缺陷而经常迟到,无论其编辑内容如何优秀,都会失去客户。

more merchandise than any other salesperson in the store). victims of tired blood. At age 96 she has started a new business selling - what else? - carpet You will be pleased to know that Mrs. B continues to make Horatio Alger's heroes look like and furniture. And as always, she works seven days a week. most successful home furnishings store in the country. They are outstanding merchants, outstanding At the Mart Louie, Ron, and Irv Blumkin continue to propel what is by far the largest and of 1989, the carpet department registered a 75.3% consumer share in the Omaha market, up from managers, and a joy to be associated with. One reading on their acumen: In the fourth quarter breadth of merchandise at one location; (2) the lowest operating costs in the business; (3) the shrewdest NFM and Borsheim's follow precisely the same formula for success: (1) unparalleled depth and of buying, made possible in part by the huge volumes purchased; (4) gross margins, and therefore prices, far below competitors'; and (5) friendly personalized service with family members on hand at all times. is the only city in which a home furnishings store is the advertising leader. Many retailers cut space purchases in 1989; our experience at See's and NFM would indicate they made a major • The Buffalo News continued to star in 1989 in three important ways: First, among major metropolitan papers, both daily and Sunday, the News is number one in household penetration - the percentage of local households that purchase it each day. Second, in "news hole" - the portion of the paper it more news-rich than any comparable American paper. Third, in a year that saw profits slip at many major papers, the News set its seventh consecutive profit record. To some extent, these three factors are related, though obviously a high-percentage news hole, by itself, reduces profits significantly. A large and intelligently-utilized news hole, however, attracts a wide spectrum of readers and thereby boosts penetration. High penetration, in turn, makes a newspaper particularly valuable to retailers since it allows them to talk to the entire community through a and will eventually suffer in both ad rates and profits. single "megaphone." A low-penetration paper is a far less compelling purchase for many advertisers The population of Erie County, home territory of the News, has been falling - from 1,113,000 It should be emphasized that our excellent penetration is neither an accident nor automatic. in 1970 to 1,015,000 in 1980 to an story. In 1975, shortly before we started our Sunday edition, the Courier-Express, a long-established estimated 966,000 in 1988. Circulation figures tell a different Buffalo paper, was selling 207,500 Sunday copies in Erie County. Last year - with population at least 5% lower - the News sold an average of 292,700 copies. I believe that in no other major Sunday market has there been anything close to that increase in penetration. in its home town - someone is doing something right. In this case major credit clearly belongs When this kind of gain is made - and when a paper attains an unequaled degree of acceptance to Murray Light, our long-time editor who daily creates an informative, useful, and interesting product. late, because of production problems or distribution weaknesses, will lose customers, no matter how Credit should go also to the Circulation and Production Departments: A paper that is frequently its editorial content. 10

[第 13 页]

[PAGE 13]

我认为斯坦的管理能力至少能为利润率带来五个百分点的额外收益。《新闻报》的出版人斯坦·利普西创造的利润,完全配得上我们产品的实力。相比之下,换成一般管理者在同样条件下,根本做不到这个水平。这堪称惊人的表现,只有一位对业务的一钉一铆都了如指掌、并且全心投入的天才管理者才能做到。

需要强调的是,斯坦的知识和才华同样延伸到编辑产品。他早年职业生涯专注于新闻业务,曾主导和编辑了一系列报道,并在 1972 年为奥马哈的《太阳报》赢得了普利策奖。我找不到更好的搭档了。斯坦和我共事超过 20 年,经历过顺境也经历过逆境。

• 在费奇海默,赫尔德曼家族——鲍勃、乔治、加夫、罗杰和弗雷德——继续着他们的非凡表现。1989 年利润略有下降,原因是公司在整合 1988 年的一笔重大收购时遇到了一些问题。这些问题会随着时间推移而解决。与此同时,费奇海默的投入资本回报率依然出色。

与我们所有的管理者一样,赫尔德曼家族对业务细节了如指掌。在去年的股东大会上我提到过,当一名囚犯进入圣昆廷监狱,鲍勃和乔治大概连他的衬衫尺码都知道。这毫不夸张:无论讨论到国家的哪个地区,他们都清楚主要客户和竞争对手的最新动向。

尽管我们四年前就收购了费奇海默,查理和我从未去过它的任何工厂或辛辛那提总部。我们就像那则经典广告中寂寞的梅塔格修理工:赫尔德曼家族的管理产品太出色了,根本不需要上门服务。

• 拉尔夫·谢伊继续出色地管理着我们最大的集团——世界图书、卡比以及斯科特-费泽制造公司。这些业务的合计利润自我们收购以来年年增长,投入资本回报率也一直出类拔萃。拉尔夫管理的企业如果独立运营,规模足以跻身《财富》世界 500 强。而且,他经营的方式如果按净资产收益率衡量,能让他稳居前十分位的顶尖位置。

多年来,世界图书一直集中在芝加哥商品市场大厦的单一地点运营。由于租约即将到期,该业务如今正分散到四个地点。这场搬迁的费用不小;尽管如此,1989 年利润仍保持良好。搬迁成本完全消化还需要一年时间。

卡比的业务去年尤其强劲,出口销售大幅增长。国际业务在过去两年翻了一倍多,过去四年翻了四倍;其销量占比从 5% 上升到 20%。我们 1989 年最大的一笔资本支出就在卡比,用于为 1990 年的大改款做准备。

这些业务为伯克希尔创造了资金,进而让我们得以进行许多其他利润丰厚的投资。这正是我们对 1927 年洋基队的回应。

I believe Stan's managerial skills deliver at least five extra percentage points in profit margin compared Stan Lipsey, publisher of the News, has produced profits fully up to the strength of our product. to the earnings that would be achieved by an average manager given the same circumstances. is an amazing performance, and one that could only be produced by a talented manager who knows

  • and cares - about every nut and bolt of the business.

early years in the business were Stan's knowledge and talents, it should be emphasized, extend to the editorial product. His and editing a series of stories that in 1972 won a Pulitzer Prize for the Sun Newspaper of Omaha. spent on the news side and he played a key role in developing I could not ask for a better partner. Stan and I have worked together for over 20 years, through some bad times as well as good, and • At Fechheimer, the Heldman clan - Bob, George, Garv, Roger and Fred - continue their ex experienced aordinary pertormance. Pronts in 1989 were down somewhat because of problems the busines. Meanwhile, return on invested capital in integrating a major 1988 acquisition. These problems will be ironed out in time. at Fechheimer remains splendid. business. At last year's annual meeting I mentioned that when a prisoner enters San Quentin, Bob Like all of our managers, the Heldmans have an exceptional command of the details of their of the country is being discussed, they know exactly what is going on with major customers and and George probably know his shirt size. That's only a slight exaggeration: No matter what area with the competition. plants or the home office in Cincinnati. We're much like the lonesome Maytag repairman: The Though we purchased Fechheimer four years ago, Charlie and I have never visited any of its Heldman managerial product is so good that a service call is never needed. • Ralph Schey continues to do a superb job in managing our largest group — World Book, Kirby, and the Scott Fetzer Manufacturing Companies. Aggregate earnings of these businesses have increased is running an enterprise large enough, were it standing alone, to be on the Fortune 500. And he's every year since our purchase and returns on invested capital continue to be exceptional. Ralph running it in a fashion that would put him high in the top decile, measured by return on equity. Mart. Anticipating the imminent expiration of its lease, the business is now decentralizing into For some years, World Book has operated out of a single location in Chicago's Merchandise well. It will be another year before costs of the move are fully behind us. four locations. The expenses of this transition are significant; nevertheless profits in 1989 held up business has more than doubled in the last two years and quintupled in the past four; its share Kirby's business was particularly strong last year, featuring large gains in export sales. International of unit sales has risen from 5% to 20%. Our largest capital expenditures in 1989 were at Kirby, in preparation for a major model change in 1990. have produced funds for Berkshire that, in turn, have allowed us to make many other profitable And that completes our answer to the 1927 Yankees. 11

[第 14 页]

[PAGE 14]

保险业务

财产险行业:

下表是我们通常提供的关键数据表的更新版本,展示了财产险行业的主要数据:

年份保费收入法定增长 (%)综合成本率(含保单分红后)综合成本率年度变化已发生损失通胀率 (%)国民生产总值平减指数 (%)
19823.8————————
1983——————————
19843.7106.05.0109.66.5
198522.1112.08.49.66.8
198622.2118.03.86.53.8
19879.4116.316.93.8——
198816.1108.04.4————
1989 (估计值)2.6104.613.5————
1990 (估计值)3.0110.42.1————
1991 (估计值)3.1105.47.8————
1992 (估计值)4.2————————

来源:A.M. Best 公司

综合成本率代表总保险成本(已发生损失加费用)与保费收入的比较:比率低于 100 意味着承保利润,高于 100 则表示承保亏损。当考虑到保险公司持有投保人资金(“浮存金”)所产生的投资收益时,综合成本率在 107-111 的范围内通常会产生盈亏平衡的结果——这还不包括股东提供的资金所产生的收益。

基于以往报告中阐述的原因,我们预期该行业的已发生损失将以每年约 10% 的速度增长——即使在总体通胀率低得多的年份也是如此。(实际上,在过去 25 年里,已发生损失的增长速度更快,达到 11%。)如果保费增长在此期间大幅落后于那个 10% 的增长率,承保亏损将会上升——尽管该行业在业务变糟时倾向于少提储备,这种倾向可能会掩盖亏损的真实程度。

去年我们说过,综合成本率的上升“几乎肯定会继续——并且可能会加速——至少还要持续两年。”今年我们不会预测会加速,但除此之外,必须重复去年的预测。保费增长目前远低于所需的每年 10% 的增长率。记住,10% 的增长率只能稳定综合成本率,并不能让它下降。

1989 年综合成本率的上升幅度比我们预期的要大一些,原因是巨灾(主要是飓风雨果)异常严重。这些异常事件大概导致了其中两个百分点的上升。如果 1990 年算是一个比较“正常”的年份,综合成本率应该会从 1989 年被巨灾推高的基数上仅略微上升。不过,到了 1991 年,该比率很可能会以更大的幅度攀升。

评论员们经常讨论这一主题,但他们的讨论常常暴露出对该行业基本经济状况的错误思考。这个说法在几十年前是合适的,当时该行业和监管机构合作,以卡特尔的方式开展业务。那时,综合成本率会有节奏地波动——因为错误定价的保单需要相当长的时间才能到期——这延缓了新定价带来的影响。

Insurance Operations casually insurance industry: Shown below is an updated version of our usual table presenting key figures for the property- Yearly Change Statutory in Premiums Combined Ratio Yearly Change Written (%) After Policyholder Dividends in Incurred Inflation Rate Losses (%) GNP Deflator (%) Measured by 1982 1981 3.8 1984 1983 3.7 106.0 5.0 109.6 6.5 1986 1985 22.1 8.5 112.0 8.4 9.6 118.0 6.8 3.8 6.5 1988 1987 22.2 116.3 16.9 3.8 9.4 108.0 16.1 1989 (Est.). 4.4 104.6 13.5 2.6 3.0 2.1 110.4 105.4 7.8 8.7 5.5 3.3 3.1 4.2 Source: A.M. Best Co. to revenue from premiums: A ratio below 100 indicates an underwriting profit, and one above 100 The combined ratio represents total insurance costs (losses incurred plus expenses) compared funds ("the float") is taken into account, a combined ratio in the 107-111 range typically produces indicates a loss. When the investment income that an insurer earns from holding policyholders' an overall breakeven result, exclusive of earnings on the funds provided by shareholders. by about 10% annually, even in years when general For the reasons laid out in previous reports, we expect the industry's incurred losses to grow over the last 25 years, incurred losses have grown at a still faster rate, 11%.) If premium growth inflation runs considerably lower. (Actually, to under-reserve when business turns bad may obscure meanwhile materially lags that 10% rate, underwriting losses will mount, though the industry's tendency Last year we said the climb in the combined ratio probably will accelerate — for at least two more years." This year we will not predict accel- was "almost certain to continue - and eration, but otherwise must repeat last year's forecast. Premium growth 10% required annually. Remember also that a 10% rate would only stabilize the combined ratio, 1s running far below the not bring it down. catastrophes (led by Hurricane Hugo) were unusually severe. These abnormalities probably accounted The increase in the combined ratio in 1989 was a little more than we had expected because for about two points of the increase. If 1990 is more of a "normal" year, the combined ratio should to climb by a greater degree. rise only minimally from the catastrophe-swollen base of 1989. In 1991, though, the ratio is apt If that men to us fd to enly die is the guderesit is in and spears amer that let du o Commentators frequently discuss faulty thinking about the industry's fundamental economics. conduct the business in cartel fashion. At that time, the combined ratio fluctuated rhythmically The term was appropriate some decades ago when the industry and regulators cooperated to for two that it took a considerable time for mispriced policies to expire - delayed the impact of new 12

[第 15 页]

[PAGE 15]

而如今,由于缺乏显著的价格竞争,整个行业在一个完整周期里的平均利润还算令人满意。卡特尔时期早已远去。如今,行业中有数百家参与者,以独立制定的价格,销售一种同质化产品。这种格局——无论销售的是钢铁还是保单——在所有情况下都注定会导致低于正常水平的盈利能力,唯有一种情况例外:可用产能出现短缺。而产能短缺时期发生的频次与持续时长,决定了相关行业的平均盈利能力。

在绝大多数行业中,产能用物理指标描述。然而在保险领域,产能通常用财务指标描述;也就是说,通常认为一家公司若有 Y 美元的净资产,只适合承保不超过 X 美元的业务。但在实践中,此类约束已被证明收效甚微。监管机构、保险经纪商和客户,均迟迟不对那些过度消耗自身资源的公司加以约束。当公司严重夸大真实资本时,他们也予以默许。于是,一家公司只需极少真实资本,便可承接大量业务。

理解了这一切,就不难预测行业的利润。良好的利润只有在产能短缺时才会实现。而产能短缺只有在保险公司感到恐惧时才会到来。这种情况极少发生——当下更是确定无疑地没有发生。一些分析师认为,近期对保险业加征的更高税负,以及 1989 年的巨灾——飓风雨果与加州地震——将促使费率大幅走强。我们不同意此观点。这些不利因素并未浇灭保险公司以当前费率承保业务的急切心态。因此,1990 年保费收入不会增长 10%,这意味着承保亏损的趋势不会逆转。只有费率攀升到令保险公司胆寒,以至于虽然费率更高,它们仍纷纷拒接业务时,局面才会好转。而我们离那个临界点还差得很远。

伯克希尔 1990 年的保费收入可能降至 1.5 亿美元左右(自 1986 年 10 亿美元的高点回落),部分原因在于我们传统业务持续萎缩,部分原因在于我们依据合同承保消防员基金保险(Fireman's Fund)7% 业务的安排于去年 8 月到期。不过,无论保费规模大小,我们只承保我们相信存在盈利期望的保单;我们在自认为有望盈利的交易中已遭遇了足够多的失望,无意再做预期亏损的买卖。然而,我们对定价合理的业务胃口很大,1989 年的一则故事即可说明。它涉及“巨灾再保险”(CAT covers),即原保险公司为保护自身免受大额损失而购买的一种再保险合同。原保险公司会先自行承担某一自留额,并为超出部分购买多层再保险。当损失超过自留额时,再保险公司通常支付超出部分(最高至合同限额)的 95%,原保险公司支付剩余部分。(要求原保险公司在每一层中自留 5%,是为了使其在每一次损失理赔中均保留财务利害关系,防止其挥霍再保险公司的资金。)

巨灾再保险通常是一年期保单,并附有一次自动恢复条款:若原保险公司的保额因一次巨灾而耗竭,可通过再支付一笔保费,为该年度剩余时间购买第二份保障。该条款保护原保险公司,使其在首次巨灾事件后不至于出现哪怕是很短时间的“裸露”状态。“一次事件”的持续时间,通常由合同限定为原保险公司指定的任意一个连续 72 小时。据此定义,一场由单一气候原因引发、持续三日造成损害的大范围风暴,将被归类为一次单一事件。如果风暴持续四天,原保险公司则会提出索赔,从中划出损失最严重的那段连续 72 小时。

averaged out current. Meanwhile, the absence of over the cycle, would be satisfactory. significant price competition guaranteed that industry profits, like product at independently-established prices. Such a configuration - whether the product being The cartel period is long gone. Now the industry has hundreds of participants selling a commodity- sold is steel or insurance policies — is certain to cause subnormal profitability in all circumstances determines the but one: a shortage of usable capacity. Just how often these periods occur and how long they last average profitability of the industry in question. In most industries, capacity is described in physical terms. In the insurance world, however, to write no more than X dollars of business if it has Y dollars of net worth. In practice, however, capacity is customarily described in financial terms; that is, it's considered appropriate for a company all slow to discipline companies that strain their resources. constraints of this sort have proven ineffective. Regulators, insurance brokers, and customers are grossly overstate their true capital. Hence, a company can write a great deal of business with very They also acquiesce when companies will be realized only when there is a shortage of capacity. Shortages will occur only when insurers All this understood, it is not very difficult to prognosticate the industry's profits. Good profits are frightened. That happens rarely - and most assuredly is not happening now. and 1989's catastrophes — Hurricane Hugo and the California earthquake — will cause prices to Some analysts have argued that the more onerous taxes recently imposed on the insurance industry strengthen significantly. We disagree. These adversities have not destroyed the eagerness of insurers to write business at present prices. Therefore, premium volume won't grow by 10% in 1990, which means the negative underwriting trend will not reverse. a orde higher to to shee potably sa ching the turning away business despite higher prices. And we're a long way from that point. determine are in 1986), partly because our traditional business continues to shrink and partly because the contract Berkshire's premium volume may drop to $150 million or so in 1990 (from a high of $1 billion under which we received 7% of the business of Fireman's Fund expired last August. Whatever believe to carry an expectation of profit. a mathematical expectation of loss; we experience enough disappointments doing transactions we tell. It concerns "CAT covers," which are reinsurance contracts that primary insurance companies However, our appetite for appropriately-priced business is ample, as one tale from 1989 will buying various layers of reinsurance above that level. When losses exceed the retained amount, payıng the remainder. (By requiring the primary insurer to keep 5% of each layer, the reinsurer the reinsurer typically pays 95% of the excess up to its contractual limit, with the primary insurer leaves him with a financial stake in each loss settlement and guards against his throwing away india fake in each lass intume te the reinsurer's money.) requires a primary insurer whose coverage has been exhausted by a catastrophe to buy a second CAT covers are usually one-year policies that also provide for one automatic reinstatement, which cover for the balance of the year in question by paying another premium. This provision protects the primary company from being "bare" for even a brief period after a first catastrophic event. the primary company. Under this definition, a wide-spread storm, causing damage for three days, The duration of "an event" is usually limited by contract to any span of 72 hours designated by will be classified as a single event if it arises from a single climatic cause. If the storm lasts four days, however, the primary company will file a claim carving out the 72 consecutive hours during 13

[第 16 页]

[PAGE 16]

1989 年发生了两件不寻常的事。首先,飓风“雨果”造成了 40 亿美元或更多的保险损失,其强度之大,使得卡罗来纳地区的严重损害,在加勒比地区遭受同等严重破坏之后,稍晚一些——超过 72 小时——才发生。其次,加利福尼亚的地震在数周内来袭,造成的保险损失即使在事件发生很久之后,也难以估算。遭受这两次——或者可能三次——重大巨灾的打击,一些直接保险公司,以及许多自行购买了巨灾再保险保护的再保险公司,要么用尽了其自动续保额度,要么不确定自己是否已经用尽。在那一刻,巨灾再保险保单的出售方已经损失了巨额资金——可能损失了双倍的巨灾保费收入,使得大多数巨灾再保险承保人舔舐伤口。但正因为 1989 年的灾难让许多保险公司要么确实脱保,要么可能脱保,同时也因为巨灾再保险承保人自身购买的再保险(即巨灾再保险承保人购买的保护)出现了立即短缺,因此市面上急需大量的巨灾再保险保障。价格立刻变得具有吸引力,特别是对于巨灾再保险承保人自身购买的再保险而言。几乎同时,伯克希尔·哈撒韦提出愿意承保高达 2.5 亿美元的巨灾再保险,并在行业刊物上刊登了这则广告。尽管我们没有完全写出我们寻求的所有业务,但在繁忙的十天内,我们确实获得了可观的业务量。我们愿意为可能明天就发生的损失承担如此巨额的资金,这使我们有别于世界上任何一家再保险公司。当然,有些公司有时也能承保 2.5 亿美元甚至更多的巨灾再保险。但他们这样做,只有在能够反过来将大部分业务向其他公司进行再分保(“转分保”)时才可行。当他们无法“转分保”规模巨大的业务时,他们就从市场上消失了。相反,伯克希尔的政策是保留我们承保的业务,而不是将其转分保出去。当保费水平有望带来利润时,我们希望承担尽可能多的、审慎的风险。而在我们的情况下,这个量很大。我们根本不在乎我们每季度,甚至每年报告多少利润,只要导致这些利润(或亏损)的决策是明智地做出的。显然,如果我们承保了 2.5 亿美元的巨灾再保险并全数自留,那么我们在一个季度内损失全部 2.5 亿美元的可能性是存在的。这种可能性很低,但并非为零。如果我们遭受如此规模的损失,我们的税后成本大约为 1.65 亿美元。虽然这远高于伯克希尔通常一个季度的盈利,但损失只会打击我们的自尊心,而不会影响我们的财务健康。这种姿态是很少有保险公司管理层会采取的。通常,他们愿意承保大量业务,而这些业务的条款几乎保证了平庸的净资产收益率。但他们不愿意让自己暴露于一个尴尬的单季度亏损面前,即使导致亏损的管理策略,从长远来看,有望产生卓越的成果。我能理解他们的想法:对其所有者最有利的,未必对管理者最有利。幸运的是,查理和我都拥有完全的工作保障,以及与我们股东利益完全一致的经济利益。只要我们觉得自己没有做出愚蠢的行为,我们愿意在别人看来显得愚蠢。我们的经营方式,顺便说一下,使我们成为行业中的一个稳定力量。当市场承保能力短缺时,我们加入巨大的承保能力;只有当承保能力充裕时,我们的竞争力才会减弱。当然,我们遵循这项政策并非为了稳定市场——我们遵循它是因为我们认为这是最明智、最有利可图的行动方针。尽管如此,我们的行为确实稳定了市场。在这种情况下,亚当·斯密的“看不见的手”如约发挥了作用。

which it suffered the greatest damage. Losses that occurred outside that period will be treated as arising from a separate event. insured loss, at a pace, however, that caused the vast damage in the Carolinas to occur slightly In 1989, two unusual things happened. First, Hurricane Hugo generated $4 billion or more of more than 72 hours quake hit within weeks, causing insured damage that was difficult to after the equally severe damage in the Caribbean. Second, the California earth- event. Slammed by these two - or possibly three - major catastrophes, some primary insurers, estimate, even well after the second cover or became uncertain as to whether they had done so. and also many reinsurers that had themselves bought CAT protection, either used up their automatic At that point sellers of CAT policies had lost a huge amount of money - perhaps twice because a CAT premium some years, we've thought premiums of that kind inadequate and have stayed away from the business. left most CAT writers licking their wounds, there was an immediate shortage after the earthquake But because the 1989 disasters left many insurers either actually or possibly bare, and also that CAT writers themselves buy. Just as instantly, Berkshire Hathaway offered to write up to $250 of much-needed catastrophe coverage. Prices instantly became attractive, particularly for the reinsurance million of catastrophe coverage, advertising that proposition in trade publications. Though we did not write all the business we sought, we did in a busy ten days book a substantial amount. sets us apart from any reinsurer Our willingness to put such a huge sum on the line for a loss that could occur tomorrow write $250 million or even far more of catastrophe coverage. But they do so only when they can, in the world. There are, of course, companies that sometimes off" in size, they disappear from the market. in turn, reinsure a large percentage of the business with other companies. When they can't "lay rates carry an expectation of profit, we want to assume as much risk as is prudent. And in our Berkshire's policy, conversely, is to retain the business we write rather than lay it off. When case, that's a lot. companies of about $6 billion — the second highest amount in the United States; and (2) we simply to those earnings (or losses) were reached intelligently. don't care what earnings we report quarterly, or even annually, just as long as the decisions leading is some probability that we will lose the full $250 million in a single quarter. That probability Obviously, if we write $250 million of catastrophe coverage and retain it all ourselves, there is low, but it is not zero. If we had a loss of that magnitude, our after-tax cost would be about be a blow only to our pride, not to our well-being. $165 million. Though that is far more than Berkshire normally earns in a quarter, the damage would write scads of business on terms that almost guarantee them mediocre returns on equity. But they This posture is one few insurance managements will assume. Typically, they are willing to do not want to expose themselves to an embarrassing single-quarter loss, even if the managerial their thinking: What is best for their owners is not necessarily best for the managers. Fortunately strategy that causes the loss promises, over time, to produce superior results. I can understand Charlie and I have both total job security and financial interests that are identical with those of our shareholders. We are willing to look foolish as long as we don't feel we have acted foolishly. huge capacity when capacity is short and we become less competitive only when capacity is abundant. Our method of operation, incidentally, makes us a stabilizing force in the industry. We add believe it to be the most sensible and profitable course of action. Nevertheless, our behavior steadies Of course, we don't follow this policy in the interest of stabilization — we follow it because we the market. In this case, Adam Smith's invisible hand works as advertised. 14

[第 17 页]

[PAGE 17]

目前我们持有的浮存金相对于保费规模来说异常庞大。这种情况会像 1989 年那样,在未来几年为我们带来相当不错的保险业绩。我们的承保亏损应该可以控制在可承受范围内,而保单持有人资金产生的投资收入将会非常可观。不过,随着浮存金逐渐减少,这种有利局面也会慢慢消退。但在某个时点,我们一定会遇到大规模承保优质业务的机会。迈克·戈德堡和他的管理团队——罗德·埃尔德里德、迪诺斯·约达诺、阿吉特·贾恩、菲尔·厄本和唐·沃斯特——正在为这一局面的到来做好充分准备。

有价证券

在为我们的保险公司选择有价证券时,我们通常会在五大类别中进行挑选:(1)长期普通股投资,(2)中期固定收益证券,(3)长期固定收益证券,(4)短期现金等价物,(5)短期套利承诺。我们的目标与最大化眼前报告利润无关;相反,我们的目标是最大化最终的净资产。

• 下面我们列出价值超过 1 亿美元的普通股持仓。这些投资中有一小部分属于伯克希尔持股不到 100% 的子公司。

股份数公司成本 (000s omitted)市值 12/31/89
23,350,000大都会/美国广播公司$517,500$1,692,375
3,000,000联邦住宅贷款抵押公司$71,729$1,803,787
2,400,000可口可乐公司$1,023,920$1,727,765
6,850,000《华盛顿邮报》公司$45,713$1,044,625
161,100GEICO 公司$9,731$486,366

这份公司名单与去年相同,只有一只股票的持股数发生了变化:可口可乐的持仓从 1988 年底的 14,172,500 股增加到了 23,350,000 股。

我是在 1936 年开始,以六瓶 25 美分的价格从我家的杂货店 Buffett & Son 买进可口可乐,然后以每瓶 5 美分在社区里兜售的。在这段涉足高利润率零售业的经历中,我恰当地观察到了该产品非凡的消费者吸引力和商业潜力。在接下来的 52 年里,我持续注意到这些特质,因为可口可乐席卷了全世界。在此期间,我却刻意避免买入哪怕一股股票,而是将我的大部分净资产配置给了有轨电车公司、风车制造商、无烟煤生产商、纺织企业、印花券发行商和其他类似的生意。(如果你觉得我是在编故事,我可以提供名字。)直到 1988 年夏天,我的大脑才终于和眼睛建立了联系。

我所看到的一切既清晰又迷人。在 20 世纪 70 年代略显迷失之后,随着罗伯托·戈伊苏埃塔在 1981 年出任 CEO,可口可乐变成了一家新公司。罗伯托,以及曾是我在奥马哈的街对面邻居的唐·基奥,首先重新思考并聚焦了公司策略,然后充满活力地予以执行。这本已是全世界最无处不在的产品,如今获得了新的增长动力,海外销售几乎是在爆发。

should produce quite favorable insurance results Currently, we hold an exceptional amount of float compared to premium volume. This circumstance 1989. Our underwriting losses should be tolerable and our investment income from policyholder for us during the next few years as it did in funds large. This pleasant situation, however, will gradually deteriorate as our float runs off. usiness. Mike Goldberg and his management team of Rod Eldred, Dinos lordanou, Ajit Jain, Phi t some point, however, there will be an opportunity for us to write large amounts of profitabl Urban, and Don Wurster continue to position us well for this eventuality. Marketable Securities major categories: (1) long-term common stock investments, (2) medium-term fixed-income securities, In selecting marketable securities for our insurance companies, we generally choose among five (3) long-term commitments. fixed-income securities, (4) short-term cash equivalents, and (5) short-term arbitrage net worth. to do with maximizing immediately reportable earnings; our goal, rather, is to maximize eventual • Below we list our common stock holdings having a value of over $100 million. A small portio f these investments belongs to subsidiaries of which Berkshire owns less than 100% Shares Company Cost 12/31/89 Market 23,350,000 3,000,000 Capital Cities/ABC, Inc. 2,400,000 Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp The Coca-Cola Co.. $ 517,500 (000s omitted) 1,023,920 $1,692,375 71,729 1,803,787 1,727,765 The Washington Post Company.... 6,850,000 GEICO Corp........ 45,713 1,044,625 161,100 9,731 486,366 shares changed: Our holdings of Coca-Cola increased from 14,172,500 shares at the end of 1988 This list of companies is the same as last year's and in only one case has the number of to 23,350,000. that I started buying Cokes at the rate of six for 25¢ from Buffett & Son, the family grocery store, to sell around the neighborhood for 5¢ each. In this excursion into high-margin retailing, I duly observed the extraordinary consumer attractiveness and commercial possibilities of the product. this period, however, I carefully avoided buying even a single share, instead allocating major portions I continued to note these qualities for the next 52 years as Coke blanketed the world. During businesses, trading-stamp issuers, and the like. (If you think I'm making this up, I can supply the of my net worth to street railway companies, windmill manufacturers, anthracite producers, textile names.) Only in the summer of 1988 did my brain finally establish contact with my eyes. Coca-Cola had in 1981 become a new company with the move of Roberto Goizueta to CEO. Roberto, What I then perceived was both clear and fascinating. After drifting somewhat in the 1970's, along with Don Keough, once my across-the-street neighbor in Omaha, first rethought and focused the company's policies and then energetically carried them out. What was already the world's most ubiquitous product gained new momentum, with sales overseas virtually exploding. 15

[第 18 页]

[PAGE 18]

凭借营销与财务技能极为罕见的融合,罗伯托将产品的增长以及这种增长带给股东的回报都最大化了。通常,一家消费品公司的首席执行官,会基于其个人天赋或经验,导致要么营销要么财务以牺牲另一门学科为代价来主导业务。而罗伯托则营销与财务并重,两者结合堪称完美,结果是股东的梦想。

当然,我们本该更早开始买入可口可乐,就在罗伯托和唐刚开始管理公司之后。事实上,如果当时我头脑清醒,就会说服我祖父在 1936 年把杂货店卖掉,然后把所有钱都投进可口可乐的股票。我吸取了教训:下次再遇到如此诱人的机会时,我的反应时间会缩短到远低于 50 年。

正如我先前所述,我们主要投资标的的年末价格,相较于其内在价值,比以往高出很多。虽然这些价格可能还不至于让人流鼻血,但它们显然容易受到市场整体下跌的影响。这些股票的价格下跌我们完全不会介意——实际上可能最终对我们有利——但至少会造成伯克希尔净资产有一年的减少。我们认为,未来三年中至少有一年出现这种减少几乎是可以肯定的。事实上,只要我们的投资组合总市值比上年下跌大约 10%,伯克希尔的净资产就会下降。

我们继续幸运地拥有投资组合公司中杰出的经理人。他们素质一流、才华横溢且以股东为导向。我们在与他们一起投资中所取得的非凡成果,准确反映了他们非凡的个人品质。

去年我们告诉过您,预计 1989 年在套利上会做得很少,结果也确实如此。套利头寸是短期现金等价物的替代品,在年内部分时段我们持有较低水平的现金。在其他时段我们持有相当大额度的现金头寸,即便如此也选择不参与套利。主要原因是那些在毫无经济意义的企业交易中做套利,太接近于玩博傻游戏了。(正如华尔街人士雷·德沃所说:“天使怕交易的地方,傻瓜才冲进去。”)我们会时不时地参与套利——有时规模很大——但只有在我们看好胜率时才会出手。

• 撇开下一节讨论的三只可转换优先股不谈,我们大幅减少了中期和长期固定收益证券的持仓。在长期债券方面,我们几乎只持有华盛顿公共电力供应系统的债券,其票面利率从低到高不等。年内我们卖出了不少当初以很大折扣买入的低息券。自我们购买以来,这些低息券的价格大约翻了一倍,此外每年还免税支付给我们 15%-17% 的利息。我们卖出时的价格仅仅略低于当时典型高等级免税债券的价格。我们保留了所有高息 WPPSS 债券。其中一些将在 1991 年和 1992 年被赎回,我们预计其余部分会在 1990 年代初期至中期被赎回。

年内我们还卖出了许多中期免税债券。当初买入时我们就说过,只要遇到更好的机会,无论价格比买入时高还是低,都乐意卖出。果然遇到了——于是我们同时卖出了大部分此类债券,获得了温和的收益。总体而言,我们 1989 年出售免税债券的税前利润约为 5100 万美元。

• 债券出售所得的资金,加上年初的过剩现金以及此后产生的现金,都用来买入股票和三次可转换优先股交易。第一笔交易发生在 7 月,我们以 6 亿美元购买了吉列公司的优先股,股息率 8.75%,十年内强制赎回,可按每股 50 美元转换为普通股。接着我们以 3.58 亿美元购买了美国航空集团的可转换优先股,十年内强制赎回,股息率 9.25%,可按每股 60 美元转换为普通股。最后,年底我们以 3 亿美元购买了冠军国际公司的优先股,十年内强制赎回,股息率 9.25%,可按每股 38 美元转换为普通股。

growth of his product and the rewards that this growth brings to shareholders. Normally, the CEO Through a truly rare blend of marketing and financial skills, Roberto has maximized both the either marketing or finance to dominate the business at the expense of the other discipline. With of a consumer products company, drawing on his natural inclinations or experience, will cause Roberto, the mesh of marketing and finance is perfect and the result is a shareholder's dream. running things. In fact, if I had been thinking straight I would have persuaded my grandtather Of course, we should have started buying Coke much earlier, soon after Roberto and Don began to sell the grocery store back in 1936 and put all of the proceeds into Coca-Cola stock. I've learned my lesson: My response time to the next glaringly attractive idea will be slashed to well under As I mentioned earlier, the yearend prices of our major investees were much higher relative are clearly vulnerable to a general market decline. A drop in their prices would not disturb us to their intrinsic values than theretofore. While those prices may not yet cause nosebleeds, they reduction in Berkshire's net worth. We think such a reduction is almost certain in at least one at all — it might in fact work to our eventual benefit - but it would cause at least a one-year of the next three years. Indeed, it would take only about a 10% year-to-year decline in the aggregate value of our portfolio investments to send Berkshire's net worth down. We continue to be blessed with extraordinary managers at our portfolio companies. They are high-grade, talented, and shareholder-oriented. The exceptional results we have achieved while investing with them accurately reflect their exceptional personal qualities. way it turned out. Arbitrage positions are a substitute for short-term cash equivalents, and during We told you last year that we expected to do little in arbitrage during 1989, and that's the part of the year we held relatively low levels of cash. In the rest of the year we had a fairly transactions that made no economic sense to us; arbitraging such deals comes too close to playing good-sized cash position and even so chose not to engage in arbitrage. The main reason was corporate the greater-fool game. (As Wall Streeter Ray DeVoe says: "Fools rush in where angels fear to trade.") We will engage in arbitrage from time to time — sometimes on a large scale - but only when we like the odds. • Leaving aside the three convertible preferreds discussed in the next section, we substantially just about our only holdings have been Washington Public Power Supply Systems (WPPSS) bonds reduced our holdings in both medium- and long-term fixed-income securities. In the long-terms, carrying coupons ranging from low to high. During the year we sold a number of the low-coupon issues, which we originally bought at very large discounts. Many of these issues had approximately doubled in price since we purchased them and in addition had paid us 15%-17% annually, tax- free. Our prices upon sale were only slightly cheaper than typical high-grade tax-exempts then commanded. We have kept all of our high-coupon WPPSS issues. Some have been called for redemption in 1991 and 1992, and we expect the rest to be called in the early to mid-1990s. We also sold said we would be happy to sell them - regardless of whether they were higher many of our medium-term tax-exempt bonds during the year. When we bought or lower than at our time of purchase — if something we liked better came along. Something did - and concurrently we unloaded most of these issues at modest gains. Overall, our 1989 profit from the sale of tax-exempt bonds was about $51 million pre-tax. • The proceeds from our bond sales, along with our excess cash at the beginning of the yea and that generated later through stocks. In the first transaction, which took place in July, we purchased $600 million of The Gillette went into the purchase ot three convertible preterre Co. preferred with an 8 3/4% dividend, a mandatory redemption in ten years, and the right to convert into common at $50 per share. preferred stock with mandatory redemption in ten years, a dividend of 9 1/4%, and the right to $358 million of USAir Group, Inc. convert into common at $60 per share. Finally, late in the year we purchased $300 million of Champion International Corp. preferred with mandatory redemption in ten years, a 9 1/4% dividend, and the right to convert into common at $38 per 16

[第 19 页]

[PAGE 19]

与标准可转换优先股不同,我们持有的这些要么无法出售,要么在相当长的时间内不能转换,因此我们根本无法从普通股的短期价格波动中获利。我加入了吉列董事会,但并未进入美国航空或冠军国际的董事会。(我非常享受目前所在的董事会,但无法再多承担了。)

吉列的业务正是我们非常喜欢的那一类。查理和我认为我们理解该公司,也能对其未来做出相当明智的推测。(如果你还没试过吉列的新款 Sensor 剃须刀,赶紧去买一把。)然而,对于我们投资所涉及的投资银行业务(所罗门可转换优先股)、航空业或造纸业,我们却无法预测其经济前景。这并不意味着我们预测这些行业前景黯淡:我们是不可知论者,而非无神论者。但这一点意味着,当投资于这些业务时,我们必须采用与投资于看起来经济特性极佳的企业时截然不同的结构。

然而,在某个重要方面,这些投资并无不同:我们只愿与自己喜欢、欣赏且信任的人合作。所罗门的约翰·古特弗罗因德、吉列的科尔曼·莫克勒二世、美国航空的埃德·科洛尼以及冠军国际的安迪·西格勒,全都完美满足这个条件。而他们也对我们展现出了信心,在每次交易中都坚持让我们获得完全转换基础上的投票权——这项安排远非企业融资中的标准做法。实际上,他们信任我们是明智的、着眼未来的所有者(而非只关注今天),正如我们信任他们是明智的、同样着眼未来的管理者一样。

我们协商的这些优先股结构,如果所处行业的经济状况拖累了被投资公司的表现,它们只能为我们带来平庸的回报;但如果这些公司能赚取与美国工业整体水平相当的回报,那么我们的投资就能产生相当吸引人的业绩。我们认为,在科尔曼管理下的吉列将远远超越这一回报水平,并相信约翰、埃德和安迪也能达成目标,除非行业环境极为严酷。

几乎在任何条件下,我们都预期这些优先股能收回本金并带来股息。如果仅此而已,结果将是令人失望的,因为我们放弃了灵活性,从而将错过在未来十年内必然出现的某些重大机遇。在这种情形下,我们只是获得了一段优先股收益率,而在此期间,典型的优先股对我们而言根本毫无吸引力。伯克希尔从其四只优先股投资中获得令人满意回报的唯一途径,是被投资公司的普通股表现良好。

而这需要优秀的管理层和至少尚可忍受的行业环境。但我们相信,伯克希尔的投资同样能提供帮助,并且每家被投资公司的其他股东将在未来多年中从我们的优先股购买中受益。这种帮助源于一个事实:现在每家公司都拥有了一位重要、稳定且利益攸关的股东,而该股东的主席和副主席,通过伯克希尔的投资,已间接将一大笔自有资金投入到这些事业中。在与我们的被投资公司打交道时,查理和我会保持支持、分析和客观。我们认识到,我们是在与经验丰富的首席执行官们共事,他们完全掌控着自己的业务,但在某些时刻,他们珍视有机会与一个与他们的行业或过往决策毫无瓜葛的人探讨想法。

总体而言,这些可转换优先股不会产生我们找到一家拥有极佳经济前景、却被市场低估的企业时所能获得的回报。也不会产生我们进行最优形式的资本配置——收购一家优秀企业 80% 或更多股份,并配备优秀管理层——时的回报那么有吸引力。但这两类机会都很稀少,尤其是适合我们当前及预期资源规模的机遇更是罕见。

综上所述,查理和我认为,我们的优先股投资应能产生略高于大多数固定收益投资组合的回报,同时我们能在被投资公司中扮演一个微小但令人愉快且富有建设性的角色。

17

convertible for considerable periods of time and there is consequently no way we can gain from Unlike standard convertible preferred stocks, the issues we own are either non-salable or non- short-term price blips in the common on the board of USAir or Champion. (I thoroughly enjoy the boards I am on, but can't handle stock. I have gone on the board of Gillette, but I am not any more.) economics Gillette's business is very much the kind we like. Charlie and I think we understand the company's you haven't tried Gillette's new Sensor razor, go right out and get one.) However, we have no and therefore believe we can make a reasonably intelligent guess about its future. (If ability to forecast the economics of the investment banking business (in which we have a position industry. This does not mean that we predict a negative future for these industries: we're agnostics, of Salomon convertible preferred), the airline industry, or the paper we must structure our investments in them differently from what we do when we invest in a not atheists. Our businesses, however, means that business appearing to have splendid economic characteristics. with people whom we like, admire, and trust. John Gutfreund at Salomon, Colman Mockler, Jr. In one major respect, however, these purchases are not different: We only want to link up at Gillette, Ed Colony at USAir, and Andy Sigler at Champion meet this test in spades. They in turn have demonstrated some confidence in us, insisting in each case that our preferreds in corporate finance. In effect they are trusting us to be intelligent owners, thinking about tomorrow voting rights on a fully-converted basis, an arrangement that is far from standard instead of today, just as we are trusting them to be intelligent managers, thinking about tomorrow as well as today. economics hinder the performance of our investees, but will produce reasonably attractive results The preferred-stock structures we have negotiated will provide a mediocre return for us if industry for us if they can earn a return comparable to that of American industry in general. We believe and Andy will reach it unless industry conditions are harsh. that Gillette, under Colman's management, will far exceed that return and believe that John, Ed, If that is all we get, though, the result will be disappointing, because we will have given up flexibility Under almost any conditions, we expect these preferreds to return us our money plus dividends. and consequently will have missed some significant opportunities that are bound to present themselves during the decade. Under that scenario, we will have obtained only a preferred-stock yield during way Berkshire can achieve satisfactory results from its four preferred issues is to have the common a period when the typical preferred stock will have held no appeal for us whatsoever. The only stocks of the investee companies do well. But we believe Berkshire's investment will also help and that the other shareholders of each investee Good management and at least tolerable industry conditions will be needed if that is to happen. will profit over the years ahead from our preferred-stock purchase. The help will come from the fact that each company now has a major, stable, and interested shareholder whose Chairman and of their own money to these undertakings. In dealing with our investees, Charlie and I will be Vice Chairman have, through Berkshire's investments, indirectly committed a very large amount supportive, analytical, and objective. We recognize that we are working with experienced CEOs who are very much in command of appreciate the chance to test their thinking on someone without ties to their industry or to decisions their own businesses but who nevertheless, at certain moments, of the past. As a group, these convertible preferreds will not produce the returns we can achieve when we find a business with wonderful economic prospects that is unappreciated by the market. Nor will the returns be deployment, the acquisition of 80% or more of a fine business with a fine management. But both attractive as those produced when we make our favorite form of capital opportunities are rare, particularly in a size befitting our present and anticipated resources. In summation, Charlie and I feel that our preferred stock investments should produce returns moderately above those achieved by most fixed-income portfolios and that we can play a minor but enjoyable and constructive role in the investee companies. 17

[第 20 页]

[PAGE 20]

零息证券

9 月,伯克希尔发行了本金总额 9.026 亿美元的零息可转换次级债券,这些债券目前已在纽约证券交易所挂牌。所罗门兄弟以一流的方式处理了承销工作,为我们提供了有益的建议和完美的执行。

当然,大多数债券都要求定期支付利息,通常是每半年一次。而零息债券则不需要当期利息支付;相反,投资者通过以远低于面值的价格购买证券来获得收益。有效利率由发行价格、到期价值和发行与到期之间的时间长度决定。

就我们的情况而言,这些债券按面值的 44.314% 发行,15 年后到期。对于购买债券的投资者来说,这在数学上等同于获得 5.5% 的当期利息,按半年复利计算。因为我们每 1 美元只收到 44.31 美分,所以本次发行的净收益为 4 亿美元(扣除约 950 万美元的发行费用)。

这些债券的面值是 1 万美元,每张债券可以转换为 0.4515 股伯克希尔·哈撒韦股票。因为一张 1 万美元的债券成本是 4431 美元,这意味着转换价格是每股 9815 美元,比当时的市场价格溢价 15%。伯克希尔可以在 1992 年 9 月 28 日之后的任何时间按累计价值(即发行价加上按 5.5% 半年复利计算的利息)赎回这些债券,并且在两个指定日期,即 1994 年 9 月 28 日和 1999 年 9 月 28 日,债券持有人可以要求伯克希尔按累计价值买回这些证券。

在税务方面,伯克希尔有权每年扣除这 5.5% 的应计利息,尽管我们不需要向债券持有人支付任何款项。因此,对我们来说,由于减少了税收,净效果是正向的现金流。这是一个相当重要的好处。一些未知的变量使我们无法计算确切的实际利率,但在任何情况下它都会远低于 5.5%。同时,税法有一个对称性:任何应税的债券持有人,即使没有收到现金,也必须每年为这 5.5% 的利息纳税。

我们的债券,以及去年其他一些公司发行的类似债券(特别是洛斯公司和摩托罗拉公司),都与近年发行的大多数零息债券截然不同。对于后者,我和查理一直是,并且将继续是直言不讳的批评者。正如我稍后将解释的,这些债券常常以最具欺骗性的方式被使用,并对投资者造成致命后果。但在探讨那个话题之前,让我们先回到伊甸园,回到那个苹果还没被咬过的时代。

如果你像我一样年纪,你会在二战期间购买你的第一只零息债券,方式就是购买著名的 E 系列美国储蓄债券,这是历史上发行最广泛的债券。(战后,一半的美国家庭持有这种债券。)当然,没有人把 E 系列称为零息债券,我怀疑这个术语当时可能还没有被发明出来。但这其实就是 E 系列的本质。这些债券的面值小到 18.75 美元。这个金额可以购买一张 10 年期、价值 25 美元的美国政府债券,条款规定买家可获得 2.9% 的年复合回报率。在当时,这是一个有吸引力的报价:2.9% 的利率高于当时政府债券的一般水平,而且持有人没有市场波动风险,因为他可以在任何时候兑现他的债券,只损失很小一部分利息。

另一种同样良性和有用的零息美国国债形式出现在过去十年。普通债券的一个问题是,即使它支付一个给定的利率——比如 10%——持有人也无法保证能实现 10% 的复利回报。因为要让这个利率实现,每半年的息票在收到后都必须以 10% 的利率进行再投资。如果当这些息票需要再投资时,当前利率只有 6% 或 7%,持有人就无法在债券的存续期内按所宣传的利率进行复利增长。对于养老基金或其他有长期负债的投资者来说,这是一个问题。储蓄债券本来可以解决这个问题,但它们只向个人发行,并且没有大面额。大型买家需要的是大量的“储蓄债券等价物”。

18

Zero-Coupon Securities Subordinated Debentures, which are now listed on the New York Stock Exchange. Salomon Brothers In September, Berkshire issued $902.6 million principal amount of Zero-Coupon Convertible handled the underwriting in superb fashion, providing us helpful advice and a flawless execution. bond, conversely, requires no current interest payments; instead, the investor receives his yield by Most bonds, of course, require regular payments of interest, usually semi-annually. A zero-coupon is determined by the original issue price, the maturity value, and the amount of time between purchasing the security at a significant discount from maturity value. The effective interest rate issuance and maturity. In our case, the bonds were issued For investors purchasing the bonds, that is the mathematical equivalent of a 5.5% current payment at 44.314% of maturity value and are due in 15 years. offering were $400 million (less about $9.5 million of offering expenses). compounded semi-annually. Because we received only 44.31g on the dollar, our proceeds from this shares of Berkshire Hathaway. Because a $10,000 bond cost $4,431, this means that the conversion The bonds were issued in denominations of $10,000 and each bond is convertible into .4515 can call the bonds at any time after September 28, 1992 at their accreted value (the original issue price was $9,815 per Berkshire share, a 15% premium to the market price then existing. Berkshire price plus 5.5% compounded semi-annually) and on two specified days, September 28 of 1994 and 1999, the bondholders can require Berkshire to buy the securities at their accreted value. we make no payments to the bondholders. Thus the net effect to us, resulting from the reduced For tax purposes, Berkshire is entitled to deduct the 5.5% interest accrual each year, even though taxes, is positive cash flow. That is a very significant benefit. Some unknowable variables prevent below 5.5%. There is meanwhile a symmetry to the tax law: Any taxable holder of the bonds us from calculating our exact effective rate of interest, but under all circumstances it will be well must pay tax each year on the 5.5% interest, even though he receives no cash. (notably Loews and Motorola) resemble the great bulk of zero-coupon bonds that have been issued Neither our bonds nor those of certain other companies that issued similar bonds last in recent years. Of these, Charlie and I have been, and will continue to be, outspoken critics. As I will later explain, such bonds have often been used in the most deceptive of ways and with a time when the apple had not yet been bitten. deadly consequences to investors. But before we tackle that subject, let's travel back to Eden, to the famous Series E U. S. Savings Bond, the most widely-sold bond issue in history. (After the If you're my age you bought your first zero-coupon bonds during World War II, by purchasing war, these bonds were held by one out of two U. S. households.) Nobody, of course, called the what the Series E was. Series E a zero-coupon bond, a term in fact that I doubt had been invented. But that's precisely of the United States government due in 10 years, terms that gave the buyer a compounded annual These bonds came in denominations as small as $18.75. That amount purchased a $25 obligation return of 2.9%. At the time, this was an attractive offer: the 2.9% rate was higher than that generally available on Government bonds and at any time cash in his bonds with only a minor reduction in interest. the holder faced no market-fluctuation risk, since he could last decade. One problem A second form of zero-coupon U. S. Treasury issue, also benign and useful, surfaced in the

  • say 10% - the holder cannot be assured that a compounded 10% return will be realized. For

with a normal bond is that even though it pays a given interest rate that rate to materialize, each If current interest rates are, say, only 6% or 7% when these coupons come due, the holder will semi-annual coupon must be reinvested at 10% as it is received. be unable to compound his money over the life of the bond at the advertised rate. For pension problem. Savings Bonds might have solved it, except that they are issued only to individuals and funds or other investors with long-term liabilities, are unavailable in large denominations. What big buyers needed was huge quantities of "Savings Bond Equivalents." 18

[第 21 页]

[PAGE 21]

一些极富创造力且在这件事上极为有用的投资银行家(我很高兴地说,领头的是所罗门兄弟公司)创造了市场想要的金融工具。他们通过“剥离”标准政府债券的半年期息票来实现这一点。每张息票一旦被剥离,就具备了储蓄债券的本质特征,因为它代表一笔未来某个时间到期的单笔款项。例如,如果你将一份 2010 年到期的美国国债的 40 张半年息票剥离,你就会得到 40 张零息债券,期限从 6 个月到 20 年不等,每张都代表一笔未来一次性到期的款项。这些零息债券随后会与其他相同期限的息票打包,一起销售。如果当前利率对所有期限都是 10%,那么 6 个月期的债券将以到期价值的 95.24% 出售,而 20 年期的债券将按 14.20% 出售。因此,任何特定期限的购买者都能在整个持有期内保证获得 10% 的复合收益率。政府债券的剥离近年来大规模发生,从养老基金到个人退休金账户(IRA)等长期投资者,都认识到这些高信用等级的零息债券非常适合他们的需求。

但正如华尔街屡见不鲜的情况,智者最初所为,愚者最终效仿。在过去几年里,零息债券(以及功能等同的实物付息债券 PIK,其每半年以额外 PIK 债券付息,而非支付现金)已被信用越来越垃圾的发行人大量发行。对这些发行人来说,零息债券(或 PIK 债券)有一个压倒性的优势:承诺什么都不付的债务永远不会违约。确实,如果发展中国家政府在 20 世纪 70 年代只发行过长期零息债券,他们现在会拥有一个完美的履约记录。这一行之有效的原理——只要你郑重承诺在相当长的时间内什么都不用付,你在相当长的时间内就无需违约——并没有被那些想为越来越不靠谱的交易融资的发起人和投资银行家们忽略。但贷款人花了一段时间才接受它:当杠杆收购热潮在几年前开始时,收购者只能在一个相当稳健的基础上借款,其保守估算的自由现金流——即经营利润加折旧和摊销,减去正常化的资本支出——必须足以覆盖利息支出和适度的债务削减。

后来,随着交易撮合者的肾上腺素飙升,企业开始以如此高的价格被收购,以至于所有自由现金流都必然被用于支付利息,没有留下任何钱来偿还债务。实际上,借款人采取了一种斯嘉丽·奥哈拉式的“我明天再想”态度对待本金偿还,而这被一种新型贷款人——原始发行垃圾债券的买家——所接受。债务现在变成了需要再融资的东西,而不是需要偿还的东西。这种变化让人想起《纽约客》的一幅漫画,漫画中感激的借款人站起来与银行贷款主管握手,并激动地说:“我不知道该怎么还你钱。”很快,借款人甚至觉得这些新的、宽松的标准也绑得太紧,令人难以忍受。为了诱使贷款人资助更愚蠢的交易,他们引入了一个可恶的指标,EBDIT——即扣除折旧、利息和税项前的收益——作为公司偿债能力的测试。使用这个被截短的标尺,借款人忽略了折旧这一费用,理由是它“不涉及现金支出”。这种态度显然是妄想。在美国 95% 的企业中,长期来看大致等于折旧的资本支出是必需的,且与劳动力或公用事业成本一样,是实实在在的费用。即使是高中辍学生也知道,为了贷款买车,他必须有收入来覆盖利息、运营费用以及现实计算的折旧。如果他开始谈论 EBDIT,他会被银行哄笑出去。当然,企业的资本支出在任何一个月都可以被跳过,就像人可以跳过一天甚至一周不吃饭一样。但如果跳过成为常态且不加弥补,身体就会变弱并最终死亡。此外,时断时续的进食方式,长期而言,无论对人还是对公司,都会造就一个不如稳定饮食健康的有机体。作为商人,查理和我乐于拥有那些无力进行资本支出的竞争对手。你可能会认为,为了让交易听起来更有“想象力”而把折旧这样的大笔费用一笔勾销,是一种荒唐的会计把戏,但贷款人却贪婪地吞下了这个诱饵。

say, by Salomon Brothers). They created the instrument desired by "stripping" the semi-annual coupons some ingenious and, in this case, highly useful investment bankers (led, I'm happy to of a Savings Bond since it represents standard Government issues. Each coupon, once detached, takes on the essential character you strip the 40 semi-annual coupons from a U. S. Government Bond due in the year 2010, you a single sum due sometime in the future. For example, if then be bundled with other coupons of like maturity will have 40 zero-coupon bonds, with maturities from six months to 20 years, each of which say, 10% for all maturities, the six-month issue will sell for 95.24% of maturity value and the and marketed. If current interest rates are, 20-year issue will sell for 14.20%. The purchaser of any given maturity is thus guaranteed a com- on a large scale in recent rate of 10% for his entire holding period. Stripping of government bonds has occurred IRA accounts, recognized these high-grade, zero-coupon issues to be well suited to their needs. as long-term investors, ranging from pension funds to individual the end. In the last few years zero-coupon bonds (and their functional equivalent, pay-in-kind bonds, But as happens in Wall Street all too often, what the wise do in the beginning, fools do in issued in enormous quantities by ever-junkier credits. To these issuers, zero (or PIK) bonds offer which distribute additional PIK bonds semi-annually as interest instead of paying cash) have been one overwhelming advantage: It is impossible to default on a promise to pay nothing. Indeed, if they would now have a spotless record LDC governments had issued no debt in the 1970's other than long-term zero-coupon obligations, to pay nothing for a long time - has not been lost on promoters and investment bankers seeking This principle at work - that you need not default for a long time if you solemnly promise to finance ever-shakier deals. But its acceptance by lenders took a while: When the leveraged buy- 222242 which conservatively-estimated free cash flow - that is, operating earnings plus depreciation and out craze began some years back, purchasers could borrow only on a reasonably sound basis, in reductions in debt. amortization less normalized capital expenditures — was adequate to cover both interest and modest high that Later, as the adrenalin of deal-makers surged, businesses began to be purchased at prices so nothing for the paydown of debt. In effect, a Scarlett O'Hara "I'll think about it tomorrow" position all free cash flow necessarily had to be allocated to the payment of interest. That left in respect to principal payments was taken by borrowers and accepted by a new breed of lender, repaid. The change brings to mind a New Yorker cartoon in which the grateful borrower rises to the buyer of original-issue junk bonds. Debt now became something to be refinanced rather than shake the hand of the bank's lending officer and gushes: "I don't know how I'll ever repay you." finance even sillier transactions, they introduced an abomination, EBDIT - Earnings Before Soon borrowers found even the new, lax standards intolerably binding. To induce lenders to sawed-off yardstick, the borrower ignored depreciation as an expense on the theory that it did not Depreciation, Interest and Taxes — as the test of a company's ability to pay interest. Using this that over time roughly approximate depreciation are a necessity and are every bit as real an expense Such an attitude is clearly delusional. At 95% of American businesses, capital expenditures income that covers not only interest and operating expenses, but also realistically-calculated depre- as labor or utility costs. Even a high school dropout knows that to finance a car he must have ciation. He would be laughed out of the bank if he started talking about EBDIT. Capital outlays at a business can be skipped, of course, in any given month, just as a human can skip a day or even a week of eating. up, the body weakens and eventually dies. Furthermore, a start-and-stop feeding policy will over But if the skipping becomes routine and is not made time produce a less healthy organism, human or corporate, than that produced by a steady diet. As businessmen, Charlie and I relish having competitors who are unable to fund capital expenditures. You might think that waving away a major expense such as depreciation in an attempt to make with more "imagination." 19

[第 22 页]

[PAGE 22]

不久前,肯·加尔布雷思(Ken Galbraith)在他那本机智而富有洞察力的《大崩盘》(The Great Crash)中,创造了一个新的经济学术语:“bezzle”,意指当前未被发现的贪污总额。这种金融生物具有一种神奇的特质:贪污者因贪污额而变得更富,而受害者却尚未感到自己变穷了。加尔布雷思教授敏锐地指出,这个数额应该加到国民财富中,这样我们就能了解“心理国民财富”。逻辑上讲,一个想要感觉极其繁荣的社会,既会鼓励其公民去贪污,又会尽量不揭露罪行。通过这种方式,“财富”会膨胀,尽管没有做过一丁点生产性工作。

与零息债券的现实荒诞相比,bezzle 的讽刺性荒诞就相形见绌了。零息债券使合同一方可以体验“收入”,而对方却感受不到支出的痛苦。在我们的例子中,一家公司每年只能赚 1 亿美元——因此也只能支付那么多利息——却神奇地为债券持有人创造了 1.5 亿美元的“收益”。只要主要投资者愿意戴上彼得·潘的翅膀,反复说“我相信”,零息债券就能创造出无限量的“收入”。

在这种新标准下,一家税前盈利 1 亿美元、且必须立即支付 9000 万美元利息的企业,可能会发行零息债券或 PIK 债券,再承担 6000 万美元的年利息,这笔利息会累积并复利,但若干年内无需到期支付。这些债券的利率通常非常高,这意味着第二年可能是 9000 万美元现金利息加上 6900 万美元累积利息,以此类推,复利不断推进。这种高利率再借款方案,几年前还只适用于码头区,如今却几乎在所有大型投资银行成为现代金融的典范。

当他们进行这些发行时,投资银行家们展示了他们幽默的一面:他们发布对未来五年或更长时间的收入和资产负债表预测,这些预测针对的是那些在评估交易财务可行性时,零息债券或 PIK 债券的利息可以被忽略的公司。这种方法不仅将折旧费用打入“忽略不计”的角落,而且对利息费用中通常很大的一部分也给予了同样的待遇。可耻的是,许多专业投资经理也附和这种胡言乱语,尽管他们通常很小心,只拿客户的钱这样做,绝不动用自己的钱。(称这些经理为“专业人士”其实太客气了;他们应该被称作“推销员”。)

零息债券或 PIK 债券对发起人和投资银行家还有一个额外的吸引力,那就是从愚蠢到失败之间的时间可以拉长。这不是一个小好处。如果所有成本都必须面对之前的期限很长,发起人就可以在之前冒险的恶果尚未显现之前,制造一连串愚蠢的交易,并收取大量费用。

但最终,无论是冶金术还是金融术,炼金术都会失败。一个基础业务无法通过会计或资本结构的把戏变成黄金业务。自称金融炼金术士的人可能会变得富有。但让他致富的,通常是轻信的投资者,而不是商业成就。

nough he doing last a teres and yeir in many are procained on zero-coupon or PIK bonds could be ignored when the financial feasibility of a transaction was being assessed. This approach not only relegated depreciation expense to the let's-ignore-it corner, but gave similar treatment to what was usually a significant portion of interest expense. To their shame, many professional investment managers went along with this nonsense, though they usually is actually too kind; they should be designated "promotees.") were careful to do so only with clients' money, not their own. (Calling these managers "professionals" which $90 million of interest must be paid currently, might use a zero-coupon or PIK issue to Under this new standard, a business earning, say, $100 million pre-tax and having debt on incur another $60 million of annual interest that would accrue and compound but not come due for some years. The rate on these issues would typically be very high, which means that the situation in year 2 might be $90 million cash interest plus $69 million accrued interest, and so on compounding proceeds. Such high-rate reborrowing schemes, which a few years ago were appro- as the investment banking houses. priately confined to the waterfront, soon became models of modern finance at virtually all major income and balance sheet projections extending five or more years into the future for companies When they make these offerings, investment bankers display their humorous side: They dispense you join in the fun: Ask the investment banker for the one-year budgets that his own firm prepared term: "the bezzle," defined as the current amount of undiscovered embezzlement. This financial Some time ago Ken Galbraith, in his witty and insightful The Great Crash, coined a new economic creature has a magical quality: The embezzlers are richer by the amount of the bezzle, while the embezzlees do not yet feel so that we might know the Psychic National Wealth. Logically, a society that wanted to feel enormously Professor Galbraith astutely pointed out that this sum should be added to the National Wealth prosperous would both encourage its citizens to embezzle and try not to detect the crime. By this means, "wealth" would balloon though not an erg of productive work had been done. bond. With zeros, one party to a contract can experience "income" without his opposite experiencing The satirical nonsense of the bezzle is dwarfed by the real-world nonsense of the zero-coupon the pain of expenditure. In our illustration, a company capable of earning only $100 million dollars for bondholders of $150 million. As long as major investors willingly don their Peter Pan wings annually - and therefore capable of paying only that much in interest - magically creates "earnings" and repeatedly say "I believe," there is no limit to how much "income" can be created by the zero-coupon bond. for the strel orele mod here, ventily, was an enentimens that enlid her ed folk might reserve at prices no longer limited by actual earning power. The result, obviously, would be more transactions: finally, was an instrument that would let the Street make deals the mother's milk of finance. Silly prices will always attract sellers. And, as Jesse Unruh might have put it, transactions are banker, which is that the time elapsing The zero-coupon or PIK bond possesses one additional attraction for the promoter and investment between folly and failure can be stretched out. This is no small benefit. If the period before all costs must be faced is long, promoters can create a string earlier ventures. ot foolish deals - and take in lots of fees - before any chickens come home to roost from their not be transformed But in the end, alchemy, whether it is metallurgical or financial, fails. A base business can claiming to be a financial alchemist may become rich. But gullible investors rather than business into a golden business by tricks of accounting or capital structure. The man achievements will usually be the source of his wealth. 20

[第 23 页]

[PAGE 23]

我们实际上持有一部分这类债券,如果市场跌得足够惨,可能还会再买一些。需要补充的是,不管有多少缺陷,很多零息债券和 PIK 债券并不会违约。没有哪类金融工具本身天然邪恶,只是有些变种引发祸害的潜力远大于其他品种。(不过,我们从未考虑过买入一家弱信用主体发行的新券。)祸害排行榜的冠军,应该颁给那些无法用当前现金流、在扣除充裕的资本支出后,从容偿还全部到期利息与应计利息的零息债券发行人。我们的忠告是:每当投资银行家开口谈论某种资本结构,说连利息和应计利息都无法用现金流覆盖时——请拉上钱包拉链。反将一军,建议对方让推销人和他那些高薪同伙的报酬,等到零息债券全部付清之后再拿。我们对投资银行家的评论也许听上去刻薄。但是,查理和我——抱着无可救药的老派观念——认为,他们应当履行守门人的角色,保护投资者免受推销人肆意放纵的侵害。说到底,推销人长期以来在放纵上表现出来的判断力与克制力,与酒鬼在饮酒上的表现一直不相上下。因此,投资银行家的行为操守,至少应当达到负责任的调酒师的水平:必要时,放弃下一杯酒的利润,也不让醉汉开车上路。遗憾的是,近年来,许多顶尖投资公司认为,调酒师的道德标准过于严苛。在华尔街,走正路的人近来并没有遇到交通拥堵。

一个令人痛心的注脚:零息债券这出闹剧的代价,不会仅由直接参与者承担。某些储蓄贷款协会曾是这类债券的大买家,用的资金来自联邦储蓄与贷款保险公司承保的存款。为了拼命展示亮丽盈利,这些买家将债券上超高利息收入记入账面——但这些利息一直没收到真金白银。许多这类协会现在深陷困境。如果当初发放给弱信用主体的贷款起了作用,协会的所有者本可以赚走利润。而在众多贷款注定失败的案例中,买单的将是纳税人。套用杰基·梅森的话:在这些储贷协会里,该戴上滑雪面罩的其实是那些经理。

前二十五年犯下的错误(简缩版)

引用罗伯特·本奇利的话:“养条狗教会男孩忠诚、坚毅,以及躺下之前先转三圈。”这就体现了经验的种种局限。即便如此,在犯下新错误之前回顾旧错,仍不失为好主意。所以,我们快速回顾一下过去二十五年。

• 我的第一个错误,自然是买下伯克希尔的控制权。虽然我知道它的业务——纺织制造——前景堪忧,但因为价格看上去便宜,还是被诱了进去。早年,这类股票投资曾带来相当不错的回报,但到了 1965 年伯克希尔出现时,我已经逐渐意识到这种策略并不理想。如果你以足够低的价格买入一只股票,公司命运通常会出现一些波折,让你有机会以不错的价格脱手获利,即便其长期经营表现可能非常糟糕。我把这称为“烟蒂股”投资法。街上捡到的烟蒂,只够再吸一口,可能冒不出多少烟来,但“廉价买进价”会让这一口全成利润。除非你是清算专家,否则以这种思路买企业是愚蠢的。首先,最初的“便宜”价格到头来很可能根本不是什么便宜货。在一家困难企业里,一个问题刚刚解决,另一个问题就冒了出来——厨房里绝不会只有一只蟑螂。其次,你初始获得的任何优势,都会被企业低下的回报率迅速侵蚀。例如,你用 800 万美元买下一家企业,这家企业可以出售或清算出 1000 万美元,并且能立刻采取其中一种方式退出,你就能实现高回报。但是,如果这家企业要在十年后才以 1000 万美元卖出,而在此期间每年仅赚取、并只分配了占成本仅几个百分点的收益,那么这笔投资就会令人失望。时间是优秀企业的朋友,是平庸企业的敌人。

We have in fact owned some and may buy more if their market becomes sufficiently distressed Whatever their weaknesses, we should add, many zero-coupon and PIK bonds will not default. is evil per se; it's just that some variations have far more potential for mischief than others. (We've not, however, even considered buying a new issue from a weak credit.) No financial instrument The blue ribbon for mischief-making a current basis. Our advice: Whenever an investment banker starts talking should go to the zero-coupon issuer unable to make its both payable and accrued, to be comfortably met out of current cash flow net of ample capital someone creates a capital structure that does not allow all interest, expenditures — zip up your wallet. Turn the tables by suggesting that the promoter and his high- their take until the zero-coupon bonds have old-fashioned way — believe that they should perform a gatekeeping role, guarding investors against Our comments about investment bankers may seem harsh. But Charlie and I - in our hopelessly the same judgment and restraint in accepting money that alcoholics have exercised in accepting the promoter's propensity to indulge in excess. Promoters, after all, have throughout time exercised liquor. At a minimum, therefore, the banker's conduct should rise to that of a responsible bartender who, when necessary, refuses the profit from the next drink to avoid sending a drunk out on the to be an intolerably restrictive standard. Lately, those who have traveled the high road in Wall highway. In recent years, unfortunately, many leading investment firms have found bartender morality Street have not encountered heavy traffic. direct participants. Certain savings and loan associations were heavy buyers of such bonds, using One distressing footnote: The cost of the zero-coupon folly will not be borne solely by the cash that came from FSLIC-insured deposits. Straining to show splendid earnings, these buyers recorded are now in major trouble. Had their loans to shaky credits worked, the owners of the associations

  • but did not receive - ultra-high interest income on these issues. Many of these associations

will pick up the bill. To paraphrase Jackie Mason, at these associations it was the managers who would have pocketed the profits. In the many cases in which the loans will fail, the taxpayer should have been wearing the ski masks. Mistakes of the First Twenty-five Years (A Condensed Version) To quote Robert Benchley, "Having a dog teaches a boy fidelity, perseverance, and to turn around idea to review past mistakes before committing new ones. So let's take a quick look at the last three times before lying down." Such are the shortcomings of experience. Nevertheless, it's a good • My first mistake, of course, was in buying control of Berkshire. Though I knew its business 25 years.

  • textile manufacturing — to be unpromising, I was enticed to buy because the price looked cheap.

Stock purchases of that kind had proved reasonably rewarding in my early years, though by the time Berkshire came along in 1965 I was becoming aware that the strategy was not ideal. If you buy a stock at a sufficiently low price, there will usually be some hiccup in the fortunes of the business that gives you a chance to unload at a decent profit, even though the long-term performance of the business may be terrible. I call this the "cigar butt" approach to investing. A cigar butt found on the street that has only one puff left in it may not offer much of a smoke, but the "bargain purchase" will make that puff all profit. original "bargain" price probably will not turn out to be such a steal after all. In a difficult business, Unless you are a liquidator, that kind of approach to buying businesses is foolish. First, the no sooner is one problem solved than another surfaces — never is there just one cockroach in that the business earns. For example, if you buy a business for $8 million that can be sold or the kitchen. Second, any initial advantage you secure will be quickly eroded by the low return liquidated for $10 million and promptly take either course, you can realize a high return. But the has annually earned and distributed only a few percent on cost. Time is the friend of the wonderful investment will disappoint if the business is sold for $10 million in ten years and in the interim business, the enemy of the mediocre. 21

[第 24 页]

[PAGE 24]

你也许会觉得这个道理显而易见,但我可是吃了不少苦头才学到的——事实上,我反复学了好几次。收购伯克希尔后不久,我又买入巴尔的摩的一家百货公司——霍赫希尔德·科恩,我是通过一家后来并入伯克希尔的公司 Diversified Retailing 买下的。我以大幅低于账面价值的价格买入,管理层是一流的,交易还附赠了一些额外好处——未入账的房地产价值以及一笔相当可观的 LIFO 存货缓冲。我怎么可能失手?结果呢——三年后,我庆幸能把这家公司卖掉,拿回的价钱差不多等于我当初投入的成本。我宁愿把公司名字改成“好想它”。

我还能再给你们举一些“捡便宜货”犯蠢的个人例子,但我想你们应该已经明白这个道理了:以公平的价格买一家出色的公司,远胜于以美妙的价格买一家平庸的公司。查理很早就明白了这一点;我是学得慢的那个。

但现在,无论是收购公司还是买普通股,我们要找的都是一流的生意搭配一流的 管理。

这自然引出了又一个相关的教训:好骑师配上好马才能跑出好成绩,配上精疲力竭的劣马就没戏了。伯克希尔的纺织业务和霍赫希尔德·科恩,都配有能干而正直的人在管理。同样的经理人,如果放在经济特质优良的生意里,本来都能做出优异的成绩。但他们在流沙里挣扎,是永远也跑不起来的。

我说过很多次,当一个以聪明才智著称的管理层去对付一个以烂名昭著的生意时,最后无损的往往是生意的名声。我真希望自己当年在创造反面教材这件事上别那么精力旺盛。我当初的所作所为,和梅·韦斯特承认的那句话如出一辙:“我本来是白雪公主,可后来跑偏了。”

又一个相关的教训:别硬来,慢慢来。查理和我买了各式各样的生意,监督了 25 年,也没学会怎么去解决困难的业务难题。我们学会的是避开它们。我们之所以取得了一些成功,并不是因为我们获得了任何跨越七英尺高杆的能力,而是因为我们专注于找到那些抬脚就能跨过去的一英尺跨栏,跨过去就是了。

这个发现也许看起来不太公平,但在商业和投资中,解决容易且显而易见的问题,通常远比解决难题更赚钱。偶尔,棘手的问题必须去解决,就像我们在布法罗创办周日版报纸时那样。另一些时候,绝佳的投资机会出现在一家了不起的公司遇到某个一次性的、巨大但可以解决的问题的时候,就像多年前的美国运通和 GEICO 那样。但总的来看,比起屠龙,我们避开恶龙做得更好。

我最意想不到的一个发现是:商业中有一股看不见的力量——我们不妨称之为“机构强制力”——其重要性压倒一切。在商学院的时候,从来没人跟我提过机构强制力的存在,我踏足商界时也没有直觉地理解它。那时我认为,正派、聪明、经验丰富的管理者,理所当然会做出理性的商业决策。但随着时间的推移,我发现事实并非如此。相反,当机构强制力开始起作用时,理性就频繁地枯萎了。

举例来说:(1)仿佛受牛顿第一运动定律支配一样,机构会抵制任何改变其当前方向的举动;(2)正如工作会自行膨胀以填满可用时间,公司的项目或收购会不断涌现以消耗可用的资金,不管这些点子有多蠢,都会立刻得到下属精心准备的详细回报率分析和战略研究报告的支持;(3)任何来自于领导者的业务冲动——无论是扩张、收购、设定高管薪酬还是别的什么——都会被身边人盲目地模仿;(4)同行的行为,不管是扩张、收购还是别的,也都会被不动脑筋地照搬。

让企业走上这些道路的,是机构的惯性力量,而不是贪婪或愚蠢,这些做法往往都误入歧途了。因为忽略了机构强制力的威力而犯过一些代价高昂的错误之后,我努力以削弱其影响的方式来组织和经营伯克希尔。此外,查理和我也努力将投资集中在那些看起来对这个问题保持警惕的公司上。

You might think this principle is obvious, but I had to learn it the hard way - in fact, I had to learn it several times over. Shortly after purchasing Berkshire, I acquired a Baltimore department store, Hochschild, Kohn, buying through a company called Diversified Retailing that later merged with Berkshire. I bought at a substantial discount from book value, the people were first-class, and the deal included some extras - unrecorded real estate values and a significant LIFO inventory cushion. How could I miss? So-o-o - three years later I was lucky to sell the business for about Miss Him a Lot." give you other personal examples of "bargain-purchase" folly but I'm sure you get the picture: It's far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price. Charlie understood this early; I was a slow learner. common stocks, we look for first-class businesses accompanied by first-class But now, when buying companies or managements. • That leads right into a related lesson: Good jockeys will do well on good horses, but not on broken-down nags. Both Berkshire's textile business and Hochschild, Kohn had able and honest people running them. The same managers employed in a business with good economic characteristics in quicksand. would have achieved fine records. But they were never going to make any progress while running I've said many times that when a management with a reputation for brilliance tackles a business just wish hadnt been so econgetic in ireating examples. My behavior nas matched that admitted the reputation of the business that remains intact. l by Mae West: "I was Snow White, but I drifted." • A further related lesson: Easy does it. After 25 years of buying and supervising a great variety of businesses, Charlie and I have not learned how to solve difficult business problems. What we have learned is to avoid them. To the extent we have been successful, it is because we concentrated to clear seven-footers. on identifying one-foot hurdles that we could step over rather than because we acquired any ability to simply stick with the easy The finding may seem unfair, but in both business and investments it is usually far more profitable problems must be tackled as was the case when we started our Sunday paper in Buffalo. In other and obvious than it is to resolve the difficult. On occasion, tough instances, a great investment opportunity occurs when a marvelous business encounters a one-time huge, but solvable, problem as was the case many years back at both American Express and GEICO. Overall, however, we've done better by avoiding dragons than by slaying them. • My most surprising discovery: the overwhelming importance in business of an unseen force imperative's existence and I did not intuitively understand it when I entered the business world. that we might call "the institutional imperative." In business school, I was given no hint of the I thought then that decent, intelligent, and experienced managers would automatically make rational business decisions. But I learned over time that isn't so. Instead, rationality frequently wilts when the institutional imperative comes into play. any change in its current direction; (2) Just as work expands to fill available time, corporate projects For example: (1) As if governed by Newton's First Law of Motion, an institution will resist however foolish, will be quickly supported by detailed rate-of-return and strategic studies prepared or acquisitions will materialize to soak up available funds; (3) Any business craving of the leader, by his troops; setting executive compensation or whatever, will be mindlessly imitated. and (4) The behavior of peer companies, whether they are expanding, acquiring, too often misguided. After Institutional dynamics, not venality making some expensive mistakes because I ignored the power of the stupidity, set businesses on these courses, which are Furthermore, Charlie and 1 have attempted to concentrate our investments in companies that appear imperative, I have tried to organize and manage Berkshire in ways that minimize its influence. alert to the problem. 22

[第 25 页]

[PAGE 25]

在犯了另外一些错误之后,我学会了只和自己喜欢、信任而且敬佩的人一起做生意。正如我之前所说,这一条政策本身并不能保证成功:一家二流的纺织公司或百货公司,不会仅仅因为它的经理是你乐意把女儿嫁给他的人就生意兴隆。然而,一个所有者——或者说投资者——如果能与具备如此品格的人共事,并置身于经济特质还过得去的生意里,是可以创造奇迹的。反过来,我们不愿与缺乏可敬品质的经理人为伍,无论他们生意的前景多么诱人。和烂人打交道,我们从来没能做成一笔好买卖。

*我一些最严重的错误并非外界可见。这些错误,是我看懂了它们的价值、却没有出手的股票和企业买入决定。错失一项超出你能力圈的大机会算不上罪过。但我却放过了好几桩真正巨大的买入机会,它们简直是装在银盘里端到我面前,而我完全有能力看懂。对伯克希尔的股东——包括我自己在内——这种吮手指观望的代价极为沉重。

*我们一贯保守的财务政策,或许看上去是个错误,但依我之见并非如此。回过头看,很明显,如果伯克希尔采用明显更高、但仍属常规的杠杆比例,带来的净资产收益率会远好过我们实际实现的 23.8%。即使在 1965 年,我们或许也可以判定,更高杠杆有 99% 的概率只会带来好事。相应地,我们可能只看到了 1% 的概率,即有某种外部或内部的冲击因素,会让一个常规的负债率导致介于暂时痛苦和违约之间的后果。我们不会喜欢那样的 99:1 赔率——也永远都不会。在我们看来,一丝发生危困或蒙羞的可能,无法用大概率获得额外回报来抵消。如果你的行动是明智的,你肯定会得到好结果;在多数这类情形中,杠杆只不过是加快了事情推进的速度。查理和我从来不急:我们享受这个过程,远胜过享受最终收益——尽管我们也学会了容忍那些吮手指的失误。

  • * * * *

杂项

我们希望能收购更多与现有企业类似的公司,也需要一些引荐。如果你有一家企业符合以下标准,请致电我,或最好写信给我。

以下是我们寻求的条件:

(1)大笔收购(税后利润至少 1,000 万美元),

(2)展现出持续的盈利能力(我们对未来预测兴趣寥寥,对“扭亏为盈”的情形也没有兴趣),

(3)企业在很少或没有负债的情况下,取得良好的净资产收益率,

(4)管理层在位(我们提供不了管理层),

(5)业务简单(技术含量高,我们就理解不了),

(6)有报价(价格未知的情况下,我们不想浪费自己或卖家的时间,去做哪怕只是初步的交易讨论)。

我们不会进行恶意收购。我们承诺完全保密,并以极快速度——通常在五分钟内——回复是否有兴趣。我们倾向于用现金收购,但当我们获得的内在商业价值与我们付出的一样多时,也会考虑发行股票。

我们希望在下一个 25 年,能汇报头 50 年所犯的错误。假如到了 2015 年我们还在干这事,你可以相信,这一节占的篇幅会比现在多得多。

• After some other mistakes, I learned to go into business only with people whom I like, trust, and admire. or department-store company won't prosper simply because its managers are men that you would As I noted before, this policy of itself will not ensure success: A second-class textile if he manages to be pleased to see your daughter marry. However, an owner — or investor — can accomplish wonders associate himself characteristics. Conversely, we do not wish to join with managers who lack admirable qualities, such people in businesses that possess decent economic deal with a bad no matter how attractive the prospects of their business. We've never succeeded in making a good • Some of my worst mistakes were not publicly visible. These were stock and business purchases one's area of competence. But I have passed on a couple of really big purchases that were served whose virtues I understood and yet didn't make. It's no sin to miss a great opportunity outside myself included, the cost of this thumb-sucking has been huge. up to me on a platter and that I was fully capable of understanding. For Berkshire's shareholders, view were not. In retrospect, it is clear that significantly higher, though still conventional, leverage • Our consistently-conservative financial policies may appear to have been a mistake, but in my have actually averaged. Even in 1965, perhaps we could have judged there to be a 99% probability ratios at Berkshire would have produced considerably better returns on equity than the 23.8% we that higher leverage would lead to nothing but good. Correspondingly, we might have seen only to produce a result falling somewhere between temporary anguish and default. a 1% chance that some shock factor, external or internal, would cause a conventional debt ratio disgrace cannot, in our view, be offset by a large chance of extra returns. If your actions are sensible, We wouldn't have liked those 99:1 odds — and never will. A small chance of distress or you are certain to get good results; in most such cases, leverage just moves things along faster.

  • though we have learned to live with those also.

Charlie and 1 have never been in a big hurry: We enjoy the process far more than the proceeds

  • * * * *

*

  • * * *

2015 to do that, you can count on this section occupying many more pages than it does here. We hope in another 25 years to report on the mistakes of the first 50. If we are around in Miscellaneous help. If you have a business that fits the following criteria, call me or, preferably, write. We hope to buy more businesses that are similar to the ones we have, and we can use some Here's what we're looking for: (1) Large purchases (at least $10 million of after-tax earnings), (2) demonstrated consistent earning power (future projections are of little interest to us, nor are "turnaround" situations), (3) businesses earning good returns on equity while employing little or no debt, (4) management in place (we can't supply it), (5) simple businesses (if there's lots of technology, we won't understand it), (6) an offering price (we don't want to waste our time or that of the seller by talking, even preliminarily, about a transaction when price is unknown). very fast answer — customarily within five minutes — as to whether we're interested. We prefer We will not engage in unfriendly takeovers. We can promise complete confidentiality and a o buy for cash, but will consider issuing stock when we receive as much in intrinsic business value as we give. 23

[第 26 页]

[PAGE 26]

我们最喜欢的收购形式,是契合布拉姆金-弗里德曼-海尔德曼模式的那种。在这类案例中,公司的所有者兼管理者希望拿出相当大一笔现金来套现,有时是为了自己,但往往是为了家人或不参与经营的股东。与此同时,这些管理者希望仍然作为重要股东,像过去一样继续经营自己的公司。我们认为,对有这类目标的所有者来说,我们提供了格外好的匹配。我们诚邀潜在卖家通过联系过往与我们做过生意的人,来对我们进行一番考察。

查理和我经常接触到远不达我们标准的收购提议:我们发现,如果你登广告表明有兴趣买柯利牧羊犬,会有很多人打电话来,想把他们的可卡犬卖给你。我们对新创企业、扭亏项目或拍卖式出售的态度,可以用一句高德温式的名言来概括:“请把我排除在外。”

除了对以上所述企业收购的兴趣之外,我们也有兴趣通过协商买进不构成控股的大宗普通股,类似于我们对大都会/美国广播公司、所罗门、吉列、全美航空和冠军国际的持股。去年我们曾表示,对大宗可转换优先股有特别的兴趣,但目前我们在这一品种上的头寸已接近我们认为合适的最高仓位,因此兴趣有限。

* * * * * * * *

两年前,我向各位提起过哈里·博特尔,他在 1962 年迅速治愈了我所控股的第一家工业企业——登普斯特农机制造公司(我的一次“烟蒂股”投资)的一场大乱子,又在 24 年后再次出现救我于水火,这次解救的是 K&W 产品公司(一家生产汽车化工品的小型伯克希尔子公司)。我曾向各位报告,哈里快到斩乱麻地降低了 K&W 的占款,调整了生产,削减了成本,并使利润增长了三倍。你多半以为他会就此歇口气。但就在去年,已届 70 岁的哈里参加了一场破产拍卖,只花了一丁点儿钱便买下一个与 K&W 天然适配的产品线。这一神来之笔,很可能会让那家公司的盈利能力再提高 50%。请留意此处,等待哈里未来捷报频传。

*

*

在伯克希尔股票于纽约证券交易所挂牌交易超过一年之际,我们的指定做市商——亨德森兄弟公司(HBI)的吉姆·马圭尔,仍然保持着出色的表现。在我们挂牌之前,交易商之间的价差常常达到市价的 3% 甚至更多。吉姆一直把价差维持在 50 个点或更小,以当前股价计算远低于 1%。买卖股票的股东都从交易成本的这一下降中得到了实实在在的好处。

因为我们对与吉姆、HBI 和纽约证券交易所的合作深感满意,我在纽交所刊登的一组广告中公开表达了这一态度。我通常回避写推荐语,但在这次,我很高兴能公开称赞纽交所。

*

  • *
  • *

*

*

去年夏天,我们卖掉了三年前花 85 万美元购买的那架公司飞机,然后又花 670 万美元买了另一架二手飞机。你们当中那些还记得第 5 页细菌繁殖数学题的读者,难免要慌了:如果我们的净资产继续以当前速度增长,而换飞机的费用也以当下已然确立的每年 100% 的复利速度继续攀升,那么用不了多久,伯克希尔的全部净资产就要被公司的飞机吞噬殆尽。

查理不喜欢我把飞机比作细菌;他觉得这对细菌是种贬低。他心中的气派出行是一辆空调大巴,而那也得等到有特价票的时才肯享用。至于我自己对飞机的态度,可以用一段据称是……的祷词来概括。

these, the company's owner-managers Our favorite form of purchase is one fitting the Blumkin-Friedman-Heldman mold. In cases like wish to generate significant amounts of cash, sometimes for themselves, but often for their families or inactive shareholders. At the same time, these managers past. We think we offer a particularly good fit for owners with such objectives. We invite potential wish to remain significant owners who continue to run their companies just as they have in the sellers to check us out by contacting people with whom we have done business in the past. our tests: Charlie and I frequently get approached about acquisitions that don't come close to meeting call hoping to sell you their cocker spaniels. Our interest in new ventures, turnarounds, or auction- We've found that if you advertise an interest in buying collies, a lot of people will like sales can best be expressed by a Goldwynism: "Please include me out." in the negotiated purchase Besides being interested in the purchase of businesses as described above, we are also interested of large, but not controlling, blocks of stock comparable to those we interest in large purchases of convertible preferreds. We still have hold in Capital Cities, Salomon, Gillette, USAir and Champion. Last year we said we had a special it is limited since we now are close to the maximum position we feel appropriate for this category of that kind, but of investment. * * * * * * * * mess at Two years ago, I told you about Harry Bottle, who in 1962 quickly cured a major business "bargain" purchases) and who 24 years later had reappeared to again rescue me, this time from first industrial company I controlled, Dempster Mill Manufacturing (one of my I reported, in short order Harry reduced capital employed at K&W, rationalized production, cut problems at K&W Products, a small Berkshire subsidiary that produces automotive compounds. As costs, and quadrupled profits. You might think he would then have paused for breath. But last year Harry, now 70, attended a bankruptcy auction and, for a pittance, acquired a product line Watch this space for future bulletins on Harry's triumphs. that is a natural for K&W. That company's profitability may well be increased 50% by this coup. *

* With more than a year behind him of trading Berkshire's stock on the New York Stock Exchange, our specialist, Jim Maguire of Henderson Brothers, Inc. ("HBI"), continues his outstanding maintained the spread at 50 points or less, which at current prices is well under 1%. Shareholders performance. Before we listed, dealer spreads often were 3% or more of market price. Jim has who buy or sell benefit significantly from this reduction in transaction costs. in ads that have been run in ecause we are delighted by our experience with Jim, HBI and the NYSE, I said as mur series placed by the NYSE. Normally I shun testimonials, but was pleased in this instance to publicly compliment the Exchange.

  • * *
  • *
  • *

* * bought another used jet for $6.7 million. Last summer we sold the corporate jet that we purchased for $850,000 three years ago and plying bacteria on page 5 will understandably panic: If our net worth continues to increase at Those of you who recall the mathematics of the multi current rates, and the cost of replacing planes also continues to rise at the now-established rate by its jet. of 100% compounded annually, it will not be long before Berkshire's entire net worth is consumed His idea of traveling in style is an air-conditioned bus, a luxury he steps up to only when bargain Charlie doesn't like it when I equate the jet with bacteria; he feels it's degrading to the bacteria. fares are in effect. My own attitude toward the jet can be summarized by the prayer attributed, 24

[第 27 页]

[PAGE 27]

我确信,这故事有些演绎色彩——说的是圣奥古斯丁,他在考虑告别世俗享乐、成为神职人员之前,曾想过要守贞。理智与欲望在内心交战,他恳求道:“主啊,帮助我变得贞洁——但不是现在。”

给飞机起名可不容易。我最初建议叫“查尔斯·T·芒格号”。查理则用“怪物号”来回应。我们最后定下了“无可辩护号”。

  • * * * * *

** * * **

1989 年,伯克希尔股东指定捐款计划约有 96.9% 的合格股份参与。通过该计划捐出的金额为 590 万美元,共有 2550 家慈善机构受捐。

我们强烈建议新股东阅读第 52-53 页上关于股东指定捐款计划的说明。如果您想参与未来的计划,我们强烈建议您立即确认您的股票是以实际持有人的名字登记的,而不是经纪人、银行或存管机构的代名人。在 1990 年 8 月 31 日之前未如此登记的股份,将不具备参与 1990 年计划的资格。

  • * * * * * * *

今年的股东大会将于 1990 年 4 月 30 日星期一上午 9:30 举行。去年参会人数增加到约 1000 人,几乎坐满了乔斯林博物馆威瑟斯庞厅。因此今年的会议将移至奥马哈市中心的奥菲姆剧院,这里距离红狮酒店约四分之一英里。雷迪森-雷迪克塔酒店,一家小得多但不错的酒店,就在奥菲姆剧院对面。您可能也愿意住在西奥马哈的万豪酒店,距离波仙珠宝店约 100 码。我们将安排巴士在 8:30 和 8:45 从万豪酒店出发前往会场,并在会议结束后返回。

查理和我一直很享受股东大会,希望您能出席。我们股东的高素质反映在提问的质量上:我们从未在任何公司的股东大会上,听到过如此持续高水平的、与所有者利益相关的睿智提问。

我们的委托材料中附有一份说明,告诉您如何获取入场所需的证件。由于奥菲姆剧院周边工作日停车可能紧张,我们已为股东在附近安排了数个停车场。附件中还包含相关信息。

和往常一样,会后我们将有巴士送您去内布拉斯加家具城和波仙珠宝店,之后再将您送到市中心酒店或机场。希望您能留出充足时间,充分领略这两家店的魅力。

提前到达的股东可以在任何工作日去家具城;家具城周六从上午 10 点营业到下午 5:30,周日从中午 12 点营业到下午 5:30。

波仙珠宝店通常周日不营业,但我们将在 4 月 29 日周日中午 12 点到下午 6 点,专门为股东及其客人开放。艾克喜欢搞些花样,您可以相信他会为我们的股东准备一些非常特别的东西。

在这封信里,我们谈了很多关于复利的内容。如果您能承受让自己的复利在某一天变成负数——我承认这念头不讨喜——那就 29 号来找艾克吧。

沃伦·E·巴菲特

董事会主席

1990 年 3 月 2 日

apocryphally I'm sure, to St. Augustine as he contemplated leaving a life of secular pleasures to to become chaste - but not become a priest. Battling the conflict between intellect and glands, he pled: "Help me, Oh Lord, countered with Naming the plane has not been easy. I initially suggested "The Charles T. Munger." Charlie "The Aberration." We finally selled on "The Indefensible."

  • * * * * *

** * * ** ontributions program. Contributions made through the program were $5.9 million, and 2.550 charitie bout 96.9% of all eligible shares participated in Berkshire's 1989 shareholder-designate were recipients. program that appears on pages 52-53. If you wish to participate in future programs, we strongly We urge new shareholders to read the description of our shareholder-designated contributions urge that you immediately make sure your shares are registered in the name of the actual owner, 1990 will be ineligible for the 1990 program. not in the nominee name of a broker, bank or depository. Shares not so registered on August 31, * * * * * * * * grew last year to about 1,000, very close to the seating capacity of the Witherspoon Hall at Joslyn The annual meeting this year will take place at 9:30 a.m. on Monday, April 30, 1990. Attendance Museum. So this year's meeting will be moved to the Orpheum Theatre, which is in downtown smaller but nice hotel, is located across the street from the Orpheum. Or you may wish to stay Omaha, about one-quarter of a mile from the Red Lion Hotel. The Radisson-Redick Tower, a much at the Marriott that will leave at 8:30 and 8:45 for the meeting and return after it ends. at the Marriott, which is in west Omaha, about 100 yards from Borsheim's. We will have buses shareholders is reflected in the quality of the questions we get: We have never attended an annual Charlie and I always enjoy the meeting, and we hope you can make it. The quality of our meeting anywhere that features such a consistently high level of intelligent, owner-related questions. for admission to the meeting. Because weekday parking can be tight around the Orpheum, we have An attachment to our proxy material explains how you can obtain the card you will need about them. lined up a number of nearby lots for our shareholders to use. The attachment also contains information the meeting and to take you to downtown hotels or to the airport later. I hope that you will allow As usual, we will have buses to take you to Nebraska Furniture Mart and Borsheim's after plenty of time to fully explore the attractions of both stores. the Furniture Mart any day of the week; it is open from 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. on Saturdays, and Those of you arriving early can visit from noon to 5:30 p.m. on Sundays. from noon to 6 p.m. on Sunday, April 29th. Ike likes to put on a show, and you can rely on Borsheim's normally is closed on Sunday, but we will open for shareholders and their guests him to produce something very special for our shareholders. own rate turn negative for a day — not a pretty thought, I admit - visit Ike on the 29th. In this letter we've had a lot to say about rates of compounding. If you can bear having your Warren E. Buffett March 2, 1990 Chairman of the Board 25

[第 28 页]

[PAGE 28]

德勤会计师事务所

内布拉斯加州奥马哈市 68102-1678

第一国民中心 2000 号

电传:6716075 TROSS UW

电话:(402) 346-7788

独立审计师报告

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司董事会及各位股东:

我们审计了所附伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司及其子公司 1989 年 12 月 31 日和 1988 年 12 月 31 日的合并资产负债表,以及截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日止三年各期的相关合并收益表和现金流量表。这些财务报表由公司管理层负责。我们的责任是根据我们的审计对这些财务报表发表意见。

我们按照公认审计准则进行审计。这些准则要求我们计划并执行审计,以合理确信财务报表是否不存在重大错报。审计包括在测试的基础上检查支持财务报表中金额和披露的证据。审计还包括评估管理层使用的会计原则和所作的重大估计,以及评价财务报表的整体列报。我们认为,我们的审计为我们的意见提供了合理基础。

我们认为,上述合并财务报表在所有重大方面公允反映了伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司及其子公司 1989 年 12 月 31 日和 1988 年 12 月 31 日的财务状况,以及截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日止三年各期的经营成果和现金流量,符合公认会计原则。如附注 1 所述,合并财务报表对公司在 1989 年采用财务会计准则公告《特定长期合同会计及出售投资已实现损益的会计处理》给予了追溯调整。

1990 年 3 月 7 日

26

Deloitte & Touche Omaha, Nebraska 68102-1678 2000 First National Center Telex: 6716075 TROSS UW Telephone: (402) 346-7788 INDEPENDENT AUDITORS' REPORT To the Board of Directors and Shareholders Berkshire Hathaway Inc. Hathaway Inc. We have audited the accompanying consolidated balance sheets of Berkshire related consolidated statements of earnings and cash flows for each of the subsidiaries of December 31, 1989 and 1988, and the three years in the period ended December 31, 1989. These financial statements are the responsibility of the Company's management. express an opinion on these financial statements based on our audits. Our responsibility is to standards. We conducted our audits in accordance with generally accepted auditing obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements are free of Those standards require that we plan to material misstatement. supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. An audit includes examining, on a test basis, evidence includes assessing accounting principles and significant An audit statement presentation. estimates made by management, We believe that our audits provide a reasonable basis as well as evaluating the overall financial for our opinion. present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of Berkshire In our opinion, the consolidated financial statements referred to above Hathaway Inc. and subsidiaries results of their operations and their cash flows for each of the three years as of December 31, 1989 and 1988, and the in the period ended December 31, 1989, in conformity with generally accepted accounting principles. retroactive effect to the Company's adoption in 1989 of Statement of Financial Note 1, the consolidated financial statements give Accounting for Certain Long-Duration Contracts and for Standards "Accounting Reporting Realized Insurance Losses from the Sale of Investments." March 7, 1990 26

[第 29 页]

[PAGE 29]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司及其子公司合并资产负债表

(除每股数据外,单位均为千美元)

1989 年 12 月 31 日

1988 年 12 月 31 日

资产

现金及现金等价物

$ 205,127

$ 265,081

投资:

固定期限债务

贷款及应收账款

权益性有价证券

2,795,588

5,261,598

1,815,321

3,558,724

存货

554,763

579,910

房产及设备

195,927

207,432

其他资产

194,390

167,293

总资产

$ 9,459,594

$ 6,816,848

负债及股东权益

损失及损失调整费用

$ 1,436,311

$ 1,407,189

储蓄账户

未赚保费

143,631

241,818

443,602

291,592

应付账款、应计费用及其他负债

286,909

所得税

325,514

1,129,038

1,007,516

定期债务及其他借款

598,905

总负债

480,009

4,451,690

3,340,344

少数股东权益

82,778

66,396

股东权益:

普通股,面值 5 美元;授权 1,500,000 股;

发行 1,375,202 股,含库存股

157,377

157,377

资本公积

6,876

6,876

权益性有价证券未实现增值,净值

2,460,968

2,342,198

留存收益

2,013,491

1,274,657

减:按成本持有的库存普通股(228,761 股)

4,967,419

3,452,401

股东权益合计

42,293

42,293

负债及股东权益总计

$ 4,925,126

$ 3,410,108

$ 9,459,594

$ 6,816,848

详见合并财务报表附注

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS and Subsidiaries (dollars in thousands except per share amounts) December 31, Cash and cash equivalents.. ASSETS 1989 1988 Investments: $ 205,127 $ 265,081 Obligations with fixed maturities Loans and accounts receivable.... Marketable equity securities....... 2,795,588 5,261,598 1,815,321 3,558,724 Inventories. 554,763 579,910 Properties and equipment. 195,927 207,432 194,390 167,293 Other assets 239,159 236,129 $ 9,459,594 $ 6,816.848 Losses and loss adjustment expenses LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY $ 1,436,311 $ 1,407,189 Savings accounts Unearned premiums... 143,631 241,818 443,602 291,592 286,909 Accounts payable, accruals and other liabilities 325,514 Income taxes 1,129,038 1,007,516 598,905 Term debt and other borrowings 480.009 4,451,690 3.340,344 Minority shareholders' interests 82,778 66,396 Shareholders' equity: Common stock of $5 par value. Authorized 1,500,000 shares; issued 1,375,202 shares, including shares held in treasury. 157,377 6,876 157,377 6,876 Capital in excess of par value.. Unrealized appreciation of marketable equity securities, net 2,460.968 2,342,198 2.013.491 1,274,657 Retained earnings 4,967,419 3,452,401 Less common stock in treasury, at cost (228,761 shares) 4.925.126 42,293 3.410,108 42.293 Total shareholders' equity $ 9,459.594 $ 6.816.848 See accompanying Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements 27

[第 30 页]

[PAGE 30]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司及其子公司合并收益表(除每股数据外,金额单位为千美元)

截至 12 月 31 日的年度

1989 年 | 1988 年 * | 1987 年 *

收入:

销售及服务收入 | 1,526,459 | 1,407,642 | 1,326,829

利息及股息收入 | 394,279 | 584,235 | 387,018

已赚保费 | 223,810 | 331,452 | 314,251

杂项收入 | 7,892 | 131,671 | 27,094

已实现投资利得 | 331,452 | 314,251 | 824,895

总收入 | 2,483,892 | 2,464,893 | 2,431,782

成本和费用:

保险损失及损失调整费用 | 844,056 | 753,845 | 705,203

销售产品及服务成本 | 309,391 | 437,695 | 526,359

保险承保费用 | 109,288 | 157,621 | 219,178

利息费用 | 77,574 | 70,280 | 77,794

销售、一般及管理费用 | 495,331 | 661,146 | 488,307

所得税前收益 | 617,224 | 550,121 | 310,511

所得税 | 159,287 | 140,791 | 69,539

少数股东权益 | 10,460 | 10,060 | 6,420

净利润 | 447,477 | 399,270 | 234,552

每股净利润 | 390.01 | 348.23 | 204.51

  • 已重述 — 参见附注 1(b)

参见合并财务报表附注

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF EARNINGS and Subsidiaries (dollars in thousands except per share amounts) 1989 Year Ended December 31, 1988* 1987* Revenues: Sales and service revenues interest and dividend incom nsurance premiums earne .... .... $1,526,459 394,279 $1,407,642 584,235 $1,326,829 Sundry income. Realized investment gain ... 223,810 331,452 314,251 824,895 237,319 .... 7,892 131,671 27,094 13.901 28,838 2,483,892 2,464,893 2.431.782 Cost and expenses: Insurance losses and loss adjustment expenses.. Cost of products and services sold 844,056 Insurance underwriting expenses... 309,391 753,845 437,695 705,203 Interest expense Selling, general and administrative expenses 109,288 495,331 157,621 661,146 526,359 219,178 1,866.668 77,574 70,280 488,307 1.914.772 2,121.271 47.437 Earnings before income taxes •..• 617,224 550,121 310,511 Income taxes. ..•• 159,287 140,791 69,539 Minority interest. 457,937 10,460 409,330 10,060 240,972 Net earnings 6,420 Net earnings per share ... $ 447,477 $ 399,270 $ 234.552 390.01 348.23 $ *Restated — See Note 1(b) 204.51 See accompanying Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements 28

[第 31 页]

[PAGE 31]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司及其子公司合并现金流量表

(金额单位:千美元)

1989 年 1988 年 1987 年

截至 12 月 31 日止年度:

经营活动产生的现金流量:

净利润 $ 447,477 $ 399,270 $ 234,552

将净利润调节为经营活动现金流量的调整项目:

折旧与摊销 32,107 29,808 29,683

已实现投资收益 (223,810) 131,671 (938)

少数股东权益 (22,181) 10,460 6,420

应交所得税增加(减少) 146,767 3,643 (400,194)

损失及损失调整费用增加 (30,937) 29,122 6,917

未赚保费减少 (98,187) (6,253) (29,526)

递延取得成本减少 (73,642) 124,737 30,481

其他 47,401 21,907 47,913

经营活动产生的现金流量净额 330,206 363,881 606,740

投资活动产生的现金流量:

购买固定到期投资 (1,468,157) (1,708,971) (739,932)

出售固定到期投资所得款项 519,470 345,351 1,229,290

购买可交易权益证券 (550,112) (109,245) (878,228)

出售可交易权益证券所得款项 821,656 28,985 46,104

固定到期投资到期收回款项 878,228 46,104 92,873

贷款本金收回 109,830 103,602 21,144

发放贷款 (133,546) (57,174) (177,840)

其他 (103,602) 15,351 123,297

投资活动产生的现金流量净额 (918,868) (519,246) (944,233)

筹资活动产生的现金流量:

偿还借款 (650,019) (250,000) (59,877)

借款所得款项 1,172,356 438,877 111,359

储蓄账户净增加额 1,688 4,683 (2,335)

其他 (6,051) (1,990) (3,853)

筹资活动产生的现金流量净额 528,708 188,484 29,176

现金及现金等价物年初余额 265,081 33,119 231,962

现金及现金等价物净增加(减少)额 (59,954) 231,962 540,279

现金及现金等价物年末余额 $ 205,127 $ 265,081 $ 231,962

其他现金流量信息:

支付利息 $ 181,468 $ 137,148 $ 100,778

支付所得税 70,191 61,798 46,067

参见合并财务报表附注

29

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS and Subsidiaries (dollars in thousands) 1989 Year Ended December 31, 1988 1987 Cash flows from operating activities: Net income... Adjustments to reconcile net income to cash flows .... $ 447,477 $ 399,270 $ 234,552 from operating activities: Depreciation and amortization.............. Realized investment gain (223,810) 32,107 29,808 29,683 Minority interests. 131,671 0,060 (28,838) Increase (decrease) in income taxes payable (22,181) 10,460 6,420 146,767 3,643 400,194 (30,937) Increase in losses and loss adjustment expenses...... Decrease in unearned premiums ... (98,187) 29,122 Other ... Decrease in deferred acquisition costs... (99,526) (6,253) 11,783 (73,642) 124,737 30,481 47,401 21,907 Net cash flows from operating activities 330,206 363,881 606.740 Cash flows from investing activities: Purchases of fixed maturity investments. (1,468,157) Proceeds on sales of fixed maturity investments Purchases of marketable equity securities (739,932) (1,708,971) (109,245) (1,229,290) 519,470 345,351 (550,112) 205,110 Proceeds from maturities of fixed Proceeds on sales of marketable equity securities......... maturity investments.... 821,656 28,985 878,228 46,104 607,080 92,873 Principal collection on loans Loans originated in finance businesses.. (133,546) _(57,174) 109,830 (103,602) 21,144 111,745 (177,840) _(15,351) 123,297 Other Net cash flows from investing activities.... (918,868) (519,246) (944,233) Cash flows from financing activities: Repayments of borrowings.... Proceeds from borrowings .. 1,172,356 (650,019) 250,000 (59,877) (111,359) 141,075 Net increase in savings account...... 1,688 4,683 (2,33Z) 698 (4,393) 3,853 Other.. Net cash flows from financing activities... 528,708 188,484 29,176 Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of year. Increase (decrease) in cash and cash equivalents.. 265,081 (59,954) 33,119 540,279 (308,317) 231,962 Cash and cash equivalents at end of year. .. . . $205,127 $ 265,081 $231.962 Other cash flow information: Interest paid Income taxes paid. ..... $ 181,468 70,191 $ 137,148 61,798 $ 100,778 46,067 See accompanying Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements 29 -

[第 32 页]

[PAGE 32]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司及其子公司

合并财务报表附注

1989 年 12 月 31 日

(1) 重要会计政策与实务

(a) 合并基础

随附的合并财务报表包括伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司(“公司”或“伯克希尔”)及其所有子公司的账目。公司内部账户及交易均已抵消。

(b) 重述

为反映财务会计准则第 97 号公告的规定(该规定要求采用一步式收益表,将税前已实现投资损益作为单独项目列报),伯克希尔对前期合并财务报表进行了重述,以取代之前将税后经营利润与税后已实现投资损益分开列示的格式。重述后的净收益与原先报告的金额一致。

(c) 现金及现金等价物

现金等价物包括投资于货币市场账户以及购买时距到期日在三个月或以内的投资。

(d) 投资

固定到期日债券投资按成本或已摊销成本列账。伯克希尔·哈撒韦保险集团成员持有的可流通权益证券按市值列账。公司及非保险子公司持有的可流通权益证券按成本列账,该成本总额低于市值。见附注 4。

(e) 投资——出售

出售证券的成本通常按先进先出法确定。偶尔,当对出售的证券进行个别计价能降低应缴所得税时,则使用个别计价法。

(f) 购入企业的商誉及负商誉

购买成本与所购入企业净资产公允价值之间的差额,在四十年内按直线法摊销。未摊销净余额计入其他资产。

(g) 保险保费获取成本

出于财务报告目的,获取保险保费的某些成本予以递延(以最终可收回为限),并在保费赚取时计入费用。对于根据主要比例分保再保险合同收到的保费,在计算其直接相关获取成本的最终可收回性时,需考虑合同所持资金预期赚取的投资收益。除此之外,保费获取成本的最终可收回性在确定时不考虑投资收益。

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS and Subsidiaries December 31, 1989 (1) Significant accounting policies and practices (a) Basis of consolidation The accompanying Consolidated Financial Statements include the accounts of Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (the "Company" or "Berkshire") consolidated with accounts of all its su sidiaries. Intercompany accounts and transactions have been eliminated. (b) Restatements Berkshire's prior period consolidated financial statements are restated to reflect the applicabl statement of earnings in which pre-tax realized investment gains and losses are reported as rovisions of Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 97 which require a one-ste replaces the previously utilized form in which net-after-tax earnings as restated are unchanged from the amounts originally reported. operating earnings were shown separately from net-after-tax realized investment gains. Net (c) Cash Cash equivalents consist of funds invested in money market accounts and in investments with equivalents a maturity of three months or less when purchased. (d) Investments Investments in obligations with fixed maturities are carried at cost or adjusted cost. Marketable equity securities held by members of the Berkshire Hathaway Insurance Group are carried at market value. Marketable equity securities held by the Company and by non-insurance subsidiaries Note 4. are carried cost, which in the aggregate is less than market value. See (e) Investments - sales Cost of securities sold is usually determined on a first-in, first-out basis. Occasionally, when specific identification of securities sold results in lower applicable income taxes, identified cost is used. Goodwill and negative goodwill of acquired businesses The difference between purchase cost and the fair value of the net assets of acquired businesses is amortized on a straight line basis over forty years. The net unamortized balance is carried in other assets. (g) Insurance premium acquisition costs 'or financial reporting purposes, certain costs of acquiring insurance premiums are deferred suoject to ultimate recoverability, and charged to income as the premiums are earned. With cation of ultimate recoverability of the directly related acquisition cost takes into account espect to premiums received under major quota-share reinsurance contracts, the compu investment income anticipated to be earned on funds held subject to the contracts. Other- investment income. wise, ultimate recoverability of premium acquisition costs is determined without regard to 30

[第 33 页]

[PAGE 33]

(1)

重要会计政策与实务(续)

(h) 损失及损失理算费用

损失及损失理算费用的负债基于对已报告损失和已发生但未报告损失的未付金额的估计确定,这些估计旨在覆盖最终赔付金额减去再保险项下可回收金额。相关准备金按预期最终赔付金额的折现现值计提,但对于定期赔付义务(即“结构性结算”),其准备金的计提方式有所不同。结构性结算的预期最终赔付金额现值,在财务报告目的上,截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日确定为 197,090,000 美元,采用的折现率为合同起始日的市场利率(加权平均值为 9%,截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日)。结构性结算的净负债现值,在法定报告和税务报告目的上,截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日确定为 277,744,000 美元,采用的折现率为保险监管机构规定的利率——1986 年后生效的合同为 5%,1987 年前签订的合同为 7%。

(j) 保险保费

保险保费在保单有效期内按比例确认为收入。未到期保费按月或按日比例法计算,并在扣除分出给再保险公司的未到期保费后列示。保单持有人分红(金额不重大,过去三年每年均低于 5,000,000 美元)与参与型保单相关,在随附的合并收益表中作为已赚保费的减项列示。

(k) 所得税

某些收入项目和扣除项目在财务报表中的确认时间,与在公司合并联邦所得税申报表中确认的时间不同,由此在财务报表中产生递延所得税和预付所得税的确认。合并资产负债表的所得税负债包括适用于可交易权益证券账面价值中未实现增值部分的递延所得税。此类税款按 34% 的税率就 1986 年后产生的未实现增值计提,并按 28% 的税率就 1987 年前年份产生的增值计提。

1987 年,财务会计准则委员会发布了第 96 号公告《所得税会计》,要求自 1988 年 12 月 15 日之后开始的年度财务报表中实施该公告。随后,财务会计准则委员会两次发布公告推迟其生效日期,现要求在 1991 年 12 月 15 日之后开始的年度财务报表中实施。该公告要求采用“负债法”进行所得税会计处理,侧重于资产负债表。它取代了第 11 号会计原则委员会意见书《所得税会计》,后者要求采用“递延法”,侧重于收益表。虽允许提前采用,但公司尚未实施该公告的规定。若伯克希尔截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日的合并资产负债表中已反映“负债法”的变更,则股东权益总额将减少,减少范围约为 35,000,000 美元至 70,000,000 美元,具体金额取决于伯克希尔在允许的替代实施方法之间所作的选择。

(1) Significant accounting policies and practices (Continued) (h) Losses and loss adjustment expenses Liability for losses and loss adjustment expenses is determined on the basis of estimates of are intended to cover ultimate payment amounts less amounts recoverable on account of unpaid amounts with respect to both reported and incurred but not reported losses. Provisions are established at discounted present value of expected ultimate payment amounts reinsurance, except that provisions for periodic payment obligations ("structured settlements" Present value of expected ultimate payment amounts for structured settlements was determined for financial reporting purposes to be $197,090,000 as of December 31, 1989 applying, as average of which was 9% as of December 31, 1989. Present value of net liabilities for structured present value discount rates, the market interest rates at contract inception dates - the weighted settlements was determined for statutory and tax reporting purposes to be $277,744,000 as

  • 5% for contracts incepting after 1986, and 7% with respect to contracts dated prior to 1987.

of December 31, 1989 applying discount rates prescribed by insurance regulatory authority (j) Insurance premiums Insurance premiums are recognized as revenues ratably over the terms of the policies. Unearned premiums are computed on a monthly or daily pro rata basis and are stated after deduction of unearned premiums ceded to reinsurers. Policyholder dividends, immaterial in amount (less than $5,000,000 per year for each of the past three years), incurred with respect to participating policies are reflected in the accom- panying Consolidated Statements of Earnings as a deduction from earned premiums. (k) Income taxes Certain items of income and deductions are recognized in the financial statements in time periods income tax returns, giving rise to recognition in the financial statements to deferred and prepaid that differ from those in which they are recognized in the Company's consolidated Federal The liability for income taxes in the Consolidated Balance Sheets includes deferred taxes deemed income taxes. securities. Such taxes were accrued at a rate of 34% relative to increases in unrealized applicable to unrealized appreciation included in carrying value of marketable equity appreciation that arose subsequent to 1986 and at the rate of 28% relative to appreciation that arose in years prior to 1987. In 1987, the Financial Accounting Standards Board ("FASB") issued Statement No. 96 " Accounting for Income Taxes" and required its implementation in financial statements issued for years its effective date. Implementation is now required in financial statements for years beginning beginning after December 15, 1988. Subsequently, the FASB issued statements twice deferring after December 15, 1991. The statement requires the "liability method" of accounting for for Income Taxes" requiring the "deferred method", with an earnings statement focus. Although income taxes, with a balance sheet focus. It supersedes APB Opinion No. 11 "Accounting If change to the "liability method" were to have been reflected in Berkshire's consolidated early adoption is permitted, the Company has not yet implemented the statement's provisions. resulted. The approximate range of reduction would have been from $35,000,000 to balance sheet as of December 31, 1989, a reduction to total shareholders' equity would have $70,000,000, with the precise amount dependent upon Berkshire's selection between per- mitted alternative means of implementation. 31

[第 34 页]

[PAGE 34]

合并财务报表附注(续)

(2)

固定到期债券投资

1989 年和 1988 年 12 月 31 日,该账户包含的资产如下:

累积可转换优先股:

1989 年

1988 年

吉列公司

冠军国际公司

$

300,000,000

600,000,000

$

所罗门公司

美国航空集团公司

700,000,000

358,000,000

700,000,000

债券

其他优先股

832,397,000

5,191,000

15,072,000

$2,795,588,000

$1,815,321,000

1,100,249,000

冠军、吉列、所罗门公司及美国航空的优先股,以及投资组合中的部分债券,并无常规交易市场可提供其市场价值报价;但伯克希尔管理层认为,截至 1989 年和 1988 年 12 月 31 日,合并固定到期债券投资组合的总体市场价值均超过了总体成本。

累积可转换优先股投资

所罗门公司

1987 年 10 月 1 日,伯克希尔的子公司购买了所罗门公司(“所罗门”)新发行的 70 万股 9% 累积可转换优先股。这些股份以现金购买,每股面值 1000 美元,总价 7 亿美元。在提交所罗门股东表决的所有事项上,每股享有 26.31579 票投票权。截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日,这些优先股约占所罗门总投票权的 13%。1990 年 10 月 31 日,每股优先股可转换为 26.31579 股所罗门缴足普通股。自 1995 年起,每年 10 月 31 日,所罗门将以成本价赎回 14 万股,或当时流通在外的较少数量的股份。

吉列公司

1989 年 7 月 20 日,伯克希尔的子公司以每股 1000 美元的现金价格——总额 6 亿美元——购买了吉列公司(“吉列”)新发行的 60 万股 B 系列累积可转换优先股,股息按年利率每股 87.50 美元累积。在提交吉列股东表决的所有事项上,每股享有 20 票投票权。截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日,这些优先股约占吉列总投票权的 11%。1991 年 7 月 20 日至 1999 年 7 月 20 日期间,每股可转换为 20 股普通股。在此期间,吉列可按每股 1100 美元的价格赎回这些股份。若既未赎回也未转换,则吉列必须在 1999 年 7 月 20 日按每股 1000 美元的价格赎回到期股份。

美国航空集团公司

1989 年 8 月 7 日,伯克希尔的子公司以每股 1000 美元的现金价格——总额 3.58 亿美元——购买了美国航空集团公司(“美国航空”)新发行的 35.8 万股 A 系列可转换优先股。股息按年利率每股 92.50 美元累积。在提交美国航空股东表决的所有事项上,每股享有 16 2/3 票投票权。截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日,该系列优先股的合计投票权约占美国航空总投票权的 11%。自 1991 年 8 月 7 日起的 8 年内,每股优先股可转换为 16 2/3 股普通股,并且美国航空可按每股 1100 美元的价格赎回这些股份。若既未赎回也未转换,则股份必须在 1999 年 8 月 7 日按其发行价格赎回。

(d) 冠军国际公司

1989 年 12 月 6 日,伯克希尔的子公司以每股 1000 美元的现金价格——总额 3 亿美元——购买了冠军国际公司(“冠军”)新发行的 30 万股优先股。年股息累积率为每股 92.50 美元,在提交冠军股东表决的所有事项上,每股享有 26.31579 票投票权。截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日,该系列优先股的合计投票权约占冠军总投票权的 8%。每股优先股可随时转换为 26.31579 股冠军普通股。冠军有权在 1999 年 12 月 6 日之前的任何时间,按每股 1150 美元的价格赎回这些股份。若股份未被赎回或转换,则冠军必须在 1999 年 12 月 6 日按发行价格赎回到期股份。

Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements (Continued) (2) Investment in obligations with fixed maturities Assets comprising this account at December 31, 1989 and 1988 were as follows: Cumulative convertible preferred stocks: 1989 1988 The Gillette Company.. Champion International Corporation. $ 300,000,000 600,000,000 $ Salomon Inc USAir Group, Inc. 700,000,000 358,000,000 700,000,000 Bonds Other preferred stocks 832,397,000 5,191,000 15,072,000 $2,795,588,000 $1,815,321,000 1,100,249,000 the Champion, Gillette, Salomon Inc and USAir preferred shares nor for some of the bond issues represented There is no regular trading market from which quotations of market value might be obtained for in the portfolio; but Berkshire management believes that aggregate market value of the consolidated portfolio of fixed maturity obligations exceeded aggregate cost at both December 31, 1989 and 1988. Investments in cumulative convertible preferred stocks Salomon Inc On October 1, 1987, subsidiaries of Berkshire purchased a new issue of 700.000 shares of 9% Cumulative Convertible Preferred Stock of Salomon Inc ("Salomon"). These shares were purchased for cash at their par value of $1,000 per share and $700,000,000 in the aggregate. shareholders. At December 31, 1989, the preferred shares possessed approximately 13% of Each share is entitled to 26.31579 votes on all matters submitted to a vote of Salomon total Salomon voting rights. On October 31, 1990, each preferred share becomes convertible commencing in 1995, Salomon will redeem, at cost, 140,000 of the shares or such fewer into 26.31579 fully paid common shares of Salomon. Annually on each October 31, The Gillette Company number as are then outstanding. On July 20, 1989, subsidiaries of Berkshire purchased an issue of 600,000 shares of Series B of $1,000 per share - $600,000,000 in the aggregate - with respect to which dividends accrue Cumulative Convertible Preferred Stock of The Gillette Company ("Gillette") at a cash price to a vote of Gillette shareholders and at December 31, 1989 the preferred shares possessed at the annual rate of $87.50 per share. Each share is entitled to 20 votes on all matters submitted approximately 11% of total Gillette voting rights. On July 20, 1991 and until July 20, 1999, may call the shares for redemption at $1,100 per share. If neither called nor converted then each share may be converted into 20 shares of common stock. Also during this period, Gillette USAir Group, Inc. Gillette must redeem the shares on July 20, 1999 at $1,000 per share. On August 7, 1989, subsidiaries of Berkshire purchased 358,000 shares of newly issued Series A Convertible Preferred Stock of USAir Group, Inc. ("USAir") at a cash price of $1,000 per Each of these shares is entitled to 16 2/3 votes on all matters submitted to a vote of USAir share -$358,000,000 in the aggregate. Dividends accrue at an annual rate of $92.50 per share. of total USAir voting rights. During the eight years beginning August 7, 1991 each preferred shareholders. At December 31, 1989 the aggregate voting rights of the issue represented 11% redemption at $1,100 per share. If neither called nor converted, the shares must be redeemed share will be convertible into 16 2/3 common shares and USAir may call the shares for (d) Champion International Corporation on August 7, 1999 at their issue price. On December 6, 1989, subsidiaries of Berkshire purchased a new issue of 300,000 shares of purchased for cash at a price of $1,000 per share - $300,000,000 in the aggregate. The annual Preference Stock of Champion International Corporation ("Champion"). These shares were dividend accrual rate is $92.50 per share and each share is entitled to 26.31579 votes on aggregate voting rights of the issue represented approximately 8% of total Champion voting all matters submitted to a vote of shareholders of Champion. At December 31, 1989, the of Champion. Champion has the right to redeem the shares at any time prior to December rights. Each preference share may be converted at any time into 26.31579 common shares redeem them on December 6, 1999 at their issue price. 6, 1999 at $1,150 per share. If the shares are not called or converted, then Champion must

[第 35 页]

[PAGE 35]

(4) 投资于有价权益证券

下表为所示日期未合并投资于有价权益证券的情况:

1989 年 12 月 31 日

普通股:成本未实现收益市值账面价值
大都会/美国广播公司517,500,000 美元569,250,000 美元1,086,750,000 美元1,077,262,000 美元
GEICO 公司45,713,000 美元803,687,000 美元849,400,000 美元632,448,000 美元
可口可乐公司1,023,919,000 美元668,456,000 美元1,692,375,000 美元1,672,794,000 美元
《华盛顿邮报》公司9,731,000 美元476,635,000 美元486,366,000 美元486,366,000 美元
所有其他有价权益证券217,797,000 美元136,008,000 美元353,805,000 美元255,818,000 美元
合计1,814,660,000 美元2,654,036,000 美元4,468,696,000 美元4,124,688,000 美元

1988 年 12 月 31 日

普通股:成本未实现收益市值账面价值
大都会/美国广播公司517,500,000 美元569,250,000 美元1,086,750,000 美元1,077,262,000 美元
GEICO 公司45,713,000 美元803,687,000 美元849,400,000 美元632,448,000 美元
可口可乐公司1,023,919,000 美元668,456,000 美元1,692,375,000 美元1,672,794,000 美元
《华盛顿邮报》公司9,731,000 美元476,635,000 美元486,366,000 美元486,366,000 美元
RJR 纳贝斯克公司1,174,875,000 美元779,868,000 美元1,954,743,000 美元1,691,624,000 美元
所有其他有价权益证券173,094,000 美元115,889,000 美元288,983,000 美元255,818,000 美元
合计2,944,832,000 美元3,413,605,000 美元6,358,437,000 美元5,816,312,000 美元

表中“所有其他有价权益证券”类别所包含的若干股票,其未实现收益已扣除名义未实现亏损后列示。

(5) 投资于大都会/美国广播公司股份

伯克希尔子公司持有的大都会/美国广播公司普通股,在 1989 年 12 月 31 日拥有约 17% 的大都会已发行股份投票权。这些股份受一份协议约束,该协议授予大都会一项优先购买权,并规定了在 1997 年 1 月 3 日之前这些股份的出售或转让方式。此外,伯克希尔及其子公司已将这些股份的不可撤销投票代理权交付给托马斯·S·墨菲(只要他担任大都会首席执行官),或丹尼尔·B·伯克(只要他担任大都会首席执行官),以便其在大都会任何及所有股东会议上行使投票权。该代理权于 1997 年 1 月 2 日或此二人均不再担任大都会首席执行官之日的较早时间失效。

(6) 投资于 GEICO 公司

伯克希尔子公司在 1989 年 12 月 31 日和 1988 年 12 月 31 日均持有 6,850,000 股 GEICO 公司普通股。这些股份在 1989 年 12 月 31 日拥有 GEICO 全部已发行股份约 45% 的投票权,但伯克希尔保持一项独立的代理投票安排,该安排应 GEICO 所在州保险监管机构命令的要求而设立。该命令源自伯克希尔子公司于 1976 年大规模购入这些股份,禁止伯克希尔寻求或促成更改该独立代理权。此外,根据该命令,伯克希尔或其任何关联公司或子公司的任何董事或高级管理人员不得担任 GEICO 的董事。由于该命令剥夺了伯克希尔对这些股份的投票权,伯克希尔并未对其在 GEICO 的投资采用权益法进行会计处理。

(4) Investments in marketable equity securities securities. elow so the dates indicated to No consolated investment in a deal guy scurie hom December 31, 1989 Common stock of: Cost Unrealized Gain Market Carrying Value Capital Cities/ABC, Inc.. GEICO Corporation. The Coca-Cola Company. $ 1,023,919,000 517,500,000 $ 1,174,875,000 779,868,000 $ 1,692,375,000 $ 1,672,794,000 All other marketable equity securities The Washington Post Company.... 45,713,000 9,731,000 998,912,000 476,635,000 486,366,000 1,044,625,000 217,797,000 136,008,000 353,805,000 255,818,000 486,366,000 $1,814,660,000 $3,566,298,000 $5,380,958.000 $5,261,598,000 December 31, 1988 Cost Unrealized Gain Market Carrying Common stock of: Value Capital Cities/ABC, Inc. GEICO Corporation. The Coca-Cola Company.. $ 517,500,000 592,540,000 $ 569,250,000 281,765,000 45,713,000 803,687,000 39,908,000 $ 1,086,750,000 $ 1,077,262,000 632,448,000 632,448,000 The Washington Post Company ..... RJR Nabisco Inc. .... 288,000,000 9,731,000 354,395,000 22,775,000 849,400,000 304,540,000 849,400,000 304,180,000 All other marketable equity securities 97,653,000 385,653,000 364,126,000 331,308,000 364,126,000 $1,735,249,000 $1,887,668,000 $3,622,917,000 $3,558,724,000 category captioned "All other marketable equity securities." Unrealized gain is shown net of nominal unrealized loss as to certain stocks included above in the (5) Investment in shares of Capital Cities/ABC, Inc. Common shares of Capital Cities/ABC, Inc. ("Capital Cities") owned by Berkshire subsidiaries 31, 1989. The shares are held subject to an Agreement the terms of which grant to Capital Cities a right possessed approximately 17% of the voting rights of all Capital Cities shares outstanding at December the shares may be sold or transferred. Also, Berkshire and its subsidiaries have delivered to Capital Cities of first refusal to purchase the shares and otherwise govern until January 3, 1997 the manner by which irrevocable proxies with respect to these shares in favor of Thomas S. Murphy so long as he shall be the chief executive officer of Capital Cities, or Daniel B. Burke so long as he shall be the chief executive proxies expire on January 2, 1997 or at the earlier date when neither of such persons is chief executive officer of Capital Cities, to vote the shares at any and all meetings of shareholders of Capital Cities. The officer of Capital Cities. (6) Investment in GEICO Corporation shares of common stock of GEICO Corporation. The shares possessed approximately 45% of the voting Subsidiaries of Berkshire, at both December 31, 1989 and at December 31, 1988, owned 6,850,000 proxy arrangement for voting of the shares as required by Order of GEICO's domiciliary insurance super- rights of all GEICO shares outstanding at December 31, 1989, but Berkshire maintains an independent visory authority. The Order, dating from Berkshire subsidiaries' major purchase of the shares in 1976, no officer or director of Berkshire or of any affiliate or subsidiary of Berkshire is permitted to serve as prohibits Berkshire from seeking or causing to change the independent proxy. Also, under the Order, a director of GEICO. Because the Order divests Berkshire of its voting rights with respect to the shares, Berkshire does not use the equity method of accounting for its investment in GEICO. 33

[第 36 页]

[PAGE 36]

合并财务报表附注(续)

(7)贷款及应收账款

贷款及应收账款构成如下:

1989 年 12 月 31 日1988 年 12 月 31 日
贸易应收账款$257,776,000$234,009,000
Mutual 储蓄与贷款协会(“Mutual”)的贷款,主要与房地产相关153,755,000136,970,000
购入的分期应收款69,479,00069,229,000
保险集团成员欠款,主要为保费42,583,00031,170,000
Scott Fetzer 金融集团(“SFF”)63,275,00043,168,000
应收已计投资收入36,906,00033,259,000
证券出售应收款1,100,784,000548,470,000
合计$1,724,558,000$1,096,275,000

(8)所得税

附列合并资产负债表中所反映的所得税负债,代表以下各项负债的估计金额:

1989 年 12 月 31 日1988 年 12 月 31 日
当期应付$ 46,758,000$ 36,906,000
递延,涉及有价权益证券未实现增值1,100,784,000548,470,000
递延(预付),源于时间性差异(8,652,000)3,677,000
合计$1,138,890,000$ 589,053,000

合并利润表反映的所得税费用如下所示:

1989 年1988 年1987 年
联邦$ 142,996,000$ 122,492,000$ 56,597,000
15,514,00015,871,000777,000
外国777,0002,428,0001,391,000
合计$159,287,000$140,791,000$ 58,765,000
当期应付税款$171,616,000$149,835,000$122,351,000
递延税款净额增加(减少)(12,329,000)(9,044,000)(52,812,000)
合计$159,287,000$140,791,000$ 69,539,000

递延税款净额增加(减少)分别代表以下时间性差异的税务影响:

1989 年1988 年1987 年
递延保险保费获取成本$ (10,363,000)$ (7,377,000)$ (13,577,000)
结构性结算负债5,607,0004,714,0006,902,000
损失及损失调整费用准备金的折现(7,752,000)(3,588,000)(10,988,000)
分期应收款递延毛利(4,610,000)(37,692,000)2,488,000
其他,净额3,767,0007,029,000(37,637,000)
合计$(12,329,000)$(9,044,000)$(52,812,000)

所得税费用与按联邦法定税率计算的假设金额之间的调节如下表所示:

1989 年1988 年1987 年
税前净利润$617,224,000$550,121,000$310,511,000
按联邦法定税率计算的假设金额(1989 年和 1988 年为 34%,1987 年为 40%)$ 209,856,000$ 187,041,000$ 124,204,000
减少项:
股息收入扣除(26,735,000)(33,477,000)(21,461,000)
免税利息收入(36,065,000)(1,991,000)(40,501,000)
州所得税(扣除联邦所得税收益后)10,240,00010,597,00010,830,000
其他净差异1,909,000(10,265,000)6,931,000
所得税费用合计$159,287,000$140,791,000$ 69,539,000

Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements (Continued) (7) Loans and accounts receivable Loans and accounts receivable represent the following: Dec. 31, 1989 Dec. 31, Trade accounts receivable. 1988 Loans of Mutual Savings and Loan Association ("Mutual"), $257,776,000 $234,009,000 stallment receivables purchased 1 rincipally real estate. 153,755,000 136,970,000 Due Insurance Group members, principally premiums.. Scott Fetzer Financial Group ("SFF") 69,479,000 Investment income due and accrued 42,583,000 69,229,000 Amounts due from sales of securities 31,170,000 43,168,000 63,275,000 33,259,000 (8) Income taxes $554,763.000 $579,910,000 represent estimates of liabilities as follows: The liability for income taxes as reflected in the accompanying Consolidated Balance Sheets Dec. 31, 36,906,000 1989 Dec. 31, ( Payable currently Deferred, relating to unrealized appreciation $ $ 46,758,000 1988 Deferred (prepaid arising from of marketable equity securities... 1,100,784,000 548,470,000 timing difference (8,652,000) 3,677,000 $1,129,038,000 $ 598,905,000 The Consolidated Statements of Earnings reflect charges for income taxes as shown below: Federal 1989 State .. $ 142,996,000 $ 122,492,000 1988 $ 1987 Foreign 15,514,000 15,871,000 56,597,000 777,000 2,428,000 11,551,000 $159,287,000 1,391,000 Taxes payable currently... $140,791,000 $ 69,539,000 Increase (decrease) in net deferred taxes .. $ 171,616,000 (12,329,000) $ 149,835,000 (9,044,000) $ 122,351,000 $159,287,000 52,812,000) $140,791,000 The increase (decrease) in net deferred taxes represent the tax effects of timing differences as follows: $69,539,000 Deferred insurance premium acquisition costs........ Applicable to: ... $ (10,363,000) 1989 $(7,377,000) 1988 1987 Structured settlement liabilities... 5,607,000 $ (13,577,000) Discounting of losses and loss adjustment expense reserves 6,902,000 4,714,000 Deferred gross profit on installment receivables.... (7,752,000) (3,588,000) (10,988,000) (4,610,000) (37,692,000) Other, net 3,767,000 7,029,000 2,488,000 (8,745,000) $(12,329,000) $(9,044,000) Charges for income taxes are reconciled in the table which follows to hypothetical amounts computed $(52,812,000) at the Federal statutory rate: Net earnings before income taxes..... .... $617,224,000 1989 $550,121,000 1988 $310,511,000 1987 Hypothetical amounts applicable to above computed at the Federal statutory rate Decreases, resulting from: (34% in 1989 and 1988, 40% in 1987) ... $ 209,856,000 $ 187,041,000 $ 124,204,000 Dividends received deduction Tax-exempt interest income .. (26,735,000) Net other differences. State income taxes, less Federal income tax benefit... (36,065,000) 33,477,000) 1,991,000 10,240,000 (21,461,000) (40,501,000) 10,597,000 10,830,000) Total income taxes (1,909,000) 6,931,000 .... $159,287,000 $140,791,000 (10,265,000) $ 69,539,000 34

[第 37 页]

[PAGE 37]

(9)长期债务及其他借款,截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日与 1988 年 12 月 31 日

下表列示了公司及其子公司的长期债务及其他借款情况:

1989 年1988 年
10% 债券,2018 年 1 月 1 日到期,可赎回
零息可转换次级债券,2004 年到期405,683,000 美元
通过偿债基金运作,自 1999 年起每年偿还 7,500,000 美元
9 3/4% 债券,2018 年 1 月 15 日到期,可赎回150,000,000 美元150,000,000 美元
通过偿债基金运作,自 1999 年起每年偿还 5,000,000 美元
0.7% 贷款,1993 年 8 月 1 日或根据提前要求偿还100,000,000 美元
其他票据,1993 年前到期109,120,000 美元100,000,000 美元
9,396,000 美元
子公司774,199,000 美元11,316,000 美元
261,316,000 美元
10% 票据,分年偿还,每年 2,625,000 美元
8.125% 票据,1996 年到期120,000,000 美元120,000,000 美元
1998 年 8 月 31 日
至 1997 年,最后付款 2,750,000 美元
9 1/2% 票据,分年偿还,每年 2,500,000 美元23,750,000 美元26,375,000 美元
8 7/8% 票据,1999 年到期
至 1998 年30,000,000 美元22,500,000 美元
25,000,000 美元
联邦住宅贷款银行预付款,1994 年 8 月到期,利率 8.73%25,000,000 美元
10 1/8% 票据,原定 1991 年到期,1989 年再融资
其他票据,2014 年前到期20,167,000 美元
16,900,000 美元
22,318,000 美元
合计1,007,516,000 美元480,009,000 美元

零息可转换次级债券于 1989 年 9 月 28 日发行,发行价格为其面值(总计 902,640,000 美元)的 44.314%。发行价格反映了原始发行折价率和 5.5% 的年化到期收益率;期间无定期利息支付。每份面值 10,000 美元的债券可随时转换为 0.4515 股普通股,持有人若在转换时获得零碎股份,将收到相当于该零碎股份当时市值的现金。转换率仅在影响普通股的某些稀释事件发生时进行调整。公司可在 1992 年 9 月 28 日之后的任何时间以现金赎回债券。持有人可要求公司在 1994 年 9 月 28 日和 1999 年 9 月 28 日以现金购买其持有的债券。购买或赎回价格为发行价加上累计原始发行折价。各项借款协议中均不含重大限制性契约。

截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日未偿还借款的未来五年内所需本金偿还额如下表所示。金额已按管理工具的提前还款选择权进行了调整。

1990 年1991 年1992 年1993 年1994 年
11,731,000 美元8,028,000 美元8,043,000 美元118,860,000 美元22,892,000 美元

(9) Term debt and other borrowings at December 31, 1989 and 1988. The following table sets forth the term debt and other borrowings of the Company and its subsidiaries 1989 1988 10% Debentures due January 1, 2018, redeemable Zero Coupon Convertible Subordinated Notes Due 2004... $ 405,683,000 $ annual repayments of $7,500,000 beginning in 1999 through operation of a sinking fund which calls for 9 3/4% Debentures due January 15, 2018, redeemable 150,000,000 150,000,000 through operation of sinking fund which calls for .7% Loan repayable August 1, 1993 or at earlier deman‹ nnual repayments of $5,000,000 beginning in 1999 ... 100,000,000 Other notes, payable through 1993 .. 109,120,000 100,000,000 9,396,000 Subsidiaries 774,199,000 11,316,000 261,316,000 10% Notes, payable in annual installments of $2,625,000 8.125% Notes, payable in 1996 120,000,000 120,000,000 on August 31, 1998 through 1997 with a final payment of $2,750,000 9 1/2% Notes, payable in annual installments of $2,500,000 23,750,000 26,375,000 8 7/8% Notes, payable in 1999..... through 1998. 30,000,000 22,500,000 25,000,000 Federal Home Loan Bank advance, due August 1994, 10 1/8% Notes, originally due in 1991, refunded in 1989.. 25,000,000 Other notes maturing through 2014 bearing interest at 8.73%... _ 20,167,000 16,900,000 22,318.000 $1,007,516,000 $480,009,000 at 44.314% of their face value which totaled $902,640,000. The issue price reflected an original issue The Zero Coupon Convertible Subordinated Notes Due 2004 were issued on September 28, 1989 discount rate and yield to maturity of 5.5% per annum; there will be no periodic payments of interest. Company into 0.4515 shares of common stock. A holder entitled upon conversion to a fractional share Each $10,000 face amount note may be converted at any time prior to redemption or purchase by the of common stock shall receive cash equal to the then current market value of such fractional share. The conversion rate will be adjusted only upon occurrence of certain dilutive events affecting the common require the Company to purchase any of its holdings on September 28, 1994 and again on September stock. The Company may redeem the notes for cash at any time after September 28, 1992. A holder may 28, 1999. The price at which notes will be purchased or redeemed will be issue price plus accrued original No materially restrictive covenants are included in any of the various borrowing Agreements. ive years as shown in the table immediately below. Amounts have been determined without regard t Principal payments on borrowings outstanding at December 31, 1989 are required during the succeeding optional repayment provisions of the governing instruments. 1991 1990 $ 11,731,000 8,028,000 1992 8,043,000 1993. 118,860,000 1994. 22,892,000 35

[第 38 页]

[PAGE 38]

合并财务报表附注(续)

(10)股东权益账户

最近三年内股东权益账户的变动如下:

未实现增值额留存收益库存股
1986 年 12 月 31 日余额$ 874,813,000$ 1,379,669,000$ 40,938,000
349,147,000
1987 年净收益
所得税(119,837,000)
1987 年 12 月 31 日余额1,104,123,0001,614,221,000234,552,000
40,938,000
1988 年计入有价证券账面价值的未实现增值额增加259,486,000
1988 年认定适用的所得税变动(88,763,000)
1988 年净收益399,270,000
未实现增值额增加(189,000)
因终止养老金计划收到的伯克希尔股票价值(附注 12)1,355,000
1988 年 12 月 31 日余额1,274,657,0002,013,491,00042,293,000
1989 年计入有价证券账面价值的未实现增值额增加1,623,462,000
1989 年认定适用的所得税变动(552,314,000)
少数股东权益增加(3,607,000)
1989 年净收益447,477,000
1989 年 12 月 31 日余额$ 2,342,198,000$ 2,460,968,000$ 42,293,000

(11)利息和股息收入

过去三年每年的利息和股息收入构成如下:

利息收入源自:1989 年1988 年1987 年
投资证券$ 114,928,000$ 164,499,000$ 149,534,000
贷款和融资应收款50,904,00051,135,00051,271,000
102,181,00063,439,00034,965,000
63,652,00017,241,00019,273,000
合计$ 331,452,000$ 314,251,000$ 237,319,000

(12)1989 年和 1988 年的杂项收入分别约为 53,000 美元和 16,366,000 美元,这些金额代表公司及其部分子公司因终止超拨养老金计划而收回的现金和有价证券的大致公允价值。

(13)利息费用

利息费用由 Mutual 储蓄账户利息及债务利息构成,详情如下:

1989 年1988 年1987 年
Mutual 储蓄账户利息$ 21,261,000$ 20,579,000$ 20,903,000
SFFG 债务利息599,000
Mutual 债务利息
其他债务利息42,389,00035,613,00011,474,000
13,325,00014,088,00015,060,000
合计$ 77,574,000$ 70,280,000$ 47,437,000

Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements (Continued) (10) Shareholders' equity accounts Changes in Shareholders' Equity accounts during the most recent three years were as follows: Net Unrealized Retained Appreciation Earnings Treasury Stock Balance at December 31, 1986..... ... $ 874,813,000 $ 1,379,669,000 $ 40,938,000 349,147,000 Net earnings 1987 income taxes '.... (119,837,000) Balance at December 31, 1987... .... ... 1,104,123,000 1,614,221,000 234,552,000 .. L 40,938,000 Increase during 1988 in unrealized appreciation included in carrying value of marketable Change during 1988 in deemed applicable equity securities.. •... 259,486,000 Increase in minority shareholders' interest income taxes... ••.. (88,763,000) Net earnings 1988 in unrealized appreciation (189,000) Value of Berkshire stock received in connection 399,270,000 with termination of pension plans (note 12).. ....• 1,355,000 Increase during 1989 in unrealized Balance at December 31, 1988. appreciation .... 1,274,657,000 2,013,491,000 42,293,000 equity securities.. included in carrying value of marketable Change during 1989 in deemed applicable ...... 1,623,462,000 Increase in minority shareholders' interest income taxes …... ..... (552,314,000) Net earnings 1989 ... in unrealized appreciation .... .... (3,607,000) 447,477,000 Balance December 31, 1989 $2,342,198,000 $2,460,968,000 (11) Interest and dividend income $ 42,293,000 Interest and dividend income for each of the past three years were comprised of the following: Interest earned with respect to: 1989 1988 1987 Investment securities... Loans and financed receivables $ 114,928,000 50,904,000 $ 164,499,000 51,135,000 $ 149,534,000 51,271,000 102,181,000 63,439,000 34,965,000 63,652,000 17,241,000 19,273,000 $331,452,000 (12) Sundry income for 1989 and 1988 includes approximately $53,000 and 516,366,000 respectively. $314,251,000 $237,319,000 which represents the approximate fair value of cash and securities that reverted to the Company and to certain of its subsidiaries upon termination of overfunded pension plans. (13) Interest expense follows: Interest expense is comprised of interest on savings accounts of Mutual plus interest on debt as Savings accounts of Mutua 1989 1988 Debt of SFFG. Debt of Mutua $ 21,261,000 1987 599,000 $ 20,579,000 $ 20,903,000 Other debt ... 42,389,000 13,325,000 35,613,000 14,088,000 11,474,000 15,060,000 36 $77,574,000 $70,280,000 $47,437,000

[第 39 页]

[PAGE 39]

(14) 股息限制——保险子公司

未经 1990 年的监管批准,伯克希尔可从保险子公司收到的股息最高约为 5.809 亿美元。保险集团成员支付股息受到保险法规的限制。根据法定会计原则(保单持有人法定盈余)计算的保险子公司合并股东权益,在 1989 年 12 月 31 日约为 60 亿美元。这一金额比按公认会计原则确定的相应金额高出约 10 亿美元;差额主要来自递延所得税负债——这些负债在财务报告上已被确认,但在法定报告上尚未确认。

(15) 业务分部数据

1989 年,伯克希尔拥有七个可报告业务分部,定义见财务会计准则委员会第 14 号公告。这与 1988 年相同。各分部的主要活动/产品/服务如下:

分部活动/产品/服务
保险财产/意外保险及再保险
糖果盒装巧克力及其他糖果产品
报纸出版《布法罗新闻》,一份日报和周日版报纸
家居用品零售地毯、家具、家电、电子产品及相关产品
百科全书编纂、出版和销售《世界百科全书》及其他教育类参考著作
家用清洁系统主要制造和分销 Kirby 品牌的家用清洁系统及产品
制服制造和分销制造和分销制服、裤子、夹克、衬衫和帽子

下表列出了这三个最新年份的分部数据。

收入

分部198919881987
保险865,026,000943,873,0001,003,821,000
糖果186,053,000135,647,000168,166,000
报纸338,397,000156,762,000131,664,000
家居用品零售157,391,000152,541,000122,955,000
百科全书549,118,000337,990,000145,997,000
家用清洁系统93,930,000144,145,000325,772,000
制服制造和分销494,000,000471,434,00074,734,000
合计2,483,892,0002,464,893,0002,431,782,000

(14) Dividend restrictions - insurance subsidiaries Without prior regulatory approval in 1990, Berkshire can receive up to approximately $580,900,000 as Payments of dividends by Insurance Group members are restricted by insurance statutes and regulations. dividends from insurance subsidiaries. rules (Statutory Surplus as Regards Policyholders) was approximately $6,000,000,000 at December 31, Combined shareholder's equity of insurance subsidiaries determined pursuant to statutory accounting on the basis of generally accepted accounting principles; the difference is principally represented by deferred 1989. This amount exceeded by approximately $1,000,000,000 the corresponding amounts determined .. L income tax liabilities recognized for financial reporting purposes but not for statutory reporting purposes. (15) Business segment data Board Statement No. 14. This is unchanged from 1988. The principle activity/product/service of each In 1989, Berkshire had seven reportable business segments as defined in Financial Accounting Standards Segment Activity/product/service Insurance Property/casualty insurance and reinsurance. Candy Boxed chocolates and other confectionery products. Newspaper Publication of the Buffalo News, a daily and Sunday newspaper. Retailing of home furnishings products. Carpet, furniture, appliances, electronics and related Encyclopedias, other reference materials encyclopedias and other educational and reference works. Composition, publication and marketing of World Book Home cleaning systems Manufacture and distribution of principally Kirby branded home cleaning systems and products. Uniform manufacturing and distribution jackets, shirts, and caps. Manufacture and distribution of uniforms, trousers, The tables which follow reflect data for those segments for each of the three most recent years. Revenues 1989 1988 1987 Insurance ... $ 865,026,000 Candy ..... 186,053,000 $ 943,873,000 135,647,000 168,166,000 $ 1,003,821,000 338,397,000 156,762,000 131,664,000 157,391,000 152,541,000 122,955,000 Home cleaning systems.. 158,959,000 337,990,000 145,997,000 Karents a tan to aid ego. ... 549,118,000 93,930,000 144,145,000 325,772,000 494,000,000 92,514,000 129,678,000 471,434,000 74,734,000 $2,483,892,000 $2,464,893,000 $2,431,782,000 37

[第 40 页]

[PAGE 40]

合并财务报表附注(续)

(15) 业务分部数据(续)

税前经营利润

198919881987
保险$ 439,223,000$ 347,900,000$ 122,985,000
糖果45,448,00031,498,00016,624,000
家居用品零售33,260,00041,830,00030,718,000
报纸25,332,00017,994,00038,811,000
百科全书及其他参考材料26,188,00027,639,00016,328,000
家用清洁系统11,899,00027,210,00025,494,000
制服制造和分销13,425,00023,325,00012,613,000
未分配至分部的税前经营利润 (a)70,798,00086,958,00060,029,000
未分配的公司费用(42,389,000)(35,613,000)(11,474,000)
债务利息 (a)(9,159,000)(8,720,000)(8,318,000)
合计$617,224,000$550,121,000$310,511,000

(a) 金融与储蓄贷款业务的利息费用已从未分配至分部的税前利润中扣除。因此,此类利息不包含在债务利息中。

资本支出

198919881987
保险$ 3,882,000$ 838,000$ 804,000
报纸525,000971,0003,509,000
糖果2,247,000988,0004,758,000
家居用品零售3,552,0002,037,0001,266,000
家用清洁系统11,191,000329,0003,103,000
百科全书及其他参考材料17,897,0002,272,0002,370,000
制服制造和分销1,320,000376,0005,418,000
其他2,203,0005,155,000981,000
合计$ 42,537,000$17,692,000$17,763,000

有形资产折旧与摊销

198919881987
保险$ 3,574,000$ 722,000$ 648,000
百科全书及其他参考材料1,745,0002,757,0002,836,000
家居用品零售3,392,0003,200,0001,612,000
报纸2,115,0003,274,0002,575,000
家用清洁系统746,0001,515,000770,000
制服制造和分销13,589,00013,421,0001,698,000
糖果2,627,00013,960,0001,192,000
其他1,698,0001,192,0001,192,000
合计$ 28,721,000$ 27,002,000$ 26,821,000

年末可辨认资产

1989 年 12 月 31 日1988 年 12 月 31 日1987 年 12 月 31 日
保险$ 7,871,097,000$ 5,421,195,000$ 4,519,657,000
报纸66,278,00048,917,00064,304,000
糖果103,159,00071,107,00050,755,000
百科全书及其他参考材料64,742,00070,660,00054,326,000
家居用品零售70,597,00060,147,00045,675,000
家用清洁系统85,675,00071,461,00080,318,000
制服制造和分销73,009,00061,595,00046,191,000
其他1,168,292,0001,005,575,000964,945,000
合计$9,459,594,000$6,816,848,000$5,863,235,000

Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements (Continued) (15) Business segment data (continued) Operating profit before taxes 1989 1988 1987 Candy.... Insurance. $ 439,223,000 Retailing of home furnishings .. Newspaper. 45,448,000 33,260,000 $ 347,900,000 31,498,000 $ 122,985,000 Encyclopedias, other reference materials 16,624,000 41,830,000 30,718,000 Home cleaning systems .... 25,332,000 17,994,000 38,811,000 Pre-tax operating profits not identified with Uniform manufacturing and distribution... 26,188,000 27,639,000 16,328,000 11,899,000 27,210,000 25,494,000 13,425,000 23,325,000 12,613,000 Unallocated corporate costs segments (a)... 70,798,000 Interest on debt (a). (42,389,000) (9,159,000) 86,958,000 (35,613,000) (8,720,000) 60,029,000 (11,474,000) (8,318,000) $617,224,000 $550,121,000 $310,511,000 (a) Interest expense of finance and savings and loan operations has been deducted in determining pre-tax profits not identified with segments. Accordingly, such interest is not included in interest on debt. Capital expenditures 1989 1988 1987 Insurance Newspaper Candy. $ 3,882,000 525,000 $ 838,000 Retailing of home furnishings... 971,000 3,509,000 $ 804,000 Home cleaning systems.. Encyclopedias, other reference materials 2,247,000 988,000 4,758,000 3,552,000 2,037,000 1,266,000 Uniform manufacturing and distribution 11,191,000 329,000 3,103,000 Other 17,897,000 2,272,000 2,370,000 1,320,000 376,000 5,418,000 2,203,000 5,155,000 981,000 $ 42,537,000 $17,692,000 $17,763,000 Depreciation and amortization of tangible assets 1989 1988 1987 Insurance $ 3,574,000 918,000 $ 722,000 Encyclopedias, other reference materials Retailing of home furnishings.... 1,745,000 2,757,000 2,836,000 3,392,000 3,200,000 648,000 Home cleaning systems.. 749,000 1,612,000 2,909,000 Other Uniform manufacturing and distribution 2,115,000 3,274,000 2,575,000 746,000 1,515,000 770,000 13,589,000 13,421,000 1,698,000 2,627,000 13,960,000 1,192,000 $ 28,721,000 $ 27,002,000 $.26,821,000 Identifiable assets at year-end Dec. 31, 1989 Dec. 31, 1988 Dec. 31, 1987 Insurance $ 7,871,097,000 Newspaper Candy. 66,278,000 $ 5,421,195,000 48,917,000 64,304,000 $ 4,519,657,000 Encyclopedias, other reference materials Retailing of home furnishings.. 103,159,000 71,107,000 50,755,000 64,742,000 70,660,000 54,326,000 Home cleaning systems.. Uniform manufacturing and distribution. 70,597,000 60,147,000 45,675,000 85,675,000 71,461,000 80,318,000 Other... 1,168,292,000 1,005,575,000 73,009,000 61,595,000 46,191,000 964,945.000 $9,459,594,000 $6,816,848,000 $5,863,235,000 38

[第 41 页]

[PAGE 41]

(15) 业务分部数据(续)

保险分部收入

198919881987
已收保费$296,092,000$484,709,000$751,253,000
已赚保费:
直接保险或原保险$188,920,000$292,309,000$441,635,000
结构化结算和组合再保险146,827,000335,747,000229,323,000
小计335,747,000628,056,000670,958,000
剔除结构化结算和组合再保险后的再保险58,532,00062,603,000127,731,000
已赚保费合计394,279,000690,659,000798,689,000
投资收入220,024,000250,723,000152,995,000
已实现投资收益250,723,0002,491,00052,137,000
合计$865,026,000$943,873,000$1,003,821,000

保险分部税前经营利润

198919881987
承保利得(损失):
直接保险或原保险$ 4,243,000$ 17,466,000$ (2,715,000)
结构化结算和组合再保险(11,204,000)(6,961,000)(14,472,000)
小计(6,961,000)10,505,000(17,187,000)
再保险(17,439,000)(24,400,000)(30,460,000)
承保(损失)合计(24,400,000)(13,895,000)(47,647,000)
投资收入净额220,024,000243,599,000152,483,000
已实现投资收益243,599,000118,196,00018,149,000
合计$439,223,000$347,900,000$122,985,000

(16) 季度数据

下表汇总了最近两年各季度的收入和利润情况。这些信息未经审计。金额单位是千美元,每股数据除外。

第一季第二季第三季第四季
19891988198919881989198819891988
收入$501,707$641,678$564,214$576,374$597,143$583,949$620,828$662,892
剔除已实现投资收益后的利润$ 72,241$ 77,835$ 62,424$ 69,506$ 70,932$ 75,961$ 94,305$ 90,139
- 每股63.0167.8754.4560.6261.8766.2682.4978.62
已实现投资收益$ 54,813$ 21,222$ 25,011$ 24,939$ 50,723$ 8,564$ 17,028$ 31,104
- 每股47.8121.8221.7527.1344.257.4714.3427.13
净利润$127,054$ 99,057$ 87,435$ 94,445$121,655$ 84,525$111,333$121,243
- 每股110.8286.3876.2782.37106.1273.7396.83105.75

喜诗糖果的销售在复活节期间达到高峰,第四季度更为显著,超过半数产品销售集中在该季度。世界图书产品(World Book)的销售和利润集中在一季度。对于伯克希尔的中期合并财务报表而言,保险子公司未决赔款负债估算过程中固有的估计误差,对中期业绩的影响相对大于对全年业绩的影响。已实现证券收益的金额和时间差异也会导致各期净利润的大幅波动。

(15) Business segment data (continued) Revenues of the insurance segment Premiums written. 1989 1988 1987 $296,092,000 $484,709,000 $ 751,253,000 Premiums earned: Primary or direct insurance. A Reinsurance assumed excluding structured $ 188,920,000 $ 292,309,000 441,635,000 settlements and portfolio reinsurance. Subtotal. 146,827,000 structured settlements and portfolio reinsurance 335,747,000 229,323,000 Investment income Total premiums earned 58,532,000 521,632,000 372,763,000 394,279,000 62,603,000 814,398,000 Realized investment gain 220,024,000 250,723,000 584,235,000 824,895,000 10,497,000 231,907,000 $865,026,000 $943,873,000 127,731,000 152,995,000 $1,003,821,000 25,931,000 Insurance segment operating profit before taxes 1989 1988 1987 Underwriting gain (loss): rimary or direct insurance grationed $ 4,243,000 $ 17,466,000 $ (2,715,000) settlements and portfolio reinsurance .... (11,204,000) Structured settlements and portfolio reinsuranc... (6,961,000) (14,472,000) Net investment income.... Total underwriting (loss).. -(17,439,000) 2,994,000 (27,745,000) (24,400,000) (14,075,000) (24,969,000) (30,460,000) Realized investment gain 220,024,000 243,599,000 231,250,000 (11,081,000) 152,483,000 (55,429,000) 127,731,000 25,931,000 $439,223,000 $ 347,900,000 $ 122,985,000 (16) Quarterly data following table. This information is unaudited. Dollars are in thousands, except per share amounts. A summary of revenues and earnings by quarter for each of the last two years is presented in the 1ST QUARTER 2ND QUARTER 3RD QUARTER 4TH QUARTER 1989 1988 1989 1988 1989

  • 1988

19891988 Revenues $Z01,707 $641,678 $564,214 $576,374 $597,143 $583,949 $620,828 $662,892 Earnings excluding realized investment gain $ 72,241 $ 77,835 $ 62,424 $ 69,506 $ 70,932 $ 75,961

  • per share

63.01 - 67.87 54.45 - 60.62 61.87 66.26 $ 94,305 82.49 $ 90,139 78.62

  • per share

Realized investment gain 54,813 $ 21,222 $ 25,011 $ 24,939 $ 17,028 $ 31,104 47.81 21.82 21.75 27.13 • per share Net earnings $ 127,054 $ 99,057 $ 87,435 $ 94,445 $ 121,655 $ 84,525 $ 111,333 $ 121,243 110.82 86.38 76.27 _ 82.37 -106.12 _ 73.73 96.83 105.75 See's Candy sales peak at Easter and more notably so in the fourth quarter when more than one-half of Revenues and earnings from marketing of World Book products are concentrated in the first quarter. determining liabilities for unpaid losses of insurance subsidiaries, can be relatively more significant to Berkshire's interim consolidated financial statements is that estimation error, inherent to the process of securities gains or losses cause significant variations in periodic net earnings. results of interim periods than to results for a full year. Variations in amount and timing of realized 39

[第 42 页]

[PAGE 42]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

财务状况与经营成果

管理层讨论与分析

经营成果

(单位:千美元,每项数据均已扣除所得税影响)

过去三年每年的净利润在下表中按项目细分。金额以千美元计。

承保业务……

活动或项目

对净利润的贡献

保险业务投资收益

……

……

$ (12,259)

1989

$ (1,045)

1988

$ (20,659)

1987

制造业、零售业及服务业

……

110,021

197,779

196,734

136,621

115,962

养老金计划资产返还*

……

……

135,652

109,681

定期公司债利息

……

(27,098)

(23,212)

9,983

(6,102)

(5,905)

实现投资收益前的利润

……

……

299,902

313,441

(5,716)

214,746

(4,992)

实现投资收益

……

……

147,575

85,829

19,806

净利润

……

$ 447,477

$ 399,270

$ 234,552

*因终止超额注资的养老金计划而发生的养老金资产返还,因其相对重要,故单独列示。这些返还发生在公司和某些子公司收回超额注资的养老金计划资产退出之后。

伯克希尔已采用财务会计准则委员会第 97 号公告。该公告要求将税前已实现投资收益在收入中单独列示,因此伯克希尔的利润表不再将净税后投资收益与净税后经营利润分开列示。然而,在我们讨论伯克希尔的业绩时,我们预期将继续分别展示这两个不同组成部分对利润的贡献。

合并财务报表附注 15(“分部附注”)列示了多个伯克希尔旗下企业的数据,这些数据应结合本讨论一并阅读。

承保业务

上述承保业务分部的税后数据来自以下部分:

(千美元省略)

承保利润(亏损):

1989

1988

1987

直接保险业务……

$ 4,243

$ 17,466

$ (2,715)

分入再保险业务(不包括结构型结算和组合再保险)

……

(11,204)

(14,472)

结构型结算和组合再保险……

(17,439)

适用所得税抵免*

承保亏损——税前

(24,400)

(14,075)

(27,745)

……

……

11,781

(11,081)

(24,969)

承保亏损——税后

$(12,259)

360

9,670

(55,429)

$(1,045)

366

34,461

$(20,659)

309

少数股东权益……

……

……

……

*适用于承保亏损的所得税抵免包含约 300 万美元(1989 年)、500 万美元(1988 年)和 800 万美元(1987 年)的“新起点”税收优惠。

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. Financial Condition and Results of Operations Management's Discussion and Analysis of Results of Operations in thousands, and each figure is income tax-effected. Net earnings for each of the past three years are disaggregated in the table that follows. Amounts are Insurance underwriting... Activity or Item Contribution to Net Earnings Insurance segment investment income. ..... ..... $ (12,259) 1989 $ (1,045) 1988_ $ (20,659) 1987 Manufacturing, merchandising, and services.. 11021 _197,779 196,734 136,621 115,962 Pension plan asset reversions* 135,652 109,681 Interest on dated corporate cost .... (27,098) (23,212) 9,983 (6,102) (5,905) Earnings before realized investment gain. ........ 299,902 313,441 -(5,716) 214,746 (4,992) Realized investment gain.... Net earnings ... $ 447,477 147,575 $ 399,270 85,829 $234,552 19,806 ermination of overfunded pension plans are set out separately because of their comparativ Net earnings that resulted from asset reversions to the Company and certain subsidiaries upo significance. Berkshire has adopted Financial Accounting Standards Board Statement No. 97. The Statement requires of Earnings no longer reflect net-after-tax investment gains separately from net-after-tax operating earnings pre-tax realized investment gains to be shown as a component of revenues. As a result, Berkshire's Statements contribution to earnings of those differing components. However, in our discussions of Berkshire's results, we expect to continue to show separately the net the individual Berkshire businesses and should be read in conjunction with this discussion. Note 15 to the consolidated financial statements ("the Segment Note") shows data for a number of Insurance Underwriting The after-tax figures shown above for the Insurance underwriting segment derive from the following: 000s Omitted Underwriting gain (loss): 1989 1988 1987 Primary or Direct Insurance Operations..... Reinsurance Assumed, excluding Structured ....• $ 4,243 $ 17,466 $ (2,715) Structured Settlements and Portfolio Reinsurance. Settlements and Portfolio Reinsurance ...... (11,204) Applicable income tax credit* Underwriting loss - pre-tax (17,439) (14,472) .... After-tax underwriting loss... Applicable minority interest.. ....•• (24,400) (14.075) (27,745) ..... ....•• 11,781 (11,081) (24,969) $(12,259) 360 9,670 (55,429) $(1,045) 366 34,461 $(20,659) 309 of approximately $3 million for 1989, $5 million for 1988 and $8 million for 1987. *Income tax credits applicable to underwriting losses include a "fresh start" tax benefit 40

[第 43 页]

[PAGE 43]

保险承保(续)

直接或原保险承保

下表汇总了伯克希尔·哈撒韦保险集团直接或原保险业务按公认会计原则确定的综合承保结果。金额单位为千美元。

1989 1988 1987

金额 占比 金额 占比 金额 占比

已赚保费 $ 169,661 100.0% $ 218,838 100.0% $ 412,748 100.0%

已承保保费 188,920 292,309 441,635

赔款及赔付费用 125,873 66.6% 196,165 67.1% 338,575 76.7%

承保费用 58,804 31.1% 78,678 26.9% 105,775 23.9%

赔款及费用合计 184,677 97.7% 274,843 94.0% 414,350 100.6%

承保利润(亏损)——税前 4,243 2.3% 17,466 6.0% (2,715) -0.6%

1989 年来自直接或原保险业务的已赚保费比 1988 年下降了约 35%,1988 年又比 1987 年下降了约 34%。在 1987 至 1989 年期间,构成伯克希尔原保险业务的各独立细分承保领域签发的保单数量持续下降。1985 年该业务起步至 1989 年,由纽约市的商业意外险和专业风险两个部门产生的已赚保费累计为 2.414 亿美元,1987 年达到峰值 9300 万美元,随后降至 1988 年的 5410 万美元和 1989 年的 2020 万美元。自 1986 年以来,保险业务的竞争已显著侵蚀价格,随后出现的定价有利的承保机会也越来越少。

从上表可以看出,承保费用占已赚保费的比例逐年上升,这有两个原因,都是保费水平下降的结果。首先,纽约市两个部门产生的业务历史上承保费用率低于集团平均水平(开业至今为 8.8%),而该业务占集团全部直接或原保险已赚保费的比例已从 1987 年的 21% 降至 1988 年的 18%,再到最新年度的 11%。其次,为传统业务提供承保支持的成本,特别是人员成本,其下降速度慢于此类业务已赚保费的下降速度。

下表汇总了直接或原保险承保的赔款及赔付费用数据:

1989 1988 1987

(千美元省略) (千美元省略) (千美元省略)

记录的发生赔款:

年初未付赔款及赔付费用 $ 667,592 $ 628,077 $ 429,505

当前年度事件发生额 145,907 225,309 348,010

所有以往年度事件发生额 (20,034) (29,144) (9,435)

合计 126,608 196,165 338,575

支付:

当前年度事件赔付款 27,645 39,263 44,856

所有以往年度事件赔付款 154,319 117,387 95,147

合计 181,964 156,650 140,003

年末未付赔款及赔付费用 $ 639,146 $ 667,592 $ 628,071

如上所示,针对所有以往年度事件记录的发生赔款为负数,表明过去三年该业务每年都录得赔款准备金有利进展。这些抵减额分别占当年直接或原保险已赚保费的 10.6%(1989 年)、10.0%(1988 年)和 2.1%(1987 年)。1989 年录得的赔款准备金有利进展主要来自国民赔偿公司为公交和卡车运营商提供的传统责任险业务。

Insurance Underwriting (continued) Primary or Direct Insurance Underwriting accepted accounting principles ("GAAP"), of the Berkshire Hathaway Insurance Group's primary or direct A summary follows of the combined underwriting results, determined on the basis of generally insurance operations. Dollars are in thousands. 1989 Premiums earned Premiums written.... $ 169,661 Amount % Amount 1988 Losses and loss expenses 188,920 Total losses and expenses... Underwriting expenses.... 125,873 100.0 Es 218,838 % Amount 1987 58,804 66.6 292,309 Underwriting gain (loss) - pre-tax 184,677 31.1 196,165 100.0 $ 412,748 4,243 97.7 274,843 78,678 26.9 67.1 441,635 338,575 100.0 17,466 94.0 105,775 76.7 HA 414,350 23.9 (2,715) 100.6 in 1988 from 1987 by about 34%. During the 1987-1989 period, a continuously decreasing number of Premiums earned from primary or direct operations decreased in 1989 from 1988 by about 35% and policies were issued from each of the separately-focused underwriting areas that make up Berkshire's since inception in 1985 through 1989. They peaked at $93 million for 1987, then declined to $54.1 million the Professional Liability and Special Risks Divisions, both in New York City, have been $241.4 million primary or direct business. Earned premiums from business produced by the Commercial Casualty and and successively fewer favorably priced insuring opportunities have been presented since 1986. for 1988 and to $20.2 million for 1989. Competition for insurance business has significantly eroded prices evident in the above table, are the result of the declining level of premiums, in two ways. First, the business The increases from year to year in percent of earned premiums represented by underwriting expenses, produced by the New York City divisions has historically carried a lower than group average underwriting premiums represented by this business has declined from 21% in 1987 to 18% in 1988 and 11% in the expense rate (8.8% inception-to-date), and the proportion of the Group's total primary or direct earned most recent year. Secondly, costs of providing underwriting support, particularly personnel costs, for traditional business have decreased at a slower rate than have earned premiums from such business. Summarized below is loss and loss expense data from primary or direct underwriting: $667,592 1989 000s Omitted $628,077 1988 Incurred losses recorded: Unpaid losses and loss expenses at beginning of year.. $429,505 1987 Current year occurrences..... All prior years' occurrences .... ..... (20,034) 145,907 225,309 125,873 196,165 (29,144) 348,010 338,575 (9,435) Payments with respect to: Current year occurrences.... 27,645 All prior years' occurrences 154,319 126,674 117.387 39,263 44,856 _156,650 95,147 Unpaid losses and loss expenses at end of year... $639,146 $667,592 140,003 $628.071 favorable developments of loss reserves have been recorded for this business in each of the past three As indicated above by the credits shown for incurred losses recorded for all prior years occurrences, earned in those respective years. The bulk of favorable loss development recorded in 1989 related to years. The credits represent 10.6% - 1989, 10.0% — 1988, and 2.1% — 1987, of direct or primary premiums National Indemnity Company's traditional liability coverages for bus and truck operators. 41

[第 44 页]

[PAGE 44]

管理层讨论(续)

保险承保(续)

再保险分入业务(不含结构化结算和组合再保险)

关于再保险分入业务(不包括结构化结算和组合再保险)的合并承保结果(按 GAAP 口径计算)汇总如下表,金额单位为千美元。

1989 年 1988 年 1987 年

金额 占比 金额 占比 金额 占比

已赚保费 65,954 100.0% 203,268 100.0% 328,011 100.0%

已承保保费 48,612 74.5% 229,323 107.6% 243,795 74.3%

损失及损失费用 109,419 33.1% 73,303 32.0% 112,870 30.3%

承保费用 46,827 - 73,303 - 112,870 -

损失及损失费用合计 158,031 107.6% 372,763 106.3% 400,508 107.4%

承保(亏损)- 税前 (11,204) - (14,472) - (27,745) -

1989 年已承保保费和已赚保费均大幅下降,原因是国民赔偿公司(National Indemnity Company)与消防基金保险公司(Fireman's Fund Insurance Companies,简称“FF”)之间为期四年(1985 年 9 月 1 日至 1989 年 8 月 31 日)的成数再保险协议到期,该协议下国民赔偿公司承担 FF 业务量的 7%。上表所涵盖年份中,该协议产生的已赚保费分别为:1987 年约 2.54 亿美元、1988 年约 2.16 亿美元、1989 年约 1.31 亿美元。1989 年 9 月中旬,国民赔偿公司向 FF 返还了约 5500 万美元的保费(扣除分出佣金后的净额,这部分保费在合同到期日尚未赚取)。伯克希尔·哈撒韦保险集团仍对该合同项下其分担部分的损失及损失费用负责(直至所有未决赔案处理完毕),并将继续投资以对冲准备金,而这一过程可能需要很多年才能完成。

以下汇总了该再保险业务过去三年的损失及损失费用数据。

已记录的发生损失: 1989 年 1988 年 1987 年

(千美元省略)

所有以前年度的发生事件 $531,334 $488,098 $319,989

本年度的发生事件 109,231 109,119 188,168

169,688 804 283,151

相关赔款支付:

所有以前年度的发生事件 170,492 287,638 74,328

本年度的发生事件 97,392 31,983 45,201

114,518 112,870

年末未付损失及损失费用 $511,378 $531,334 $488,098

主要成数再保险协议的未付损失及损失费用为 4.12 亿美元,由此产生的亏损发展情况可能十分显著。

结构化结算和组合再保险

对于结构化结算和组合再保险业务,其损失发展分析没有意义,因为在这些合同开始时,可以预见到后续承保损失将导致金额不等的合理估计。尽管如此,该业务的接受与否是在逐项评估预期产生资金的价值之后才决定的。

Management's Discussion (continued) Insurance Underwriting (continued) Reinsurance Assumed excluding Structured Settlements and Portfolio Reinsurance assumed business, other than structured settlements and portfolio reinsurance, are summarized in the The combined underwriting results, determined on a GAAP basis, with respect to the reinsurance following table, with dollars in thousands. 1989 Premiums earned Premiums written $ Amount 65,954 % Amount 1988 1987 Losses and loss expenses 146,827 Underwriting expenses... 109,419 100.0 $ 203,268 Amount Total losses and expenses ... 48.612 74.5 229,323 Underwriting (loss) - pre-tax $ (11,204) 158,031 107.6 33.1 170,492 100.0 $ 328,011 % 243,795 73.303 32.0 74.3 372,763 112,870 287,638 100.0 77.2 $ (14,472) 106.3 $ (27,745) 400,508 107.4 30.2 of expiration of the quota-share reinsurance arrangement under which National Indemnity Company The significant decreases reflected above for both written and earned premiums in 1989 are the result four years from September 1, 1985 to August 31, 1989. Premiums earned from that arrangement during assumed 7% of the business written by the Fireman's Fund Insurance Companies ("FF") during the $131,000,000 in 1989. In mid-September 1989, National Indemnity returned to FFC approximately $55 years covered by the above table were approximately $254,000,000 in 1987, $216,000,000 in 1988 and Hathaway Insurance Group remains liable for run-off of its share of the losses and loss expenses covered million of premiums, net of ceding commissions, unearned at contract expiration date. The Berkshire many years hence. by the contract, and will continue to invest funds offsetting the reserves until the run-off is complete past three years. Loss and loss expense data with respect to this reinsurance business is summarized below for the Incurred losses recorded: Unpaid losses and loss expenses at beginning of year... .... $531,334 1989 000s Omitted $488,098 1988 $319,989 1987 All prior years' occurrences.. Current year occurrences...... 109,231 109.119 188 169,688 804 283,151 Payments with respect to: 170,492 287,638 4,487 All prior years' occurrences Current year occurrences... 97,392 31,983 35,474 Unpaid losses and loss expenses at end of year .... . . . . $511,378 129,375 127,256 91,782 74,328 45,201 $531,334 $488,098 119,529 Unpaid losses and loss expenses from major quota share reinsurance arrangements were $412 million, 2222 may be significant. Analyses of loss developments for the Structured Settlements and Portfolio Reinsurance business are Structured Settlements and Portfolio Reinsurance losses will result in varying amounts that are reasonably estimable. Acceptance of the business nevertheless not meaningful because, at inception of these contracts, it is predictable that subsequent underwriting occurs after appraisal on a proposal-by-proposal basis of the value of funds expected to be generated thereby. 42

[第 45 页]

[PAGE 45]

保险业务投资收入

1987 年、1988 年和 1989 年分别新增约 2 亿美元、2.75 亿美元和 4.15 亿美元。过去三年,伯克希尔每年都向保险集团追加资本。追加的资本,加上留存收益和浮存金的增长,使保险集团的投资资产总额得以增加。由此带来的逐年显著增长反映在投资收入上,具体如下表所示(千美元省略):

投资收入税前收入少数股东权益少数股东权益后及税前收入所得税投资收入税后
1989 年$ 243,599$ 26,756$ 3,201$ 213,642
1988 年231,25030,6982,192197,779
1987 年152,48313,6702,773136,621

来自保单持有人的“浮存金”已从三年前(1986 年)的约 10.78 亿美元,增长至 1989 年 12 月 31 日的约 15.41 亿美元。该术语指的是未决损失、未决损失调整费用和未赚保费的总和,减去应收代理人余额、已付损失的可收回再保险金额以及递延保单购置成本后的净额。在 1989 年底的浮存金总额中,结构性赔付和组合再保险负债约为 2.85 亿美元。

制造业、零售业和服务业

伯克希尔旗下多元化的非保险业务在过去三年的经营业绩汇总如下表(千美元):

项目1989 年 金额1989 年 百分比1988 年 金额1988 年 百分比1987 年 金额1987 年 百分比
收入$ 1,613,474100.0$ 1,500,724100.0$ 1,274,466100.0
成本与费用1,389,31786.01,425,05484.91,220,643100.0
所得税前收益224,15714.0226,25815.185,8765.4
适用少数股东权益6,8300.46,3750.44,6160.3
适用所得税84,2318.2131,4515.690,1149.1
净利润109,6817.2135,6526.3109,6817.2

上述汇总的业务在 1989 年有 25 项,比 1988 年和 1987 年多出两项,此外,每年还包含伯克希尔和西科金融的一些小规模房地产管理活动的数据。1989 年新增的业务是:(i)珠宝零售——2 月,伯克希尔以现金收购了博希姆珠宝店 80% 的股权;(ii)新美国电气公司的电气设备制造——西科金融在 1988 年底以现金收购了其 80% 的股权。然而,在这三年中,有六家相同的业务构成了伯克希尔非保险业务的“可报告业务分部”,这一地位由其相对规模决定。这六家是:(i)喜诗糖果业务,(ii)《布法罗新闻》日报和周日版的出版,(iii)内布拉斯加家具城的家居用品零售,(iv)《世界百科全书》及其他参考书籍的编纂、出版和销售,(v)家用清洁系统——主要是 Kirby 品牌产品的制造和分销,以及(vi)Fechheimer 制服的制造和分销。

这六个分部的收入在 1989 年比 1988 年高出约 4200 万美元,即约 4%;而在上一年,这六个分部的总收入比 1987 年高出约 7000 万美元,即约 7%。如分部说明中的收入表格所示,从 1987 年到 1988 年,六个分部的收入增长幅度相当均衡。然而,在 1989 年,糖果业务和家用清洁系统业务的销售额均比 1988 年增长了约 10%,而其他四个分部的总收入仅增长了约 1%。

Insurance Segment Investment Income Approximately $200 million was added in 1987, $275 million in 1988 and $415 million in 1989. The Berkshire contributed additional capital to the Insurance Group in each of the past three years. added capital together with reinvested earnings and increased float increased the total invested assets of the Group. Meaningful year-to-year increases resulted in investment income, summarized below for Investment 000s Omitted Income Investment Before Applicable Applicable Income After 1989 Taxes Income Minority Taxes and 1988 $243,599 Taxes 1987 231,250 $ 26,756 $ 3,201 Interest Minority Int. $213,642 152,483 30,698 13,670 2,192 2,773 197,779 136,621 1986 - three years ago - to approximately $1,541,000,000 at December 31, 1989. The term denotes the "Float" from policyholder funds has increased from approximately $1,078,000,000 at December 31, agents balances receivable, amounts recoverable as reinsurance on paid losses and deferred policy sum of unpaid losses, unpaid loss adjustment expenses and unearned premiums, less the aggregate of acquisition costs. Of the 1989 year-end total float, structured settlement and portfolio reinsurance liabilities amounted to approximately $285,000,000. Manufacturing, Merchandising and Services summarized in the following table, in thousands of dollars: Results of operations for the past three years of Berkshire's diverse non-insurance businesses are 1989 Revenues .... Amount % Amount 1988 1987 Earnings before income taxes Costs and expenses $ 1,613,474 100.0 $ 1,500,724 % Amount 85,876 14.0 1,274,466 100.0 6,830 0.4 5.4 226,258 84.9 $1,425,054 % _1,389,317 86.0 1,220,643 100.0 Applicable minority interest Applicable income taxes.. 224,157 84,231 15.1 204,411 85.7 6 131.451 8.2 135,652 6,375 0.4 5.6 90,114 14.3 9.1 $• 109,681 4,616 0.3 6.3 Net earnings .. 7.2 in each of the three years, data are included with respect to moderate scale real estate management activities Operations summarized above numbered twenty five in 1989, two more than in 1988 and 1987, plus, of Berkshire and Wesco. The operations added in 1989 were (i) retailing of jewelry — in February, Berkshire purchased for cash 80% of Borsheim's Fine Jewelry and Gifts, and (ii) the manufacturing of electrical equipment by New America Electric — 80% purchased for cash by Wesco at the end of 1988. However, for each of the three years, the same six businesses constituted Berkshire's non-insurance "reportable business segments," a standing determined by relative size. The six are: (i) See's candy business, (ii) publication daily and Sunday of The Buffalo News, (iii) retailing of home furnishings by The Nebraska Furniture Mart, (iv) composing, publishing and marketing of World Book encyclopedias and other reference works, (vi) manufacture and distribution of Fechheimer uniforms. (v) manufacture and distribution of home cleaning systems - principally Kirby branded products and than in 1988. And, in the prior year, aggregate revenues of the six were more by approximately $70 million, Revenues of those six segments were greater in 1989 by approximately $42 million, or about 4%, or 7%, than in 1987. As shown in the table of revenues in the Segment Note, revenue increases from home cleaning systems business each recorded about 10% higher sales than in 1988, while the aggregate 1987 to 1988 were at a fairly even rate among the six. In 1989, however, the candy business and the revenues of the other four increased about 1%. 43

第 46 页

[PAGE 46]

管理层讨论(续)

制造业、零售业与服务业务(续)

喜诗糖果的销售额增长伴随着广告支出增加,但后者金额增幅较小,因此该业务为伯克希尔 1989 年净利润贡献的金额,比 1988 年增加了约 100 万美元。

家用清洁系统的销售增长主要来自 Kirby 吸尘器海外单位销量 32% 的提升,这一成果在斯堪的纳维亚、西德、澳大利亚、意大利和日本市场均有体现。然而,该板块收入改善并未带来利润增长,主要原因是为 90 年代新型号 Kirby 吸尘器的生产与营销产生了大量启动成本。

利息支出

1989 年和 1988 年的债务利息均有所增加,反映了两年中未偿还借款余额的增长。1989 年较 1988 年的增加,源于 1989 年 9 月 28 日发行的零息可转换次级票据的增值费用。1988 年较 1987 年的增长,则源于伯克希尔 1988 年 1 月发行的 2.5 亿美元面值、2018 年到期债券带来的新增借贷成本。

已实现投资收益

伯克希尔在出售增值证券时确认的这一金额,往往在不同时期之间大幅波动,对伯克希尔合并净利润产生程度不一的显著影响。多年来,已实现投资收益一直是伯克希尔净利润中的一个反复出现的元素。但是,任何期间的已实现投资收益金额都不具备预测价值,而各期金额的变动,考虑到伯克希尔合并投资组合中早已存在大量未实现价格增值,实际上也不具有分析价值。

流动性及资本资源

伯克希尔 1989 年 12 月 31 日的合并资产负债表反映了持续的资本实力。伯克希尔股东权益已从 1986 年 12 月 31 日的约 23.8 亿美元增长至 1989 年 12 月 31 日的约 49.3 亿美元。在这三年期间,已实现和未实现的证券收益使股本增加了约 17.2 亿美元。除已实现证券收益外的留存收益,三年累计约为 8.28 亿美元。

1988 年 1 月,伯克希尔发行了 2.5 亿美元面值的 30 年期债券,可从 1999 年起通过偿债基金赎回,最终到期日为 2018 年。1989 年 9 月,伯克希尔通过发行零息可转换次级票据获得约 4 亿美元资金,该票据于 2004 年到期,到期价值约为 9.03 亿美元。这些发行的收益被注入保险集团的股本。伯克希尔借入这些资金并非出于任何即时的现金需求,而是为了增强本已充裕的流动性。这也使得伯克希尔应对未来业务收购机会的能力有了一定提升。

1989 年初,标准普尔公司宣布授予伯克希尔高级债务 AAA 信用评级。债权人属于次级债务的,通常获得的评级比其高级债务低一个等级。因此,伯克希尔的零息次级票据在 1989 年 9 月发行时,获得了这家评级机构给予的 AA+ 评级。

Management's Discussion (continued) Manufacturing, Merchandising, and Services (continued) See's increased sales were accompanied by increased advertising costs, but of a lesser dollar magnitude, so the business contributed about one million dollars more to 1989 than to 1988 net earnings of Berkshire. products. Strengthened distribution for those products was evident from results in Scandinavia, West The increased sales of home cleaning systems were led by a 32% increase in unit foreign sales of Kirby Germany, Australia, Italy and Japan. Improved earnings, however, did not follow this segment's improved revenues, principally because of significant start-up costs incurred with respect to production for marketing in the 90's of a new model Kirby machine. Interest on debt increased in both 1989 and 1988, reflecting increased outstanding borrowings in Interest Expense each year. The 1989 increase over 1988 reflects the expense recorded for accretion of the zero coupon convertible subordinated notes issued on September 28, 1989. The 1988 increase over 1987 reflects the added borrowing costs from Berkshire's $250 million face amount of debentures due 2018, issued in January 1988 Realized Investment Gain The amount - recorded by Berkshire when appreciated securities are sold — tends to fluctuate significantly Realized investment gain has been a recurring element in Berkshire's net earnings for many years. from period to period, with a meaningfully varying effect upon Berkshire's consolidated net earnings. amount from period to period have no practical analytical value, given the pre-existence of substantial But, the amount of realized investment gain for any period has no predictive value, and variations in unrealized price appreciation in Berkshire's consolidated investment portfolio. Liquidity and Capital Resources Berkshire's Consolidated Balance Sheet as of December 31, 1989, reflects continuing capital strength. approximately $4.93 billion at December 31, 1989. In that three-year period, realized and unrealized Berkshire shareholders' equity has increased from approximately $2.38 billion at December 31, 1986 to securities gains increased equity capital by approximately $1.72 billion. Reinvested earnings, other than realized securities gains, were approximately $828 million for the three years. through sinking funds commencing in 1999 with final maturity in 2018. In September 1989, Berkshire In January 1988 Berkshire issued $250,000,000 face amount of 30 year debentures, redeemable received approximately $400 million proceeds from issuance of zero coupon convertible subordinated equity capital of the Insurance Group. Berkshire borrowed the funds not with a view to any immediate notes maturing in 2004 at approximately $903 million. Proceeds from the issues were contributed to the cash needs but rather to increase its already substantial liquidity. Somewhat improved ability to respon o future business acquisition opportunities also resulted In early 1989, Standard and Poor's Corporation announced its assignment of a AAA credit rating o Berkshire senior debt. Creditors' indebtedness that is subordinated normally receives a rating one gradatio ower than is received for their senior indebtedness. Accordinelv. Berkshire's issue of zero coupo subordinated notes received an AA+ rating from that rating agency, when issued in September 1989. 44

[第 47 页]

[PAGE 47]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

保险集团

伯克希尔的保险业务由 12 家独立的子公司开展,其中专业风险部在纽约市设有办事处,负责招揽和承保风险。商业意外险部以及专业责任险和后者——在科罗拉多州、堪萨斯州和内布拉斯加州注册的成员公司——为“本州”居民提供标准的多险种财产/意外险。一家在加州注册的成员公司主要向该州的雇主提供工伤保险。此外,通过在纽约市的一个再保险部门,还向其他保险公司提供再保险合约。

伯克希尔·哈撒韦保险集团保持着无与伦比的高水平资本实力,显著高于行业正常水平。这种实力使集团成员公司与竞争对手区别开来。例如,该集团 1989 年承保保费净额约为集团年末法定盈余的 5.5%。相比之下,行业平均保费与盈余比约为 170%(为 1988 年数据)。因此,向集团被保险人提供的如此明显的安全边际,在营销涉及损失组合负债假设以及个别协商的财务保险和再保险合约(包括定期付款合约,即结构性结算)时,尤其具有说服力。

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司保险集团的合并财务报表——未经审计且未在所有方面完全按照公认会计原则调整——列示于下两页。

-

45

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. INSURANCE GROUP Berkshire's insurance business is conducted by 12 separate subsidiaries, Special Risk Division, each with offices in New York City, solicit and underwrite risks. The Commercial Casualty Division and the Professional Liability and the latter. Members domiciled in the states of Colorado, Kansas and Nebraska provide standard multiple-line property/casualty insurance to "homestate" residents. A California domiciled member provides principally workers' com- in New York City, treaties of reinsurance are offered to other insurers. pensation insurance to employers in that state. Also, from a Reinsurance Division unparalleled high levels, significantly higher than normal in the industry. This The Berkshire Hathaway Insurance Group maintains capital strength at strength differentiates Group members from their competitors. For example, the Group's net premiums written in 1989 were approximately 5.5% of the Group's year-end statutory surplus. That compares to an industry average premiums-to- surplus ratio of about 170% (for 1988). The obvious margins of safety thus provided to insureds of the Group are particularly persuasive in marketing of ing liability assumptions with respect to loss portfolios and with respect to individually negotiated financial insurance and reinsurance contracts, includ- periodic payment contracts (structured settlements). Group - unaudited and not fully adjusted to conform to Generally Accepted Combined financial statements of the Berkshire Hathaway Inc. Insurance Accounting Principles - are presented on the following two pages. - 45

[第 48 页]

[PAGE 48]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

保险集团

(单位:千美元)

资产负债表

1989 年 12 月 31 日

1988 年

资产

投资:

按摊销成本计算的固定期限证券:

债券:

其他

华盛顿公共电力供应系统

$ 194,004

545,943

$ 246,982

802,916

可赎回优先股:

冠军国际

279,000

所罗门公司

吉列

600,000

624,000

全美航空

348,000

624,000

按市价计算的权益证券:

其他

668

10,548

普通股:

可口可乐公司

大都会/美国广播公司

1,799,152

1,664,169

1,068,637

1,044,625

632,448

GEICO

486,366

849,400

其他

《华盛顿邮报》

123,728

364,126

23,509

498,614

不可赎回优先股

8,606

7,733,164

5,106,277

应收款项

现金及现金等价物

70,998

45,390

121,614

2,328

14,975

139,702

其他

递延保单获取成本

45,456

3,299

$ 7,866,855

$ 5,416,348

负债

损失及损失调整费用

$ 1,436,311

201,008

143,631

$ 1,407,189

未赚保费

241,818

所得税(递延:1989 年 1,095,300 美元;1988 年 547,635 美元)

应付账款、应计费用及其他

1,136,174

565,310

85,387

2,917,124

2,299,704

权益

少数股东权益

4,914,563

35,168

3,091,687

24,957

伯克希尔股东权益

4,949,731

3,116,644

$ 7,866,855

$ 5,416,348

这些报表并非在所有方面均符合公认会计原则

这些报表未经审计

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. INSURANCE GROUP (dollars in thousands) Balance Sheets 1989 December 31, 1988 Assets Investments: Fixed maturities at amortized cost: Bonds: Other Wash. Pub. Power Supply System $ 194,004 545,943 $ 246,982 802,916 Redeemable preferred stocks: Champion International... 279,000 Salomon Inc Gillette 600,000 624,000 USAir. 348,000 624,000 Equity Securities at market: Other. 668 10,548 Common stocks: Coca-Cola Company Capital Cities/ABC, Inc.. 1,799,152 1,664,169 1,068,637 1,044,625 632,448 GEICO 486,366 849,400 Other Washington Post 123,728 364,126 23,509 498,614 Nonredeemable preferred stocks 8.606 7,733,164 5,106,277 Receivables. Cash and cash equivalents 70,998 45,390 121,614 2,328 14,975 139,702 Other Deferred insurance premium acquisition costs 45,456 3,299 Liabilities $7.866,855 $5.416.348 Loss and loss adjustment expenses $ 1,436,311 201,008 143,631 $ 1,407,189 Unearned premiums... 241,818 Income taxes (Deferred: $1,095,300, 1989; $547,635, 1988) Accounts payable, accruals and other 1,136,174 565,310 85,387 2,917,124 2,299,704 Equity Minority shareholders' _4,914,563 35,168 _ 3,091,687 24,957 Berkshire shareholders'. 4,949,731 3,116,644 $7,866,855 $5,416,348 These stalements do not conform to GAAP in all respects These statements are unandited 46

[第 49 页]

[PAGE 49]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

保险集团

利润表

(单位:千美元)

承保保费

$ 296,092

1989 年

1988 年

$ 484,709

$ 751,253

1987 年

已赚保费

承保费用

损失及损失费用

$ 394,279

309,391

$ 584,235

$ 824,895

承保亏损-税前

总损失及费用

418,679

157,621

219,178

净投资收益

(24,400)

(11,081)

880,324

152,483

(55,429)

已实现投资收益

所得税-抵免(费用)

税前经营利润

(88,902)

440,067

少数股东权益

351,165

136,575

净利润

$ 347,148

1,884

$ 280,680

$ 134,691

净投资收益表

(单位:千美元)

1989 年

1988 年

1987 年

利息:

基本免征联邦所得税

其他

华盛顿公共电力供应系统

$

52,623

26,268

$

34,615

46,701

64,545

$

68,310

32,293

应税

100,839

21,948

145,861

121,780

21,177

股息:

大都会/美国广播公司

590

冠军国际

1,864

590

590

GEICO

可口可乐公司

12,330

31,322

11,234

4,393

9,316

所罗门公司

吉列

56,160

23,479

12,876

56,160

14,040

全美航空

其他

《华盛顿邮报》

8,084

3,179

10,974

2,695

2,212

5,057

250,723

$ 243,876

(6,847)

231,907

$ 231,250

(657)

152,995

投资费用

$ 152,483

(512)

净投资收益

这些报表未在所有方面符合公认会计准则

这些报表未经审计

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. INSURANCE GROUP Statements of Earnings (dollars in thousands) Premiums written. $ 296,092 1989 1988 $ 484,709 $ 751,253 1987 Premiums earned Underwriting expenses.. osses and loss expenses $ 394,279 309,391 $ 584,235 $ 824,895 Underwriting loss - pre-tax Total losses and expenses... 418,679 157,621 219,178 Net investment income.. (24,400) (11.081) 880,324 152,483 (55,429) Realized investment gain.... Income taxes - credit (expense) Earnings from operations before income taxes (88,902) 440,067 Minority interest 351,165 136,575 Net earnings. $ 347,148 1,884 $ 280,680 $ 134,691 Statements of Net Investment Income (dollars in thousands) 1989 1988 1987 Interest: ubstantially exempt from Federal income taxes Other Vash. Pub. Power Supply Syster $ 52,623 26,268 $ 34,615 46,701 64,545 $ 68,310 32,293 Taxable 100,839 21,948 145,861 121,780 21.177 Dividends: Capital Cities/ABC, Inc. 590 Champion International 1,864 590 590 GEICO . Coca-Cola Company 12,330 31,322 11,234 4.393 9,316 Salomon Inc. Gillette 56,160 23,479 12,876 56,160 14,040 USAir.... Other Washington Post 8.084 3,179 10,974 2,695 2.212 5.057 250,723 .. ... $ 243.876 (6,847) 231.907 $ 231,250 (657) 152,995 Investment expenses.. $ 152,483 (512) Net investment income These statements do not conform to GAAP in all respects These statements are unaudited 47

[第 50 页]

[PAGE 50]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司制造业、出版及零售业务——未完全按公认会计原则调整,且未经审计——呈列于下一页。

伯克希尔制造业、出版及零售业合并财务报表——未经审计

这些合并报表所涵盖的业务包括伯克希尔六个非保险的“可报告业务分部”,以及以下业务:

运营实体活动/产品/服务
Adalet导管配件、防爆配件、接线盒
Blue Chip Stamps赠券印花
Borsheim’s高档珠宝零售
Carefree卷帘式遮阳篷及其他房车配件
Campbell Hausfeld空气压缩机、无气喷漆机
France电器定时控制器、点火变压器
Haler锌铝合金压铸配件
KEW Products压力与流量测量设备
Meriom汽车化合物
Northland分马力电机
New America Electric电气设备制造商
Precision钢材服务中心
Powerwinch船用绞盘、起锚机
Scot Labs刀具系列
Quikut各式刀具
Stahl维护化学品
Wayne Home Equipment炉用燃烧器;污水泵、排水泵、排污泵
Western Enterprises卡车底盘定制钢质车身
Western Plastics模塑塑料件
Western Enterprises燃气管线配件

六个非保险“可报告业务分部”的具体描述如下。

报纸——《布法罗新闻》是伯克希尔的一个部门,每周日出版一期,每个工作日出版七期,是纽约州北部一个涵盖十个县的发行区域内唯一的都市日报。该区域属于全美最大的 50 个一级市场之一。

制服制造与分销——伯克希尔于 1986 年中期收购了 Fechheimers 85% 的股权。Fechheimers 在肯塔基州、俄亥俄州、田纳西州和得克萨斯州的工厂生产产品,通过大约三十多个公司自有的零售分销中心以及独立经销商进行销售,这些经销商共同服务于全美 200 多个主要都市地区。

家用清洁系统——伯克希尔的这一业务分部主要由 Kirby 清洁系统和产品构成,产品卖给约 600 家工厂分销商,后者再转售给一个由区域分销商和经销商组成的网络。独立经销商采用上门演示的方式进行直销。Douglas Products 公司生产特殊用途的吸尘器,如手持式及无线电动吸尘器,通过百货商店、目录展销厅和五金店分销。Cleveland Wood Products 公司(一家吸尘器刷子制造商)的数据也纳入此分部的报告中。

家居装饰零售——内布拉斯加家具城在内布拉斯加州奥马哈市经营家居装饰零售业务,拥有一个面积超过 20 万平方英尺的超大型零售卖场和可观的仓库设施。其贸易区域以奥马哈为中心,辐射半径约 300 英里。伯克希尔拥有该业务 80% 的股权;关键管理人员持有其余部分。

糖果——喜诗糖果生产盒装巧克力和其他糖果产品,注重品质,在加利福尼亚州的两个大型厨房进行生产。喜诗通过其自有零售店(数量超过 200 家)在 12 个西部和中西部州(包括夏威夷)进行分销。此外,通过季节性变化的数量订单配送中心向全国发货,也录得了可观的糖果直销业务量。

百科全书及其他参考资料——世界图书百科全书以及 Childcraft 和 Early World of Learning(学前教育项目)是该分部的产品。百科全书的修订版每年编撰并出版。每年第一季度出版并发行一本更新用的年鉴,通过邮寄方式向早期版本的拥有者推销。除此之外,产品主要通过直销方式销售,由分布在美国、加拿大、澳大利亚和不列颠群岛的数千名委托销售人员向学校、图书馆和家庭推销。

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. MANUFACTURING, PUBLISHING AND RETAILING BUSINESSES and not fully adjusted to conform to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles - are presented on the following page. Combined financial statements of Berkshire's Manufacturing, Publishing and Retailing businesses - unaudited The operations whose data have been combined in these presentations include Berkshire's six non-insurance "reportable business segments," as well as the following: Operation Adalet Activity/product/service Blue Chip Stamps. Conduit fittings, explosion proof fittings, junction boxes Borsheim's Retailing of fine jewelry Trading stamps Carefree.. Campbell Hausfeld Air compressors, airless paint sprayers France .. Appliance timing controls, ignition transformers Roll-up awnings, other RV accessories Haler KEW Products Zinc and aluminum die cast fittings Meriom... Pressure and flow measurement devices Automotive compounds Northland New America Electric Fractional horsepower motors Manufacturer of electrical equipment Precision.... Powerwinch Steel service center Boat winches, windlasses Scot Labs.. Quikut..... Varieties of cutlery Stahl..... Maintenance chemicals Wayne Home Equipment Furnace burners; sump, utility & sewage pumps Custom steel bodies for truck chassis Western Enterprises Western Plastics .... Molded plastic parts Gas transmission line fittings The six non-insurance "reportable business segments" are more fully described below. weekday. It is the only metropolitan newspaper published daily within a ten county upstate New York distribution area Newspaper — The Buffalo News, a division of Berkshire, publishes a Sunday edition and seven editions each that comprises one of the nation's 50 largest primary market areas. 1986. Fechheimers manufactures its products at plants in Kentucky, Ohio, Tennessee and Texas, for marketing through Uniform Manufacturing and Distribution — Berkshire acquired its 85% ownership interest of Fechheimers in mid- approximately three dozen company-owned retail distribution centers and by independent dealers who together serve more than 200 of the country's major metropolitan areas. systems and products, sold to approximately 600 factory distributors who in turn sell them to a network of area Home Cleaning Systems - This segment of Berkshire's business is principally represented by Kirby cleaning distributors and dealers. Independent dealers employ in-the-home demonstrations for direct resale to consumers. distributed through department stores, catalogue showrooms and hardware stores. Data with respect to Cleveland Wood Douglas Products Company manufacturers specialty vacuum cleaners such as hand-held electric and cordless units Products Company, a manufacturer of vacuum cleaner brushes, is also reported within this segment. very large - over 200,000 square feet - retail outlet and sizable warehouse facilities in Omaha, Nebraska. It serves a trade Retailing of Home Furnishings — The Nebraska Furniture Mart operates a home furnishing retail business from a area with a radius around Omaha of approximately 300 miles. Berkshire owns 80% of this business: key managers own large kitchens in California. See's distributes its candies through its own retail stores - over 200 in number - located in Candy - See's produces boxed chocolates and other confectionary products with an emphasis on quality in two shipments made nationwide from a seasonally-varying number of quantity order distribution centers. 12 western and midwestern states, including Hawaii. A meaningful volume of candy business is also recorded for direct earning, a preschool educational program, are among the products of this segment. Revised editions of the encyclope- Encyclopedias, Other Reference Materials — World Book encyclopedias as well as Childeraft and Early World of dia are composed and published annually. In the first quarter of each year an updating yearbook is published and to schools, libraries and individual households by a commissioned sales force of thousands located throughout the marketed by mail to owners of earlier editions. Otherwise, products are marketed primarily by the direct sales method United States, Canada, Australia and the British Isles. 48

[第 51 页]

[PAGE 51]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

制造业、出版与零售业务

(单位:千美元)

资产负债表

资产

1989 年

1988 年 12 月 31 日

现金及现金等价物

25,165

应收账款

175,629

43,376

存货

165,751

150,394

房产及设备

141,935

133,762

其他

18,363

130,363

负债

$ 526,843

$ 473,565

15,670

所得税

应付账款、应计费用及其他

$ 214,152

长期债务及其他借款

38,046

37,948

$ 179,301

47,738

权益

290,146

264,743

37,704

伯克希尔股东权益

少数股东权益

211,531

25,166

18,999

$ 526,843

236,697

189,823

$ 473,565

208,822

利润表

(单位:千美元)

1989 年

1988 年

1987 年

收入:

销售及服务收入

利息收入

$ 1,526,458

8,405

$1,407,642

2,579

2,472

6,724

$1,326,829

杂项收入

6,789

1,416,838

722

成本及费用:

1,334,340

销售、一般及管理费用

838,741

487,664

747,831

债务利息

6,197

461,783

699,730

所得税费用

税前经营利润

1,332,602

4,955

445,970

204,840

1,214,569

6,730

125,863

78,977

202,269

1,152,430

76,216

181,910

净利润

少数股东权益

$ 120,881

4,982

126,053

79,588

$121,700

4,353

102,322

98,839

3,483

这些报表并非在所有方面都符合公认会计原则

这些报表未经审计

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. MANUFACTURING, PUBLISHING and RETAILING BUSINESSES (dollars in thousands) Balance Sheets Assets 1989 December 31, 1988 Cash and cash equivalents........ Accounts receivable 25,165 Inventories. 175,629 43,376 Properties and equipment 165,751 150,394 Other 141,935 133,762 18,363 130,363 Liabilities $ 526,843 $ 473,565 15,670 Income taxes... Accounts payable, accruals and other $ 214,152 Term debt and other borrowings 38,046 37,948 $ 179,301 47,738 Equity 290,146 264,743 37,704 Berkshire shareholders' Minority shareholders 211,531 25,166 18,999 $ 526.843 236,697 189,823 $ 473.565 208.822 Statements of Earnings (dollars in thousands) 1989 1988 1987 Revenues: Sales and service revenues terest income $ 1,526,458 8,405 $1,407,642 .. . . 1,537,442 2,579 2,472 6,724 $1,326,829 undry incom 6,789 1.416,838 722 Costs and expenses: 1.334,340 Soline, gendal add denisestle. 838,741 487,664 747,831 Interest on debt. 6,197 461,783 699,730 Income tax expense Earnings from operations before income taxes .... 1,332,602 4,955 445,970 204,840 1,214,569 6,730 125,863 78.977 202,269 1,152,430 76.216 181,910 Net earnings... Minority interest. $ 120,881 4,982 126,053 79,588 $121,700 4,353 102,322 98,839 3,483 repare in es comes but at cute entert rit on ereie urine apions are not These statements do not conform to GAAP in all respects These statements are unaudited 49

[第 52 页]

[PAGE 52]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

金融类业务

共同储蓄与贷款协会及其子公司、斯科特-费泽金融集团有限公司及其子公司构成伯克希尔的金融类业务。

(单位:千美元)

资产负债表

1989 年 12 月 31 日

1988 年 12 月 31 日

资产

现金及现金等价物

$

40,035

$

63,193

投资成本:

固定期限证券:

30,524

17,473

权益证券:

可赎回优先股

30,524

48,013

不可赎回优先股

FHLMC 普通股

36,852

71,729

152,807

136,970

36,852

71,729

有抵押应收贷款 (1)

预付所得税

分期及其他应收款

173,214

153,755

其他

17,183

12,864

14,375

13,558

负债

$ 553,629

$ 568,021

储蓄账户

所得税

应付账款、应计费用及其他

$

293,073

18,432

$

288,522

159,593

1,481

32,759

定期债务及其他借款

150,202

1,807

权益

472,579

473,290

少数股东权益

伯克希尔股东权益

71,329

9,721

9,882

$ 553,629

81,050

84,849

$ 568,021

94,731

利润表

(单位:千美元)

收入:

1989 年

1988 年

1987 年

投资证券的利息及股息

贷款及融资应收款的利息及费用

$

49,421

杂项收入

19,230

$

50,230

20,842

$

47,858

68,914

263

71,710

638

22,708

72,340

1,774

支出:

债务利息

储蓄账户利息

21,530

一般及管理费用

20,753

13,924

20,840

23,313

14,088

15,060

20,944

所得税费用

税前经营利润

56,207

58,241

29,493 (2)

12,707

13,469

65,497

1,237

11,458

2,011

6,843

少数股东权益

11,470

6,298

545

净利润

$ 10,036

834

$ 10,483

975

$

5,941

357

(1) 包括抵押支持证券:1989 年 $34,316,1988 年 $45,367。

(2) 包括预付 FSLJC 保险费的 $3,618 冲销。

这些财务报表并非在所有方面符合公认会计准则。

这些财务报表未经审计。

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. FINANCE-TYPE BUSINESSES up Berkshire's finance-type operations. Mutual Savings and Loan Association and its subsidiary and Scott Fetzer Financial Group, Inc. and its subsidiaries make (dollars in thousands) Balance Sheets 1989 December 31, 1988 Assets Cash and cash equivalents Investments at cost: $ 40,035 $ 63,193 Fixed maturies: Equity securities: Redeemable preferred stocks 30,524 17,473 30,524 48,013 Nonredeemable preferred stocks FHLMC common stock.... 36,852 71,729 152,807 136,970 36,852 71,729 Collateralized loans receivable (1). Prepaid income taxes Installment and other receivables 173,214 153,755 Other 17,183 12,864 14.375 13,558 Liabilities $ 553,629 $ 568,021 Savings accounts Income taxes Accounts payable, accruals and other $ 293,073 18,432 $ 288,522 159,593 1,481 32,759 Term debt and other borrowings 150.202 1,807 Equity 472,579 473,290 Minority shareholders Berkshire shareholders' 71,329 9,721 9,882 $ 553.629 81,050 - 84,849 $ 568.021 94.731 Statements of Earnings (dollars in thousands) Revenues: 1989 1988 1987 Interest and dividends on investment securities ... Interest and fees on loans and financed receivables ..... $ 49,421 Sundry income. 19,230 $ 50,230 20,842 $ 47,858 68,914 263 71,710 638 22,708 72,340 1,774 Expenses: Interest on debt Interest on savings accounts 21,530 General and administrative 20,753 13,924 20,840 23,313 14.088 15,060 20,944 Income tax expense Earnings from operations before income taxes _56,207 58.241 29,493(2) 12,707 13,469 65,497 1,237 11,458 2,011 6,843 linority interes 11,470 6,298 545 et earning $ 10,036 _ 834 $ 10,483 _ 975 $ 5.941 357 (1) Includes mortgage-backed securities of $34,316, 1989 and $45.367, 1988. (2) Includes $3,618 write off of prepaid FSLJC insurance premiums. hese statements do not conform to GAAP in all respect hese statements are unaudite 50

[第 53 页]

[PAGE 53]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

非经营活动

(未审计且不完全符合 GAAP 的收入与费用)

这些报表反映了合并财务报表中的资产、负债及股东权益数值,

并调整了此前呈报的业务集团财务报表(第 45 至 50 页)。

净资产报表

(单位:千美元)

资产

1989 年

12 月 31 日

1988 年

投资:

现金及现金等价物

$ 96,018

$ 38,511

固定到期投资:

债券

81,000

74,977

普通股

50,000

可赎回优先股

2,338

资产账户调整(1)

11,468

预付所得税

未摊销商誉(1)

140,544

79,524

其他

28,312

117,970

递延所得税

83,348

64,681

合计

8,985

53,606

负债

$ 557,197

$ 384,068

应付账款、应计费用及其他

所得税

$ 31,610

$ 28,067

定期债务及其他借款

809,877

292,103

其他负债

(24,716)

7,591

合计

$ 816,771

$ 327,761

权益

少数股东权益

(272,297)

12,723

伯克希尔股东权益

43,749

12,558

合计

$ 557,197

(259,574)

$ 384,068

56,307

收益报表

(单位:千美元)

收入:

1989 年

1988 年

1987 年

杂项收入

7,256

16,513

9,257

利息及股息收入

35,907

28,503(2)

7,404

合计

$ 14,823

$ 6,969

$ 21,792

费用:

公司管理费用

5,867

3,382

4,966

股东指定捐款

3,754

3,380

资产账户调整(1)

商誉摊销(1)

3,371

5,987

6,937

债务利息

2,719

4,938

5,546

其他成本及费用

2,862

37,350

946

所得税抵免(费用)

30,658

56,903

49,572

费用超过收入部分

538

1,754

4,930

少数股东权益

(40,390)

9,829

(13,665)

净亏损

$ (31,188)

$ (13,593)

$ (4,919)

(1)部分数值涉及会计变更调整计划。

这些报表在所有方面均不完全符合 GAAP。

这些报表未经审计。

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. NON-OPERATING ACTIVITIES revenues and expenses that were not assigned to any Berkshire operating group in the unaudited, and not fully GAY. These statements reflect the consolidated financial statement values for assets liabilities, shareholders' equity, adjusted group financial statements heretofore presented (pages 45 to 50). Statements of Net Assets (dollars in thousands) Assets 1989 December 31, 1988 Investments: Cash and cash equivalents $ 96,018 $ 38,511 Fixed maturities: Bonds. Common stocks. Redeemable preferred stocks. 81,000 74,977 50,000 2,338 Property account adjustments (1) 11,468 Prepaid income taxes Unamortized goodwill (1) 140,544 79,524 28,312 117,970 83,348 Other 64,681 8,985 53,606 9,983 Liabilities $ 557.197 $ 384.068 Accounts payable, accruals and other ncome taxes $ 31,610 Term debt and other borrowings 809,877 (24,716) $ 28,067 292,103 7,591 Equity 816,771 327,761 Minority shareholders' Berkshire shareholders' (272,297) 12,723 43,749 12,558 $ 557,197 (259,574) $ 384,068 56,307 Statements of Earnings (dollars in thousands) Revenues: 1989 1988 1987 Sundry income. Interest and dividend income 7,256 16,513 9,257 _ 35,907 28,503(2) 7,404 $ 14,823 6,969 Expenses: 21,792 Corporate administration.... 5,867 3,382 4,966 3,754 Shareholder designated contributions 3,380 Property account adjustments (1) Amortization of goodwill (1)....... 3,371 5,987 6,937 2,719 4,938 5,546 2,862 Interest on debt ...... 37,350 946 30,658 Other costs and expenses 56,903 49,572 538 1,754 4,930 Income tax credit (expense) Excess of expenses before income taxes (40,390) 9,829 (13,665) 23.410 (30,561) (12,475) 1,190 (2,605) (1,618) 627 1,118 (4,223) Minority interest Net loss $ (31,188) $ (13,593) $ (4,919) 696 11) Pouts so ever im so 0 ai am to counting bust eruption plans., These statements do not conform to GAP in all respects These statements are unaudited 51

[第 54 页]

[PAGE 54]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

股东指定捐赠计划

1981 年 10 月 14 日,董事长致信股东*,阐述该计划。公司已连续九年每年开展这一企业捐赠计划。

以下是该信的部分内容:

“1981 年 9 月 30 日,伯克希尔收到美国财政部的一项税务裁定。”

“每位伯克希尔股东——按其持有伯克希尔股份数量的比例——在大多数年份,都将能为您所选择的慈善机构带来一笔可观的利益。您来指定慈善机构;伯克希尔负责开支票。该裁定确认,这样做不会引起任何税务问题。”

“因此,我们的大约 1500 名股东现在可以行使一项特权——在股权集中的企业中,这项特权通常由股东行使,而在股权分散的企业中,它几乎完全由管理层把持。”

“在股权分散的公司里,高管们通常自行安排所有慈善捐赠,股东完全没有发言权,这些捐赠主要分为两类:

(1)被认为能直接给公司带来收益、且收益大致与捐赠成本相当的捐赠;

(2)被认为能通过各种难以衡量且长期延迟的反馈效应,间接给公司带来收益的捐赠。”

“我和伯克希尔的其他高管过去已经安排、未来仍将安排所有第一类慈善捐赠。不过,这类捐赠的总体规模一直很低,而且很可能继续保持低位,因为能够证明能给伯克希尔带来大致相称直接收益的捐赠项目并不多。”

“在第二类捐赠中,伯克希尔的慈善捐款几乎为零,因为我对常规的企业做法并不认同,却又没有更好的做法可以替代。让我对常规企业做法感到不安的是,捐赠决策往往更多地取决于谁来开口要钱、以及同行企业如何应对,而不是基于对受捐方活动的客观评估。惯例常常压倒理性。”

“一个常见的结果是,企业高管借助股东的钱,来满足自己饱受特定社会压力影响的慈善倾向。这里还常有一层额外的矛盾之处:众多企业高管一边痛斥政府分配纳税人的钱,一边却热衷于由自己来分配股东的钱。”

“对伯克希尔来说,另一种模式看来更合适。正如我不想让你用我的银行账户开支票,去实现你个人的慈善判断一样,我觉得用你的公司‘银行账户’去实现我个人的慈善选择,同样也不合适。你的慈善偏好和我的并无高下之分,而且,对你我而言,可以用来以节税方式支持慈善事业的资金,主要沉淀在公司层面,而不是在我们自己手中。”

“在这种情况下,我认为伯克希尔应该效仿股权更集中的公司,而不是更大的上市公司。假如你我各持有某公司 50% 的股份,我们的慈善决策就会很简单。与公司运营直接相关的慈善事业,将优先占用我们可供支配的慈善资金。在‘业务相关’捐赠之后剩下的任何资金,将按我们大致相当的持股比例,分配给你我各自关注的各类慈善事业。如果我们的公司经理提出某些建议,我们会认真听取——但最终决定权在你我手中。尽管我们采用了公司制形式,但在慈善这件事上,我们多半会表现得像一家合伙企业。”

*版权 © 1981 沃伦·E·巴菲特 保留所有权利

52

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. SHAREHOLDER-DESIGNATED CONTRIBUTIONS On October 14, 1981, the Chairman sent to the shareholders a letter* explaining the program. Portions The Company has conducted this program of corporate giving during each of the past nine years. of that letter follow: that, in most years, should produce a significant benefit for charities of your choice. "On September 30, 1981 Berkshire received a tax ruling from the U.S. Treasury Department "Each Berkshire shareholder — on a basis proportional to the number of shares of Berkshire You'll name the charity; Berkshire will write the check. The ruling states that there will be no exercised by the owners in closely-held businesses, is almost exclusively exercised by the managers "Thus, our approximately 1500 owners now can exercise a perquisite that, although routinely in more widely-held businesses. no input at all from shareholders, in two main categories: "In a widely-held corporation the executives ordinarily arrange all charitable donations, with (1) Donations considered to benefit the corporation directly in an amount roughly (2) Donations considered to benefit the corporation indirectly through hard-to-measure, commensurate with the cost of the donation; and long-delayed feedback effects of various kinds. all charitable donations in the first category. However, the aggregate level of giving in such category "I and other Berkshire executives have arranged in the past, as we will arrange in the future, to produce roughly commensurate direct benefits to Berkshire. has been quite low, and very likely will remain quite low, because not many gifts can be shown not comfortable with ordinary corporate practice and had no better practice to substitute. What "In the second category, Berkshire's charitable gifts have been virtually nil, because I am bothers me about ordinary corporate practice is the way gifts tend to be made based more on of the donee's activities. Conventionality often overpowers rationality. who does the asking and how corporate peers are responding than on an objective evaluation of the corporate manager, who usually is heavily influenced by specific social pressures on him. "A common result is the use of the stockholder's money to implement the charitable inclinations Frequently there is an added incongruity; many corporate managers deplore governmental allocation dollar. of the taxpayer's dollar but embrace enthusiastically their own allocation of the shareholder's your personal judgments by writing checks on my bank account for charities of your choice, "For Berkshire, a different model seems appropriate. Just as I wouldn't want you to implement I feel it inappropriate to write checks on your corporate "bank account" for charities of my choice. foster charitable interests in a tax-deductible manner reside largely at the corporate level rather Your charitable preferences are as good as mine and, for both you and me, funds available to than in our own hands. "Under such circumstances, I believe Berkshire should imitate more closely-held companies, not larger public companies. If you and I each own 50% of a corporation, our charitable decision have first claim on our available charitable funds. Any balance available after the "operations- making would be simple. Charities very directly related to the operations of the business would related" contributions would be divided among various charitable interests of the two of us, some suggestions, we would listen carefully - but the final decision would be ours. Despite on a basis roughly proportional to our ownership interest. If the manager of our company had partnership. our corporate form, in this aspect of the business we probably would behave as if we were a *Copyright © 1981 By Warren E. Buffett All Rights Reserved 52

[第 55 页]

[PAGE 55]

我们通过一家大型、股权相当分散的公司来运作。我们的税务裁定将允许这种“在可行的情况下,我坚信应保持这种合伙人心态,即便在这一领域的行为也要像合伙人那样……”

“我很高兴伯克希尔的捐款可以变成由所有者主导。”

“具有讽刺意味,但可以理解的是,数量众多且日益增加的大公司都有慈善捐赠政策——许多甚至匹配董事的捐款——但据我所知,没有一家公司有计划根据该计划匹配其员工的捐款(请做好准备)以及所有者的慈善捐赠。我说‘可以理解’,是因为许多大公司的股票是由那些投资期限短、缺乏长期所有者视角的机构以‘旋转门’方式持有的……”

“我们的股东是另一类人。正如我在 1979 年年报中提到的,每年年底,超过 98% 的股份都是由年初时就已是股东的人持有。这种对业务的长期承诺体现了所有者心态,作为你们的管理者,我打算在一切可行方式下对此予以承认。指定捐款……”

根据本计划进行的捐款历史如下:

年份 | 每股指定金额 | 参与股份比例 | 捐款金额 | 参与慈善机构数量

--- | --- | --- | --- | ---

1982 | $2 | 95.8% | $1,783,655 | 675

1981 | $3 | 95.6% | $ 890,948 | 704

1983 | $1 | 96.4% | $3,066,501 | 1,353

1985 | $4 | 96.8% | $3,179,049 | 1,519

1984 | $3 | 97.2% | $3,996,820 | 1,724

1986 | $5 | 97.1% | $4,006,260 | 1,934

1987 | $4 | 97.2% | $4,965,665 | 2,050

1988 | $5 | 97.4% | $4,937,574 | 2,319

1989 | $6 | 96.9% | $5,867,254 | 2,550

*以机构名义持有的股份不能参与。

除了上述股东指定捐款外,伯克希尔及其子公司还根据各业务经营经理的地方层面决策进行了一些捐款。

该计划可能不会在偶尔某些年份进行——如果这些年份的捐款会导致低于标准或无法享受税收抵扣的话。在其他年份,伯克希尔预计会通知股东每股可指定捐款的金额,随通知附上回复表格,让股东回复其指定。如果该计划在 1990 年进行,通知将于 1990 年 9 月 15 日左右寄送给在我们的登记员记录中截至 1990 年 8 月 31 日营业结束时登记在册的股东,股东须在 11 月 15 日前回复。股东应注意,8 月底的登记日期比过去几年使用的相应登记日期提早了一个月。所需回复日期也提前了十五天。股东还应注意,以机构名义持有的股份不能参与该计划。要符合资格,股份必须在 8 月 31 日以所有者个人名下,或适用的所有权的信托、公司、合伙企业或遗产名义登记。

we operate through a large, fairly widely-held corporation. Our Treasury ruling will allow such "Wherever feasible, I believe in maintaining such a partnership frame of mind, even though partnership-like behavior in this area ... "I am pleased that Berkshire donations can become owner-directed. understandable, that a large and growing number of major corporations have charitable policies It is ironic, but this one - many even match gifts made by directors) but none, to my knowledge, has a plan pursuant to which they will match gifts made by their employees (and - brace yourself for matching charitable gifts by owners. I say 'understandable' because much of the stock of many investment horizons, and that lack a long-term owner's perspective... large corporations is owned on a revolving door' basis by institutions that have short-term at the end of each year more than 98% of our shares are owned by people who were shareholders "Our own shareholders are a different breed. As 1 mentioned in the 1979 annual report, at the beginning of the year. This long-term commitment to the business reflects an owner mentality which, as your manager, l intend to acknowledge in all feasible ways. The designated contributions * * The history of contributions made pursuant to this program since its inception follows: Specified Amount Eligible* Shares Percent of Year per Share Participating Contributed Amount Charities No. of 1982 1981 $2 95.8% 95.6% $1,783,655 1983 $3 $1 96.4% $3,066,501 $ 890,948 675 1,353 704 1985 1984 $4 $3 96.8% 97.2% $3,179,049 97.1% $3,996,820 $4,006,260 1,724 1,519 1986 16:87 1988 $5 $4 97.2% $5 97.4% $4,965,665 $4,937,574 2,050 1,934 1989 $6 96.9% $5,867,254 2,319 2,550

  • Shares registered in street name are not eligible to participate.

In addition to the shareholder-designated contributions summarized above, Berkshire and its sub- sidiaries have made certain contributions pursuant to local level decisions of operating managers of the businesses.

  • *

* produce substandard or no tax deductions. In other years Berkshire expects to intorm shareholders of The program may not be conducted in the occasional year, if any, when the contributions would the amount per share that may be designated, and a reply form will accompany the notice allowing be mailed on or about September 15 to shareholders of record reflected in our Registrar's records as shareholders to respond with their designations. If the program is conducted in 1990, the notice will of the close of business August 31, 1990, and shareholders will be given until November 15 to respond. the corresponding of-record date used in past years. The required response date is also fifteen days earlier. Shareholders should note that the end-of-August record date is one month earlier in the year than in the program. To qualify, shares must be registered on August 31 in the owner's individual name(s) Shareholders should also note the fact that shares held in street name are not eligible to participate or the name of an owning trust, corporation, partnership or estate, as applicable. 53

[第 56 页]

[PAGE 56]

来自公司董事长的股东。

西科金融公司 1989 年年报中包含了以下致西科股东的信。

西科金融公司

致股东的信

致各位股东:

1989 日历年度,合并“正常”经营利润(即:在扣除所有非常经营项目和所有出售证券的净收益之前)增长至 24,414,000 美元(每股 3.43 美元),上一年度为 23,564,000 美元(每股 3.31 美元)。

合并净利润(即:扣除非常经营项目并加上所有出售证券的净收益之后)增长至 30,334,000 美元(每股 4.26 美元),上一年度为 30,089,000 美元(每股 4.22 美元)。

西科拥有三家主要子公司:位于帕萨迪纳的 Mutual Savings、总部在奥马哈且目前主要从事再保险业务的西科金融保险公司,以及总部在芝加哥、经营钢材仓储和特种金属制品业务的 Precision Steel。过去两年的合并净利润细分如下(单位:千美元,每股数据除外)(1):

1989 年 12 月 31 日1988 年 12 月 31 日
金额每股金额每股
“正常”净经营利润:
Mutual Savings4,191 美元0.59 美元4,694 美元0.66 美元
西科金融保险业务14,2762.0012,0941.70
Precision Steel 的业务2,7690.393,1670.44
所有其他“正常”净经营利润 (2)3,1780.453,6090.51
西科合并净利润24,4143.4323,5643.31
出售 Bowery Savings Bank 权益的收益4,8360.68
出售有价证券的净收益5,9200.831,6890.23
总计30,3344.2630,0894.22

(1) 所有数据均已扣除所得税。

(2) 已扣除利息和其他费用。

这一补充性的利润分解与遵循标准会计惯例的经审计财务报表中使用的分解方式有所不同。提供此补充性分解是因为它被认为对股东有用。

stockholders from the Chairman of the Company. The 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation included the following letter to Wesco WESCO FINANCIAL CORPORATION LETTER TO SHAREHOLDERS To Our Shareholders: Consolidated "normal" operating income (i.e., before all unusual operating income and all net gains from sales of securities) for the calendar year 1989 increased to $24,414,000 ($3.43 per share) from $23,564,000 ($3.31 per share) in the previous year. securities) increased to $30,334,000 ($4.26 per share) from $30,089,000 ($4.22 per share) in the Consolidated net income (i.e., after unusual operating items and all net gains from sales of previous year. Company, headquartered in Omaha and currently engaged principally in the reinsurance business, Wesco has three major subsidiaries, Mutual Savings, in Pasadena, Wesco-Financial Insurance metal products businesses. Consolidated net income for the two years just ended breaks down as and Precision Steel, headquartered in Chicago and engaged in the steel warehousing and specialty follows (in 000s except for per-share amounts) (1): December 31, 1989 December 31, 1988 Per "Normal" net operating income of: Amount Wesco Per Share Amount Share Wesco Mutual Savings ... $ 4,191 $ .59 $ 4,694 $ .66 Wesco-Financial Insurance business 14,276 2.00 12,094 1.70 Precision Steel's businesses (...•• 2,769 .39 3,167 44 All other "normal" net operating income (2) 24,414 3,178 45 3.43 3,609 .51 23,564 3.31 Gain on sale of interest in Bowery Savings Bank. 4,836 .68 Wesco consolidated net income Net gains on sales of marketable securities.................. 5,920 $30,334 .83 $4.26 $30,089 1,689 .23 $4.22 (1) All figures are net of income taxes. (2) After deduction of interest and other This supplementary breakdown of earnings differs somewhat from that used in audited financial statements which follow standard accounting convention. The supplementary breakdown is fur- nished because it is considered useful to shareholders. 54

[第 57 页]

[PAGE 57]

以下内容摘自西科金融公司 1989 年年报:

互助储蓄

互助储蓄 1989 年的“正常”净经营利润为 4,191,000 美元,较上年的 4,694,000 美元下降 11%。

1989 年的下降主要源于利差缩小——储蓄成本上升的幅度超过了贷款和投资的收益率。

像往常一样,这些“正常收入”数字来自一个极不正常的储贷机构。互助储蓄 1988 年及 1989 年末的单独资产负债表附于本年年报末尾。它们显示:(1)储蓄账户总额从上年 2.89 亿美元增至 2.93 亿美元;(2)股东权益对储蓄账户负债的比率非常高(接近任何成熟储贷机构中的最高水平);(3)储蓄账户负债中有很大一部分由现金等价物和有价证券抵消;(4)1989 年末贷款组合(主要是房地产抵押贷款)约为 1.54 亿美元,较 1988 年末的 1.37 亿美元略有上升。

1989 年末的贷款组合虽然几乎没有违约损失风险,但平均利率仅为 9.23%,可能接近美国储贷机构中的最低水平,不过较 1988 年末的 8.70% 略有上升。由于贷款组合几乎全部由短期工具或利率随市场自动调整的工具构成,目前贷款组合中未实现的贬值远少于互助储蓄计息证券和公用事业优先股中未实现的增值。截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日,该增值约为 1,130 万美元。

虽然互助储蓄平均支付的储蓄利率与收取的贷款利率之间的利差仍偏低,不足以带来可观利润,但这一利差去年再次改善。此外,利差不足的不利影响在近些年的每一年都因各种税收优惠投资(主要是优先股和市政债券)的效果而有所减轻。这种用税收优惠来弥补贷款利差不足的做法的负面风险在于:优先股和市政债券具有固定收益率和长期限,如果利率整体水平大幅上升,它们会贬值,且收益不足以覆盖互助储蓄的利息及其他成本。鉴于这一风险,互助储蓄的总投入相对于其净资产规模一直保持保守。

互助储蓄仍是旧联邦监管定义下的“合格储蓄机构”(该定义于 1991 年 6 月 30 日失效,要求 60% 的资产投向各类住房相关类别)。它计划继续将几乎所有应收贷款保持在短期或利率随市场波动的状态。所有新的浮动利率贷款都设有每年 25% 的利率上限,这比竞争对手通常提供的“高于市场 2.5 个百分点”的上限高出十多个百分点。当然,为了获得这种额外的利率上升保护,互助储蓄“付出”的代价是:(1)相对于利率指数的利差更低,以及(2)无法发放所需金额的贷款。

如随附财务报表附注 10 所述,西科在互助储蓄中的权益账面价值(1989 年 12 月 31 日为 4,890 万美元)高估了可按账面价值出售或清算所得的税后金额。如果互助储蓄的所有资产净负债按 4,890 万美元的账面价值出售,母公司将收到的现金远少于 4,890 万美元,因为会计上被指定为股东权益的大约 4,700 万美元,在大多数税务目的下被视为坏账准备,因而需缴纳高额所得税。

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation Mutual Savings of 11% from the $4,694,000 figure the previous year. Mutual Savings' "normal" net operating income of $4,191,000 in 1989 represented a decrease cost of holding savings increased more than yield on loans and investments. The decrease in 1989 was primarily attributable to a less favorable interest rate "spread" as association. As usual, these "normal-income" figures come from a decidedly abnormal savings and loan this annual report. They show (1) total savings accounts rising to $293 million from $289 million the Separate balance Sheets of Mutual Savings at yearend 1988 and 1989 are set forth at the end of year before, (2) a very high ratio of shareholders' equity to savings account liabilities (near the account liabilities offset by cash equivalents and marketable securities, and (4) a loan portfolio highest for any mature U.S. savings and loan association), (3) a substantial portion of savings (mostly real estate mortgages) of about $154 million at the end of 1989, up slightly from $137 million at the end of 1988. bore an average interest rate of only 9.23%, probably near the lowest among U.S. savings and loan The loan portfolio at the end of 1989, although containing almost no risk of loss from defaults, entirely made up of instruments of short maturity or bearing interest rates that adjust automatically associations, but up moderately from 8.70% at the end of 1988. Because the loan portfolio is almost with the market, there is now much less unrealized depreciation in the loan portfolio than the net unrealized appreciation in Mutual Savings' interest-bearing stocks. That appreciation at December 31, 1989 was about $11.3 million. securities and public utility preferred received on loans remains too low to provide respectable profits, this "spread" improved again last While the "spread" between Mutual Savings' average interest rates paid on savings and by the effect of various forms of tax-advantaged investment, primarily preferred stock and municipal year. Moreover, the disadvantage from inadequate "spread" has been reduced in each recent year loans is the risk that preferred stock and municipal bonds, with their fixed yield and long life, will bonds. The negative side of this tax-advantaged antidote to inadequate interest rate margin on decline in value and not provide enough income to cover Mutual Savings' interest and other costs, if the general level of interest rates should sharply rise. In view of this risk, Mutual Savings' total commitment has been kept conservative, relative to the amount of its net worth. Mutual Savings remains a "qualified thrift lender" under the old federal regulatory definition to continue keeping substantially all loans receivable either with short expected lives or with interest (which ends june 30, 1991) requiring 60% of assets in various housing related categories. it planes rates that fluctuate with the market. All new variable-rate loans are "capped" at the 25% per annum level, which is over ten percentage points higher than the common 2½-points-over-market "cap" offered by competing associations. Naturally, to gain this extra protection from interest rate increase, Mutual Savings "pays" by (1) getting lower "spreads" over an interest rate index, and (2) not being able to make loans in amounts desired. As pointed out in Note 10 to the accompanying financial statements, the book value of Wesco's after taxes, from sale or liquidation at book value. If all Mutual Savings' assets, net of liabilities, were equity in Mutual Savings ($48.9 million at December 31, 1989) overstates the amount realizable, less than $48.9 million after substantial income taxation imposed because about $47 million of what to be sold for the $48.9 million reported as book value, the parent corporation would receive much Is designated shareholders' equity for accounting purposes is considered bad debt reserves for most tax purposes. 55

[第 58 页]

[PAGE 58]

转载自西科金融公司 1989 年年报:

不动产业的隐蔽价值。互助储蓄不仅在有价证券的未实现增值中存在隐蔽价值,其持有的止赎房产(主要是 1966 年在圣巴巴拉海滨或附近收购的 22 英亩土地)在长期持有后,价值已远超过其资产负债表上 840 万美元的账面成本。对该房产进行合理的、社区敏感性开发的进程,因土地使用法规的行政程序已被拖延超过 14 年。但奇迹般地得以报告的是,作为被批准开发为 32 栋房屋项目的一部分,8 栋房屋及休闲设施正在项目上处于不同完工阶段,其间点缀着大片开放区域。互助储蓄计划将该开发项目在各个方面做到一流,并在景观品质上做到独一无二。

不动产中的隐蔽价值受到允许建造的房屋数量较少(32 栋)以及其中仅约一半房屋能拥有显著海景这一事实的限制。额外的限制将来自高昂的私人道路、排污及公用设施改善与连接、景观美化,以及房屋对地块的非标准化、环境敏感性适应成本。此外,政府部门施加的各种收费与负担(包括沉重的考古义务)将大幅降低我们相比若 1970 年代初的分区规划和开发气候延续至当前时代本应获得的潜在回收。我们已将土地价值的很大一部分“送给”了圣巴巴拉县,以换取对该土地的使用许可。

前面段落描述的这家储蓄与贷款协会,长期以来与大多数其他协会截然不同,在 1988 年又增加了一项显著的新异常之举。互助储蓄将其在联邦住宅贷款抵押公司(广泛称为“房地美”)股票的头寸增加至 2,400,000 股。这占其总流通股的 4%,当时是任何单一持有人允许持有的法定上限。互助储蓄的平均成本为每股 29.89 美元,而 1989 年底在纽约证券交易所的交易价格为每股 67.12 美元。因此,基于 1989 年底的交易价格,互助储蓄在房地美股票上拥有约 8,940 万美元的未实现税前利润。按当前税率计算,潜在税后利润约为 5,260 万美元,即每股西科流通股 7.39 美元。

房地美最初由一家联邦机构(联邦住宅贷款银行委员会)创建并长期运营,现在由私人所有,主要由机构投资者持有,并由一个独立的董事会管理。房地美主要通过购买住房抵押贷款来支持住房建设,这些贷款随即转化为由其担保并迅速出售的抵押贷款支持证券。在此过程中,房地美赚取费用和“利差”,同时避免了大部分利率变动风险。如房地美近年股本资本所获高收益率所示,这是一项比大多数(甚至大部分排名前 10% 的)储蓄与贷款协会所从事的业务要好得多的生意。造成这种高收益率的一个讽刺性原因是:作为联邦监管者创建物的它,在取代储蓄与贷款行业前身大部分功能的同时,却不需支付存款保险费。

按房地美当前股息率(每股每年 1.60 美元)计算,互助储蓄在其每股 29.89 美元的平均成本上获得的税前收益率仅为 5.35%。税后,股息收益率仅为 4.4%,但这仍相当于当前高质量抵押贷款税后收益率的大约 75%。此外,房地美在避免重大贷款损失以及增加盈利和股息率方面有着非常可信的记录,从而促进了其股票市场价格的增长。以下是 1985–1989 年的数据:

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation buried value in real estate. The foreclosed property on hand (mostly 22 acres at or near the Mutual Savings has not only a buried value in unrealized appreciation of securities but also a oceanfront in Santa Barbara, acquired in 1966) has become worth over a long holding period sensitive development of this property has been delayed over 14 years in the course of administra- considerably more than its $8.4 million balance sheet carrying cost. Reasonable, community- various stages of completion on the property as part of an authorized development into 32 houses tion of land-use laws. But, miraculous to report, eight houses, plus recreation facilities, are in interspersed with large open areas. Mutual Savings plans to make the development first-rate in every respect, and unique in the quality of its landscaping. The buried value in real estate is limited by the small number of houses allowed (32) and by the fact that only about half of such houses will have a significant ocean view. Additional limitation will come from high cost of private streets, sewage and utility improvements and connections, landscap- ing, and non-standardized, environmentally sensitive adaptation of housing to the site. Also, various will drastically reduce our potential recovery from what it would have been had the zoning and charges and burdens, including heavy archaeological obligations imposed by governmental bodies, development climate of the early 1970s continued into the present era. We have "given" a very large fraction of the value of our land to the County of Santa Barbara in exchange for permission to use it at all. The savings and loan association described in the foregoing paragraphs, quite different from Savings increased its position in stock of Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (widely known most other associations for a long time, added a significant new abnormality during 1988. Mutual as "Freddie Mac") to 2,400,000 shares. This is 4% of the total shares outstanding, the legal limit for share, compared to a price of $67.12 per share in trading on the New York Stock Exchange at the any one holder at the time the shares were purchased. Mutual Savings' average cost is $29.89 per end of 1989. Thus, based on 1989 yearend trading prices, Mutual Savings had an unrealized pre-tax is about $52.6 million, or $7.39 per Wesco share outstanding. profit in Freddie Mac shares of about $89.4 million. At current tax rates the potential after-tax profit Freddie Mac, formerly created and long run by a federal agency (the Federal Home Loan Bank independent board of directors. Freddie Mac supports housing primarily by purchasing housing Board), is now owned privately, largely by institutional investors and is now governed by an mortgage loans for immediate transmutation into mortgage-backed securities that it guarantees and rate-change risk. This is a much better business than that carried on by most (or indeed most of the promptly sells. In the process Freddie Mac earns fees and "spreads" while avoiding most interest- top 10% of) savings and loan associations, as demonstrated by Freddie Mac's high percentage returns earned on equity capital in recent years. One ironic cause of the high returns is that this function of the savings and loan industry. creation of federal regulators pays no deposit-insurance premiums as it replaces much of the former At Freddie Mac's current dividend rate ($1.60 per annum per share), Mutual Savings' pre-tax yield is only 5.35% on its $29.89 average cost per share. Post-tax, the dividend yield is only 4.4%, but this amounts to about 75% of the current after-tax yield from very high grade mortgages. Moreover, Freddie Mac has a very creditable history of avoiding significant loan losses and increasing its earnings and dividend rate, thus contributing to increases in the market price of its stock. Following are figures for 1985-1989: 56

[第 59 页]

[PAGE 59]

节选自西科金融公司 1989 年年报

Freddie Mac

截至 12/31 的年度:

每股收益

平均净资产

收益率

1985

2.98 美元

.53

9.19 美元

1986

3.72

30.0%

1.13

15.17

1987

4.53

28.5

1.10

12.12

1988

5.73

282

1.25

50.50

27.5

1989

6.57

1.60

67.12

25.0

贷款与储蓄法规的修订。但很明显,这些协会很快将以某种模式被“重新监管”,降低引发新一轮存款保险损失洪流的可能性,这类损失最终由纳税人承担。引发那次立法行动的是一波之前的损失洪流,现在看来很可能超过 1500 亿美元。这些损失由以下因素共同造成:(1)协会和银行在支付利息吸引存款时,其利息收入与利息支出之间的“利差”面临竞争压力;(2)协会的资产配置规则过于宽松;(3)联邦存款保险提供给那些可以随意设定利率以吸引存款的实体,同时允许骗子和傻瓜担任协会管理者而无人监管反对;(4)某些大区域发生普遍的地产灾难;(5)存款与贷款游说团体以及某些受最卑鄙的贷款和储蓄运营商影响的国会议员,持续不负责任地保护和强化不健全的体系。

新法案(缩写为 FIRREA)在国会愤怒的推动下迅速起草并颁布。(最近一个此类愤怒的例子,以令人瞩目的对比来说明,来自国会议员吉姆·利奇的话:“如果某些指控属实……查尔斯·基廷是一个规模惊人的金融病态者——美国商业界的吉姆·巴克牧师——他从一个由监管界的内维尔·张伯伦领导的银行委员会手中获得了行窃执照——那个啦啦队长几乎看不到邪恶,因此也几乎不说真话。”)

互助储蓄公司通过退出美国储蓄机构联盟,对这项严厉的立法行动做出了适度贡献——其辞职信尽管措辞含蓄批评,却引起了媒体的广泛关注。这封辞职信的副本附在本股东信函的末尾。互助储蓄公司希望负责任地行事,因此几乎支持了 FIRREA 所做的所有法律修订,尽管其中许多会损害互助储蓄的利润。

例如:

(1) 分阶段,到 1994 年 7 月 1 日,互助储蓄公司(及其服务公司子公司)必须处置:

(a) 高质量的公用事业优先股,享有约年均 10.8% 的优惠税率股息率,在 1989 年底的账面价值为 4140 万美元,当时市场价值高出约 870 万美元;

(b) 所罗门公司的高质量可转换优先股,享有 9% 年均的优惠税率股息率,账面价值为 2600 万美元,据信低于出售时可实现的金额。

(2) 分阶段,到同一日期,即 1994 年 7 月 1 日,互助储蓄公司在其监管净值的计算中,必须将其持有的 2,400,000 股 Freddie Mac 股票的价值逐步减记至零。

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation Mariot Free reddie Mac Year Ended 12/31: etum Earne _por Share Average Equity 1985 $2.98 $.53 $ 9.19 1986 3.72 30.0% 1.13 15.17 1987 4.53 28.5 1.10 12.12 1988 5.73 282 1.25 50.50 27.5 1989 6.57 1.60 67.12 25.0 revisions to the savings and loan laws. But it was clear that associations were shortly to be "re- When Wesco's annual report went to press last year. Congress was midcourse in considering regulated" into some mode less likely to cause a fresh torrent of deposit-insurance losses, borne by taxpayers. Provoking that legislative action was a previous torrent of losses which now seems likely to exceed $150 billion. These losses were caused by a combination of (1) competitive pressure on the "spread" between interest paid and interest received put on associations and banks when attract deposits, (2) loose asset deployment rules for associations, (3) admission and retention of federal deposit insurance is provided to entities free to pay any interest rates they wish in order to crooks and fools as managers of associations without regulatory objection, (4) general real estate unsoundness by the savings and loan lobby and certain members of Congress beholden to the most calamities in certain big regions, and (5) continuous irresponsible protection and enhancement of despicable savings and loan operators. The new laws, under the acronym FIRREA, were composed and enacted with a speed caused comparisons, is provided by the words of Congressman Jim Leach: "[If certain allegations are true] by congressional indignation. (A recent example of such indignation, employing remarkable commerce, given a license to steal by a bank board headed by the Neville Chamberlain of regulation Charles Keating is a financiopath of obscene proportions - the Reverend Jim Bakker of American

  • a cheerleader who saw little evil and thus spoke little truth.")

Mutual Savings modestly contributed to tough legislative action by resigning from the U.S. despite its understated criticism. A copy of this letter of resignation is appended at the end of this League of Savings Institutions, using a letter of resignation which drew widespread media attention letter to shareholders. FIRREA, even though many of them will hurt Mutual Savings' profits. Mutual Savings, desiring to act responsibly, supported virtually all the law revisions made by For example: (1) In stages, by July 1, 1994, Mutual Savings (and its service corporation subsidiary) must dispose of: (a) High-quality public utility preferred stocks, having tax-advantaged dividend rates 1989, and a market value then higher by about $8.7 million; and averaging about 10.8% per annum, with a carrying value of $41.4 million at yearend (b) High-quality convertible preferred stock of Salomon Inc, bearing a tax-advantaged below the amount which could be realized in the event of sale. dividend rate of 9% per annum, with a carrying value of $26 million, belleved to be (2) In stages, by the same date, July 1, 1994, Mutual Savings must write down to zero, in computing net worth for regulatory purposes, its 2,400.000 shares of Freddie Mac, which 57

[第 60 页]

[PAGE 60]

摘自西科金融公司 1989 年年报

截至 1989 年底,该项投资的账面价值为 7170 万美元,并且如上所述,当时的市场价值高于账面价值约 8940 万美元。

(3)所有新的资产配置,为符合互助储蓄公司的偏好和税务状况,基本被严格限定在(a)住房贷款(包括以抵押贷款支持证券形式的间接贷款)和(b)美国政府或其机构的债务工具。

(4)为在始于 1991 年 7 月 1 日的两年期间内达标,互助储蓄公司将需要把“合格储蓄贷款人”资产提高 10 个百分点至资产总额的 70%,使用的是一种新的、更有限的“合格储蓄贷款人”资产定义——令我们惊讶的是,该定义不包括房地美股票。如果新测试在 1989 年 12 月 31 日全面生效,互助储蓄公司本可以通过处置约 7400 万美元的非住房贷款资产(包括一些现金等价物),并将所得资金投入住房贷款(包括以短期抵押贷款支持证券形式的间接住房贷款)来达到合规要求。

(5)存款保险费已经上调。短期内,互助储蓄公司受到非经常性信用额度的保护。但到 1990 年代中期,新的保险费率将使互助储蓄公司的年盈利能力比维持原有费率水平降低约 20 万美元。原有的费率为存款的 0.083%,已实施多年,而新费率为 0.23%。更高的存款保险成本对净资产收益率的负面影响,在互助储蓄公司远小于几乎所有其他机构,后者遭受的损失更为严重。原因是互助储蓄公司的权益占比相对于存款要大得多。这是一项与某一比率相关的“一次性”优势;在每增加一美元储蓄的基础上,互助储蓄公司面临着与其他所有人相同的损害。

这些综合效应将降低互助储蓄公司的正常盈利能力。尽管经营保守,互助储蓄公司近年来一直以自己的方式勉力维持,取得了一定程度的成功,这在很大程度上归功于 FIRREA 法案之前可用的广泛资产配置选择。因此,无论考虑到公众需求后的新限制多么明智,FIRREA 都会对互助储蓄公司产生不利影响。不过,互助储蓄公司 1990 年和 1991 年的正常盈利能力很可能不会大幅下降。

我们预测正常盈利下降时间推迟的原因是:

(1)FIRREA 关于资产组合的影响是分阶段推进的,且受制于监管机构广泛的自由裁量权;

(2)我们预期监管机构会足够明智地行使自由裁量权,向那些拥有易变现资产的实力雄厚机构,也给予与那些资产难变现的弱势机构相同的宽容。

如果我们对监管机构的预测被证明是错误的,互助储蓄公司最明智的选择可能是退出储蓄和贷款业务,并免除支付存款保险费的义务。

如果互助储蓄公司(可能性较大)继续留在储蓄和贷款行业,它将保留一个比以往更为平庸的业务,短期内只有两个有趣的看头:

(1)在未来几年内,互助储蓄公司几乎肯定会在处置其通过 1966 年止赎获得的圣巴巴拉房产时,产生一笔非经常性的税前利润;

(2)如果(如预期那样)房地美支付越来越高的股息且股价也上涨,互助储蓄公司仍将保留从其房地美股票中获利的潜力。

58

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation had a carrying value of $71.7 million at yearend 1989, and, as reported above, a market value then higher by about $89.4 million. (3) All new asset commitments, fitting Mutual Savings' proclivities and tax position, are pretty well restricted to (a) housing loans (including indirect loans in the form of mortgage- backed securities) and (b) debt instruments of the U.S. Government or its agencies. (4) In stages, designed to create compliance during a two-year period commencing July 1, 1991, Mutual Savings will have to increase "qualified thrift lender" assets by 10 percentage thrift lender" assets which, to our surprise, does not include Freddie Mac stock. If the new points to a 70%-of-assets level, using a new and more limited definition of such "qualified test had been in full effect at December 31, 1989, Mutual Savings would have complied by disposing of about $74 million of non-home-loan assets (including some cash equivalents) and placing the proceeds in home loans (including indirect home loans in the form of short- term mortgage-backed securities). (5) Deposit-insurance premiums have been increased. Short term, Mutual Savings is protected by credits of a nonrecurring nature. But by the mid 1990s the new premium rates will reduce Mutual Savings' annual earning power by about $200,000 from the level which would have occurred if it were still paying at the 0.083%-of-deposits rate which was in insurance costs on percentage return on shareholders' equity is much lower at Mutual effect for years, instead of the new rate of 0.23%. The adverse effect of the higher deposit Savings than at almost all other associations, which suffer substantially. The cause of This is a "one-time" advantage related to one ratio; on an incremental dollar of savings Mutual Savings' advantage is its much larger percentage of equity, compared to deposits. Mutual Savings faces the same damage as everyone else. These combined effects will reduce Mutual Savings' normal earning power. While conservatively operated, Mutual Savings has been scrambling through recent years in its own way, obtaining a under pre-FIRREA law. Consequently, FIRREA will adversely affect Mutual Savings, however wise modest success made possible largely by the wide variety of asset-deployment options available the new restrictions, public needs considered. Nevertheless, it is probable that Mutual Savings' normal earning power will not be much reduced in 1990 and 1991. We predict this deferment of decline in normal earnings because: (1) FIRREA's asset-mix effects are phased in, subject to wide regulatory discretion; and (2) We anticipate that regulators will be wise enough to exercise their discretion to allow extra- to weak associations with hard-to-sell assets. strong associations, with easy-to-sell assets, the same forbearance which will be granted If we prove wrong in our prediction about regulators, Mutual Savings' wisest alternative will probably insurance premiums. be withdrawal from the savings and loan business and the related obligation to pay deposit- If, as seems likely, Mutual Savings stays in the savings and loan business, it will retain a business even more mediocre than before, with only two interesting near-term prospects: (1) During the next few years, Mutual Savings is almost certain to make a pre-tax profit of a foreclosure in 1966; and nonrecurring nature as it disposes of the Santa Barbara property it acquired through (2) Mutual Savings will retain prospects for gain from its Freddie Mac stock if, as anticipated, Freddie Mac pays ever-higher dividends and the price of the stock also rises. 58

[第 61 页]

[PAGE 61]

转载自西科金融公司 1989 年年报

长期而言,互助储蓄希望在储贷行业中找到某种有建设性、可持续的角色,一个不依赖前述任何一种预期短期前景的角色。在找到合适的长期角色之前,我们的政策就是“勉强苦撑”。从纳税人的角度来看,FIRREA 法案虽然极大改善了储贷体系,但采取的做法完全可以被形容为“只有大棒,没有胡萝卜”。这绝非让驴子快乐之道,但我们挨揍也是活该,因为我们在错误和恶行如此显而易见时,曾一直那样消极无为。此外,法案修订在增强安全性方面,在一个根本点上存在不足,这使利润空间受到挤压:银行和协会在很大程度上仍可自由地以任意利率吸收由政府提供保险的存款,同时又必须将最终的同类商品——资金使用权——重新投向一个残酷竞争的市场。由此带来的利差挤压,叠加协会自身的正常竞争劣势,使得一家经营得不错的普通协会,其未来前景亦不应让其所有者感到振奋。

普通协会相对于普通银行的正常竞争劣势,现在包括:存款保险成本更高、新监管规则更加令人困惑,以及在多种重要的盈利活动中缺乏经验和积淀。因此,即便是经营得极为出色的传统协会,比如 H. F. 阿曼森公司所拥有的那一家,其股票在股市上的市净率也远低于一家经营极其出色的银行。而一家普通的储贷分支机构,如今对一家经验丰富的银行所提供的增量价值,可能并大于对其现有所有者提供的价值。

此外,普通协会如今不再仅仅与银行竞争。同样在吸收“存款”的,还有货币市场基金,它们:

(1) 不缴纳存款保险费,相较协会每年节省相当于存款额 0.23% 的费用;

(2) 完全不需要能从利润中获益的所有者(基金术语中称“管理公司”)投入任何资本,而协会的资本金要求反而提高了;

(3) 接受的监管(来自人手不足的 SEC)成本低于协会;

(4) 不运营昂贵的分支网点,但它们借助快速、低成本的系统提供支票签发功能和接受频繁存款,这套系统在许多方面比普通协会的系统更能适应新格局;

(5) 由于上述全部优势,其年度总成本(扣除所有者利润前)占资产的比例,比最高效的协会的成本还要低 50% 以上。

因此,非住房抵押贷款、吸收存款这一近乎“闭眼就能做的”自然利基市场,现在已经被一些规模极大、效率极高的贷款发起机构,如 Home Savings,所占据。但正如我们仿佛每年都在说的,我们尚未为互助储蓄找到一个称得上“有吸引力”,而非仅仅“能忍受”的永久性放贷利基市场。在抵押贷款业务中,我们由此不断印证着塞缪尔·约翰逊的论断:“人生是一种须忍受甚多、享受甚少的状态。”

对作为存款保险人的联邦政府而言,结构性风险犹存。在修订后的储贷体系中,依然留有一个重要(尽管已显著缩小)的诱惑残余,诱使机构行事不审慎。这种诱惑是对利润压力的回应,而利润压力乃是该体系结构的自然结果,正是这种诱惑在 1980 年代惹出了麻烦。

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation Long term, Mutual Savings hopes to find within the savings and loan business some constructive, continuing role which is not dependent on either of the foregoing anticipated near-term prospects. Until the right long-term role is found, our policy is simply to "stagger through." taxpayers' point of view, took an approach which can fairly be described as "all stick and no carrot." The FIRREA law revision, while greatly improving the savings and loan system from the This is no way to create felicity for the donkey, but we deserve our share of the beating because we were previously so passive in the presence of obvious error and evil. Moreover, the safety- under pressure: banks and associations remain free, within wide limits, to attract government- enhancing features of the law revision fell short in one fundamental respect which leaves profits insured deposits at any interest rate they wish, while they must resell the ultimate fungible rate "spread" safely attainable, combined with normal competitive disadvantages of associations, commodity, the use of money, into a brutally competitive market. The resulting squeeze on interest- leaves the average well-run association with a likely future which should not excite its owners. bank, now include the following: higher deposit-insurance costs, more confusing new regulation, The normal competitive disadvantages of the average association, compared with the average and less experience and momentum in various important remunerative activities. As a result, even a stock market at a much lower price-to-book-value ratio than a superbly run bank. And the average superbly run conventional association, like the one owned by H. F. Ahmanson & Co., sells in the savings and loan branch office probably now offers more incremental value to an experienced bank than it provides to its present owner. "deposits" are the money-market funds which: Moreover, the average association does not now compete only with banks. Also gathering (1) pay no deposit-insurance premiums, saving 0.23% of deposits each year, compared to associations; (2) are required to employ exactly no capital from profit-earning proprietors ("management raised; companies" in fund parlance), while capital requirements for associations have been (3) have lower-cost regulation (from an understaffed SEC) than associations; (4) maintain no expensive branch offices, although they provide check-writing privileges and ways to the new order than the systems of the average association; and, accept frequent deposits, using fast, low-cost systems which are better adapted in many (5) as a result of all the foregoing advantages, have total annual costs (before proprietors' profits), as a percentage of assets, which are more than 50% lower than annual costs of the most efficient association. Thus, the natural "almost-no-brainer," non-home-mortgage, deposit-gathering niche is now some large, extremely efficient loan originators like Home Savings, but, as we seem to say each introduced into Australia. The adjustable-home-mortgage niche may now provide a decent home for year, we have not yet found for Mutual Savings a permanent lending niche which is attractive, as son's observation that: "'Life is a state in which much is to be endured and little to be enjoyed." distinguished from bearable. In the mortgage business we thus constantly confirm Samuel John- Structural risk for the federal government as deposit insurer. Associations retain a considerable Left in place in the revised savings and loan system is a significant (although much reduced) residue of temptation to act imprudently. The temptation, in response to the profit-pressure which is a natural consequence of the structure of the system, is the same one which caused troubles in the 59

[第 62 页]

[PAGE 62]

转载自西科金融公司 1989 年年报

因(1)贷款和存款期限错配,或(2)在那些愿意承诺高利率的更冒风险的借款人身上,因违约而承受不当风险,这种诱惑过去存在,现在依然存在:通过那些赌徒般的借款人寻求可接受的利率“利差”,除此之外别无他法。资产配置控制措施要严格到让一家银行或信贷协会在承担风险的同时还能暂时保持良好形象(并显得有理由为管理层支付更高薪酬)几乎是不可能的——这些风险最终会侵蚀其所有者权益,并导致存款保险损失。“全用大棒”的控制方法比完全没有要好得多,但当它成为防止存款保险机构承担损失的唯一方法时,就远非理想之选。相比之下,很久以前,联邦存款保险机构的损失很低,储贷系统既有胡萝卜也有大棒,因此普通储贷经营者无需非凡的运气或能力也能经营得不错。(胡萝卜包括极低的所得税率,以及利率管制——这降低了持有存款的成本,同时在吸引存款方面比银行更具优势。)我们认为,目前修订后的系统继续让纳税人承担了超出其应承担范围的风险,高昂的存款保险成本既补偿了这种风险,也加剧了它。

如今,住房获得的来自储贷协会的援助比以前少了。一个体现住房援助减少的例子是,FIRREA 出台了新限制,禁止向任何一家房屋建筑商提供超过所有者权益 15% 的贷款,但对于资本充足且记录良好的信贷协会,允许最高 30% 的例外。新规定要求,信贷协会的单一客户贷款不能超过所有者权益的 15%(对于资本充足、记录良好的协会,例外上限为 30%)。这项新规定会严重削弱互助储蓄在其早期集中资源用于开发贷款、仅信赖少数几家房屋建筑商时所创造的利润和住房贡献。而且,这项新规定如今产生了同样的总体效应。它将显著限制全国许多地区住房建设贷款的可得性。这个结果证明了,在不产生不良“副产物”效应的情况下修改一个复杂体系是不可能的。生态学第一定律和立法第一定律是同一个:“你永远不可能只做一件事。”

当然,法律修订的“副产物”有时会帮助(而非损害)市场中的某些参与者。FIRREA 规定的新的“基于风险”的资本要求就有这种效果,它们为信贷协会提供了新动力,促使它们将本可赚得的资金转移到房地美(Freddie Mac),通过用抵押贷款换取信用增强的抵押贷款支持证券来实现。(尽管这些证券随后带来的收入减少,但它们有助于满足监管资本要求,因为持有这些证券所需的所有者权益更少。)这种收入转移效应应该会通过互助储蓄在房地美的大量持股头寸而对它有所帮助。

精密钢铁公司

位于伊利诺伊州芝加哥郊区富兰克林公园的精密钢铁公司,在 1989 年为正常的净经营利润贡献了 276.9 万美元,比 1988 年的 316.7 万美元下降了 13%。1989 年利润下降的原因是产品销售量减少了 12%。收入下降幅度较小,为 5%,降至 5944 万美元。

在戴维·希尔斯特罗姆的娴熟领导下,精密钢铁的各项业务在 1989 年继续取得了出色的资源回报率。

我们从不厌其烦地说,出色的财务业绩背后有其根本原因,尽管这个原因并非强到足以在缺乏卓越管理的情况下也能取得这样的成果。精密钢铁的业务,尽管名称平淡无奇,但在质量等级上已从单纯的商品型业务向前迈进了好几步。精密钢铁的许多客户,需要依靠它短期通知供货,获得特定等级的高质量冷轧带钢,价格合理、切割精度高、技术上乘,并且在供应短缺时能被记住——他们有理由相信,在精密钢铁的市场区域内,没有其他完全可比的替代选择。事实上,许多客户

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation bearing undue risk from either (1) mismatched maturities of loans and deposits or (2) losses past: the temptation to seek an acceptable interest rate "spread," not available any other way, by through defaults of a gamier class of borrowers willing to promise extra-high interest rates. It is almost impossible to have asset deployment controls so tough that a bank or association can't look good for a while (and give the appearance of justifying higher compensation of management) as it takes risks which will in due course destroy its owners' equity and also cause deposit insurance losses. The "all stick" method of control is much better than nothing, but it is far from ideal when it is ago, the federal deposit insurer had low losses, the savings and loan system used both carrots and the exclusive method for prevention of losses borne by the deposit insurer. In contrast, when, lona stick, so that the average savings and loan operator could do well without exceptional luck or ability. (The carrots were very low income taxation plus interest-rate controls which reduced cost of holding deposits while giving an advantage over banks in attracting deposits.) We think the present, revised system continues to impose more risk than taxpayers should bear, with high deposit- insurance costs contributing to the risk as well as compensating for it. Housing is now less assisted than before by the existence of savings and loan associations. An example of the drift away from housing assistance is provided by FIRREA's new restriction more than 15% of owners' equity to one customer, with exceptions permitted up to 30% for preventing large loans to any one house builder. The new requirement is that an association loan no reduced the profits and housing contributions of Mutual Savings in its early days when it concen- adequately capitalized associations with good records. The new requirement would have greatly trated resources in development loans while trusting only a few house-builders. And the new requirement now has the same general effect. It will significantly restrict availability of house- complex system without undesired "by-product" effects. The first law of ecology and the first law of building loans in many regions of the country. This result demonstrates the impossibility of revising a legislation are one and the same: "You can never do merely one thing." a market. New "risk-based" capital requirements under FIRREA have such an effect, as they give Of course, a "by-product" of law revision sometimes helps, instead of hurts, some participant in associations new incentives to transfer monies they otherwise would have earned to Freddie Mac, through exchange of mortgages for credit-enhanced, mortgage-backed securities. (Although the securities then provide less income, they help satisfy regulatory capital requirements, because the securities require less owners' equity to hold.) This income-transfer effect should help Mutual Savings, through its large shareholding position in Freddie Mac. Precision Steel Franklin Park, Illinois, contributed $2,769,000 to normal net operating income in 1989, down 13% The businesses of Wesco's Precision Steel subsidiary, located in the outskirts of Chicago at compared with $3,167,000 in 1988. The decrease in 1989 profit occurred as pounds of product sold declined by 12%. Revenues were down less, by 5% to $59,440,000. under the skilled leadership of David Hillstrom, Precision Steel's businesses in 1989 continued to provide an extraordinary return on resources employed. one strong enough to cause the results achieved in the absence of superb management. Precision As we never tire of saying, the good financial results have an underlying reason, although not Steel's businesses, despite their mundane nomenclature, are stens advanced on the quality scale from mere commodity-type businesses. Many customers of Precision Steel. needina dependable prices, technical excellence in cutting to order, and remembrance when supplies are short, rightly supply on short notice of specialized grades of high-quality, cold-rolled strip steel, reasonable believe that they have no fully comparable alternative in Precision Steel's market area. Indeed. many 60

[第 63 页]

[PAGE 63]

摘自西科金融公司 1989 年年报

服务。

芝加哥以外(比如洛杉矶)的客户也找上精密钢铁公司,年复一年,在戴维·希尔斯特罗姆的领导下,它日复一日地践行着以最高质量服务为核心的古老教条,这种重复性的卓越表现令人难忘。我们希望与他长期合作。

西科金融保险公司

1985 年,西科集团新增了一项业务,是与西科 80% 控股权的母公司及最终控股公司伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司合资开展的。

在包括持有大量西科股份的彼得斯和卡斯珀家族成员在内的所有西科董事的热切支持下——没有他们的批准,这项行动无法实施——西科于 1985 年在一家新成立的、全资拥有的保险公司,即西科金融保险公司(“Wes-FIC”)中,以现金等价物形式投资了 4500 万美元。随后在 1986、1987 和 1989 年又追加投资了 5800 万美元。

这家新的子公司 Wes-FIC,通过另一家伯克希尔·哈撒韦保险公司子公司作为不盈利的中介,分保了历史悠久的总基金保险集团全部保险业务的 2%。由此,Wes-FIC 承担了总基金保险集团在截至 1989 年 8 月 31 日的四年期间内,根据一份涵盖其赚取的所有保险费的合同所产生的定价、成本和损失的所有收益和负担。这项安排使 Wes-FIC 几乎处于与它(而非总基金保险集团)直接承保了 2% 业务时完全相同的位置。差异仅出现在保险的投资端,因为 Wes-FIC(而非总基金保险集团)投资了由“浮存金”产生的资金。在合同终止前,Wes-FIC 在 1989 年分得的已赚保费超过了 3700 万美元。

合同终止后,Wes-FIC 向总基金保险集团返还了 1560 万美元的未到期保费(扣除相关再保险佣金),并保留了约 9100 万美元的资产,用于冲抵未来许多年内将缓慢耗尽的赔偿准备金。我们认为,考虑到所有未来的索赔支付,西科参与总基金保险集团再保险合同的这四年整体前景极佳。西科的最终母公司(持有 80% 股份)让西科参与其中,几乎肯定是帮了西科一个忙——正如当初计划的那样。

多年前为总基金保险集团合同选定终止日期时,是有些好运气的。该日期是 1989 年 8 月 31 日,恰逢飓风雨果和旧金山地震发生之前。这个结果带有某种天意的公正,因为在 1985 年合同生效后的数小时内,Wes-FIC 就分担了一部分飓风损失。

Wes-FIC 从 1988 年开始直接承保业务(区别于再保险)。它现在已在内布拉斯加州、犹他州和爱荷华州获得许可,但直接承保保费只有 18.3 万美元,几乎全部是阿拉巴马州的剩余业务线(允许非认可保险公司经营)。已赚直接保费为 43.8 万美元。

Wes-FIC 1989 年的“正常”净收入为 1427.6 万美元,而 1988 年为 1209.4 万美元。“正常”收入数字中剔除了 1989 年的证券收益(扣除所得税后)591 万美元,而 1988 年则为 607.1 万美元(其中包括出售 Wes-FIC 持有的鲍厄里储蓄银行 9% 股权所实现的 483.6 万美元收益)。这些项目在下方作为“证券销售净收益”列报。Wes-FIC 在 1989 年的净收入由于《税收改革法案》对所得税准备金进行了一项非常调整而获益约 21.5 万美元,相比之下,1988 年获益约 26 万美元。

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation service. customers at locations remote from Chicago (for instance, Los Angeles) seek out Precision Steel's after year, under David Hillstrom's leadership is boring, repetitive excellence as he remembers a It is not common that steel warehouses have results like Precision Steel's. What we see, year long time. basic catechism emphasizing service of the highest quality. We hope to be associated with him for a Wesco-Financial Insurance Company and ultimate parent corporation, Berkshire Hathaway Inc. A new business was added to the Wesco group in 1985, in co-venture with Wesco's 80% owner ers in the Peters and Caspers families, without whose approval such action would not have been With the enthusiastic approval of all Wesco's directors, including substantial Wesco sharehold- insurance company, Wesco-Financial Insurance Company ("Wes-FIC"'). Another $58 million was taken, Wesco in 1985 invested $45 million in cash equivalents in a newly organized, wholly owned invested in 1986, 1987 and 1989. company subsidiary as intermediary-without-profit, 2% of the entire book of insurance business of The new subsidiary, Wes-FIC, reinsured, through another Berkshire Hathaway insurance the long-established Fireman's Fund Group. Wes-FIC thereby assumed the benefits and burdens of by Fireman's Fund during a four-year period ending August 31, 1989. The arrangement put Wes-FIC Fireman's Fund's prices, costs and losses under a contract covering all insurance premiums earned written 2% of the business. Differences in results occurred only from the investment side of in almost exactly the position it would have been in if it, instead of Fireman's Fund, had directly FIC's share of premiums earned in 1989, before contract termination, exceeded $37 million. insurance, as Wes-FIC, instead of Fireman's Fund, invested funds from "float" generated. Wes- premiums, net of related ceding commissions, and retained assets of about $91 million offset by Upon contract termination, Wes-FIC returned to Fireman's Fund $15.6 million in unearned Wesco's four-year participation in the Fireman's Fund reinsurance contract as having excellent claims reserves which will be exhausted slowly over many future years. We regard the totality of prospects, all future claim payments considered. Wesco's ultimate parent corporation (and 80% time. owner) almost certainly did Wesco a favor in allowing Wesco's participation, as was planned at the Fund contract. The date, August 31, 1989, happened to be just before occurrence of both Hurricane There was some good luck in the selection, years ago, of a termination date for the Fireman's Hugo and the San Francisco earthquake. There was some heavenly justice in this outcome, because Wes-FIC caught a share of hurricane losses within hours after the inception of the contract in 1985. licensed in Nebraska, Utah and lowa, but it wrote only $183,000 in direct premiums, almost all Wes-FIC in 1988 began to write direct business, as distinguished from reinsurance. It is now were $438,000. surplus lines coverage (permitted for non-admitted insurers) in Alabama. Earned direct premiums net "normal" income figures excluded securities gains, net of income taxes, of $5,910,000 in 1989, Wes-FIC's "normal" net income for 1989 was $14,276,000, versus $12,094,000 for 1988. The Bowery Savings Bank) in 1988. These items are reported as "Net Gains on Sales of Securities," compared with $6,071,000 (including $4,836,000 realized on sale of Wes-FIC's 9% equity interest in because of an unusual adjustment to its income tax provision caused by the Tax Reform Act of below. Wes-FIC's net income benefitted by about $215,000 in 1989, versus $260,000 in 1988, 61

[第 64 页]

[PAGE 64]

摘自西科金融公司 1989 年年报

即便是最优秀的意外伤害保险业务,其本质上也决定了,在核算上,财务报表比非保险类公司的账目更接近“有根据的猜测”,因为保险公司必须对已赚保费中蕴含的所有未来成本和损失进行估算和扣除。而再保险业务,由于在损失报告链条中多了一个或多个环节,通常比非再保险业务带来更多会计上的不确定性。西科股东应当始终意识到,西科金融的会计核算存在固有的不完善之处,其基础是对未来许多年结果的预测。

西科金融目前的情况是资本充裕但优质保险业务短缺。我们目前很少看到稳健扩张的机会,但我们预计,随着其他保险公司无力或不愿支付合理赔款的情况引发恐慌,西科金融的保险业务规模终将得到扩大。自 1990 年 1 月 1 日起,西科金融开始为伯克希尔·哈撒韦的全资子公司赛普拉斯保险公司(主要承保工伤保险)的保单提供 50% 的再保险。预计西科金融 1990 年分得的保费收入约为 800 万美元。我们认为这笔再保险合同对西科来说值得持有,但就每美元保费而言,其前景远不如与总基金保险集团的那笔合同。

所有其他“正常”经营利润

所有其他“正常”经营利润,扣除利息支出和一般公司费用后,从 1988 年的 360.9 万美元下降至 1989 年的 317.8 万美元。其来源包括:(1) 西科帕萨迪纳办公楼(主要出租给外部租户,尽管互助储蓄银行是一楼租户)的租金(总租金为 251.8 万美元,不含互助储蓄银行支付的租金);(2) 来自储蓄和贷款子公司及保险子公司以外持有的现金等价物和有价证券的利息和股息;以及 (3) 新美洲电气公司的收益。1989 年这部分“其他”收益的下降,主要是由于将相关资产及其收益转移至西科的保险子公司以增强其资本基础所致。

出售证券的净收益

西科出售证券的累计税后净收益从 1988 年的 652.5 万美元下降至 1989 年的 592 万美元。如上所述,1989 年这些收益中有 591 万美元是在西科金融保险子公司实现的,而 1988 年实现的是 607.1 万美元。

所罗门公司可转换优先股

1987 年 10 月 1 日,西科及其某些全资子公司以 1 亿美元的成本,购买了所罗门公司(“所罗门”)新发行的 10 万股 A 系列累积可转换优先股(无面值)。所罗门的主要业务由其子公司所罗门兄弟公司(一家领先的证券公司)经营。我们的投资是伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司(西科的母公司)其他子公司投资 6 亿美元的总额 7 亿美元交易的一部分。交易的主要条款包括:(1) 优先股按年利率 9% 支付股息;(2) 每股优先股购买成本为 1000 美元,自 1990 年 10 月 31 日起,或发生某些特殊事件更早时,可转换为 26.31579 股所罗门普通股;(3) 该优先股受强制性赎回条款约束,要求自 1995 年起,每年 10 月 31 日,按每股 1000 美元加累计股息的价格,赎回发行在外优先股的 20%,直至所有优先股被赎回完毕。

按优先股的规定转换价格计算,只要在 1990 年 10 月 31 日之后,所罗门普通股(在纽约证券交易所上市)的交易价格超过每股 38 美元,就能实现利润(需遵守某些程序性要求)。在我们购买时,

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation It is in the nature of even the finest casualtv insurance businesses that in keepina their accounte uncertainties inherent in this undertakino make financial statements more mere *hect honest they must estimate and deduct all future costs and losses from premiums already earned reinsurance portion of the casualty insurance business, because it contains one or more extra links guesses" than is typically the case with accounts of non-insurance-writing corporations. And the in the loss-reporting chain, usually creates more accounting uncertainty than the non-reinsurance portion. Wesco shareholders should remain aware of the inherent imperfections of Wes-FIC's accounting, based as it is on forecasts of outcomes in many future years. Wes-FIC retains a "longage" of capital and a shortage of good insurance business. We see few present opportunities for sound expansion, but we expect more insurance writing in due course, made possible by fear that other insurers will become unable or unwilling to pay fair claims. Effective January 1, 1990, Wes-FIC has begun to reinsure 50% of the book of insurance business (largely workers' compensation insurance) of Cypress Insurance Company, a wholly owned subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway. Wes-FIC's share of premiums written is expected to is not nearly as promising, per dollar of insurance written, as was the Fireman's Fund contract. approximate $8 million in 1990. We regard this reinsurance contract as worth having at Wesco, but it All Other "Normal" Net Operating Income All other "normal" net operating income, net of interest paid and general corporate expenses, decreased to $3,178,000 in 1989 from $3,609,000 in 1988. Sources were (1) rents ($2,518,000 nantly leased to outsiders although Mutual Savings is the ground floor tenant), (2) interest and gross, excluding rent from Mutual Savings) from Wesco's Pasadena office building block (predomi- dividends from cash equivalents and marketable securities held outside the savings and loan and insurance subsidiaries, and (3) earnings of New America Electrical Corporation. The decrease in this "all other" component of earnings in 1989 resulted primarily from transfer of assets, with their related incomes, to Wesco's insurance subsidiary to augment its capital position. Net Gains On Sales Of Securities Wesco's aggregate net gains on sales of securities, combined, after income taxes, decreased to $5,920,000 in 1989 from $6,525,000 in 1988. As noted above, $5,910,000 of these gains were realized in the Wes-FIC insurance subsidiary in 1989, versus $6,071,000 realized in 1988. Convertible Preferred Stock of Salomon Inc newly issued shares of Series A Cumulative Convertible Preferred Stock, without par value, of On October 1, 1987 Wesco and certain of its wholly owned subsidiaries purchased 100,000 its subsidiary, Salomon Brothers, a leading securities firm. Our investment was part of a $700 million Salomon Inc ("Salomon"'), at a cost of $100 million. Salomon's primary business is transacted by transaction in which other subsidiaries of Berkshire Hathawav Inc.. Wesco's parent, invested $600 dividends at the annual rate of 9%; (2) each preferred share, purchased at a cost of $1,000, will be million. Principal terms of the transaction included the following: (1) the preferred stock pays convertible into 26.31579 shares of Salomon common stock on or after October 31, 1990, or earier if certain extraordinary events occur; and (3) the preferred stock is subject to mandatory redemption provisions requirina the retirement, at $1,000 ner share plus accrued dividends. of 20% outstanding. of the issue on each October 31, beginning in 1995, so long as any shares of preferred stock remain requirements) will be realizable whenever, after October 31. 1990, the common stock of Salomon At the stated conversion price of the preferred stock, a profit (subiect to certain procedural (listed on the New York Stock Exchange) trades at over $38 per share. At the time of our 62

[第 65 页]

[PAGE 65]

摘自西科金融 1989 年年报

不过,西科刚拿到新的股票凭证,1987 年 10 月 19 日“黑色星期一”股灾就爆发了,这给所罗门带来了暂时但重大的经营亏损,信用评级也被下调。虽然所罗门在证券公司中只是承受了整体灾难中大致相称的一份,但其普通股在股灾后一度跌至 20 美元左右。到 1988 年底,所罗门对业务进行了大量建设性调整以适应新环境,其普通股价格为 24 美元;1989 年底,所罗门普通股价格为 23 美元左右。1988 年复苏期间,所罗门作为优先股股息和股票赎回潜在来源的信用状况有所改善,当时市场上可得的优先股股息率大致稳定。1989 年,与多数其他证券公司相比,所罗门表现突出。由于西科所持优先股的合同期限缩短、转换权价值在过去两年上升,我们认为西科这项投资的公允市值略高于成本;截至 1989 年 12 月 31 日,这一超额对西科整体而言并不重大。沃伦·巴菲特先生(伯克希尔·哈撒韦董事长)和我本人于 1987 年 10 月 28 日加入所罗门董事会,我们对这段关系感到非常满意。

其他可转换优先股

在一系列与所罗门投资类似的交易中,西科及其子公司于 1989 年共投入 7500 万美元,购买数只新发行的可转换优先股。这些发行方的普通股均在纽约证券交易所上市。这些交易如下:

(1) 吉列公司。1989 年 7 月 20 日,西科旗下 Wes-FIC 子公司投资 4000 万美元,购买吉列公司新发行的可转换优先股。该股票提供 8.75% 的年股息,吉列必须在 10 年内赎回,并可按每股 50 美元转换为吉列普通股。沃伦·巴菲特(西科母公司的董事长)加入了吉列董事会。吉列刚刚推出新产品 Sensor 剃须刀,因显著改善湿刮过程而应会热销。

(2) 全美航空集团。1989 年 8 月 7 日,Wes-FIC 投资 1200 万美元,购买全美航空集团新发行的可转换优先股。该股票提供 9.25% 的年股息,全美航空必须在 10 年内赎回,并可按每股 60 美元转换为全美航空普通股。

(3) 冠军国际公司。1989 年 12 月 6 日,西科及其某些子公司投资 2300 万美元,购买冠军国际公司新发行的可转换优先股。该股票提供 9.25% 的年股息,冠军必须在 10 年内赎回,并可按每股 38 美元转换为冠军普通股。

虽然我们钦佩这些公司及其管理层,但我们认为这些投资整体上是稳健而非令人兴奋的。过去,很少有投资者通过投资优秀公司的可转换优先股获得巨大成功。考虑到其他可选投资机会,我们对买入这些股票感到满意,但西科股东不应期待意外之财。

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation However, shortly after Wesco acquired its new stock certificates, the October 19, 1987 "Black commitment to buy the new preferred, the common stock of Salomon was selling in the low 30s. Monday" stock market crash occurred, which caused temporary but substantial operating losses rough share of the general debacle, its common stock at one time after the crash traded as low as plus a lowered credit rating at Salomon. Although Salomon, among securities firms, suffered only its end of 1988, after much constructive adjustment of Salomon's business to new conditions. At the end of 1989 Salomon common stock was trading at $23%, compared with $24 at the Salomon's credit as a potential source of preferred dividends and stock redemptions improved during its 1988 recovery, when generally available dividend rates on preferred stock were roughly stable. And during 1989 Salomon was a star performer, compared to most other securities firms. enhanced in value during the last two years, we believe that the fair market value of Wesco's With Wesco's preferred stock now shorter in contractual duration, and its conversion privilege investment was somewhat in excess of its cost, and that the aggregate amount of any such excess was not material to Wesco, at December 31, 1989. Salomon on October 28, 1987, and are very pleased with the association. Berkshire Hathaway's Chairman, Warren Buffett, and the undersigned joined the board of Other Convertible Preferred Stocks In transactions similar to that which created our Salomon investment, Wesco and its subsidiar- ies during 1989 invested a total of $75 million in several new issues of convertible preferred stock. The common stock of all issuers is listed on the New York Stock Exchange. These transactions are briefly summarized below: (1) The Gillette Company On July 20, 1989, Wesco's Wes-FIC subsidiary invested $40 million in newly issued shares of convertible preferred stock of The Gillette Company ("Gillette"). The stock provides an 84% common stock at $50 per share. Warren Buffett, Chairman of Wesco's parent company, has annual dividend, must be redeemed by Gillette in 10 years, and is convertible into Gillette joined Gillette's board of directors. Gillette has just introduced a new product, the Sensor razor, which will sell well because it provides significant improvements to the wet-shaving process. (2) USAir Group, Inc. stock of USAir Group, Inc. ("USAir"). The stock provides an annual 94% dividend, must be On August 7, 1989, Wes-FIC invested $12 million in the newly issued convertible preferred redeemed by USAir in 10 years, and is convertible into USAir common stock at 560 per share. (3) Champion International Corporation of convertible preferred stock of Champion International Corporation (Champion"). The On December 6, 1989, Wesco and certain of its subsidiaries invested $23 million in a new issue stock provides an annual 9/4% dividend, must be redeemed by Champion in 10 years, and is convertible into Champion common stock at $38 per share. aggregate as sound but not exciting. Few, if any, investors have ever prospered mightily from While we admire the corporations and managements involved, we regard these investments in the investing in convertible preferred stocks of leading corporations. Considering alternatives available When the investments were made, we were pleased to buy the stocks, but Wesco shareholders should expect no bonanza. 63

[第 66 页]

[PAGE 66]

摘自西科金融 1989 年年报

1988 年底,西科收购了新美洲电气公司 80% 的股权,收购价为 820 万美元。其中,716.5 万美元以现金支付给新美洲基金原股东的清算信托,另有 103.5 万美元为一张 10 年期、利率 10% 的应付票据,票据持有人是新美洲电气首席执行官格伦·米切尔,他保留了西科未收购的那 20% 新美洲电气股权。这次收购的模式在伯克希尔·哈撒韦集团内部很常见:我们愿意持有许多企业 80% 的股权,但前提是我们欣赏并信任那些保留其余 20% 股权、并预计将继续经营企业的人,而我们对他们的经营既不加干预,也不提供什么帮助。对于那些我们不欣赏、不信任的人管理的企业,哪怕只持有 80% 股权,我们也不愿涉足。

格伦·米切尔是签署人(西科首席执行官)的多年老友,也是一位备受信任和钦佩的商业伙伴。事实上,由于西科首席执行官及其家族持有的新美洲电气股权比例高于西科,整个交易得到了西科董事会的批准,并由伯克希尔·哈撒韦(西科的母公司)首席执行官及大股东沃伦·巴菲特推荐并参与。巴菲特先生在新美洲电气并无经济利益,他和芒格先生、米切尔先生都认为,1025 万美元是对新美洲电气 100% 股权在 1988 年底的公允估值。

西科之所以能获得这次收购机会,是因为格伦·米切尔更愿意成为伯克希尔·哈撒韦集团子公司的少数股东(20%),而不是选择另一个方案——在新美洲电气的其他股权通过新股公开发行广泛分散后,持有 30% 的控股地位。我们喜欢激发这样的信任,并始终努力做到配得上这份信任。

新美洲电气是一家生产各种电气产品的制造商,产品包括开关设备、断路器、照明镇流器和启动器,以及用于码头和房车停车场的电气设备。其工厂位于加利福尼亚州奥兰治县。

西科收购其 80% 权益时,新美洲电气的账面净资产约为 640 万美元,其中包括约 250 万美元的现金及现金等价物,并且有着长期获得高资本回报率的历史,但当前盈利受到全行业价格战的影响而下降。

不幸的是,新美洲电气在被收购后的第一年,财务业绩令我们感到难堪。1989 年,新美洲电气税后仅盈利 16.8 万美元(在根据合并会计惯例就收购股票进行调整之前),这(1)仅占股东权益历史账面价值的 2.6%,(2)仅相当于西科收购价的 1.6%。经过合并会计调整后,新美洲电气对西科 1989 年盈利的总贡献甚至更低:仅为 5.9 万美元(包含在我们的“所有其他正常营业净收入”类别中)。

新美洲电气盈利同比下降幅度高达 77%。盈利下降的部分原因是,在租用的一栋大型新楼中合并此前分散的运营,产生了高昂的费用。其他因素包括:(1)价格战升级,同时销售额同比下降 2.5%;(2)一项荒谬且不公正的诉讼结果;(3)至少一个事后看来像是失误的决策。

新美洲电气 1989 年的麻烦仅限于利润表。其资产负债表依然强劲。例如,在 1989 年底,尽管进行了设施的重大改进和新设备的采购,手头持有的现金及现金等价物仍与年初相同:250 万美元。

我们认为 1989 年的盈利下滑是暂时的。我们相信格伦·米切尔正以他一贯的娴熟技巧和勤奋精神应对这些问题。新大楼和新设备给我们留下了深刻印象,两者都将降低成本并提高产品和服务质量。我们期待看到 1990 年新美洲电气的情况。

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation New America Electrical Corporation ("'New America Electric"') for a price of $8,200,000. Of this price $7,165,000 was cash paid to a At the close of 1988, Wesco acquired 80% of the stock of New America Electrical Corporation liquidating trust for the former shareholders of New America Fund and $1,035,000 was a ten-year, America Electric not acquired by Wesco. The pattern of this acquisition is a common one within the 10% note payable to Glen Mitchel, CEO of New America Electric, who retains the 20% of New Berkshire Hathaway group, where we are willing to be an 80% owner in many a business we would not be in if we did continue to operate the business, with little help and no hindrance from us. not admire and trust people who retain the other 20% and are expected to Glen Mitchel is a long-time friend and trusted and admired business associate of the under- signed, Wesco's CEO. Indeed, because Wesco's CEO and his family owned a higher percentage of New America Electric than Wesco, our whole transaction was approved by the Wesco board with the recommendation and participation of Warren Buffett, CEO and major shareholder of Berkshire Hathaway, Wesco's parent company. Mr. Buffett had no financial interest in New America Electric, of New America Electric at yearend 1988. and he, plus Messrs. Munger and Mitchel, all believed that $10,250,000 was a fair valuation for 100% This acquisition became available to Wesco because Glen Mitchel preferred minority (20%) America Electric, with all other New America Electric stock pretty well scattered through a new ownership of a Berkshire Hathaway group subsidiary instead of dominant 30% ownership in New public offering, which was the alternative offered. We like causing such confidence and try always to deserve it. New America Electric is a manufacturer of various electrical products including switchgear, and recreational vehicle parks. Its facilities are in Orange County, California. circuit breakers, lighting ballasts and starters and electrical equipment for marinas and mobile home When Wesco purchased its 80% interest, New America Electric had a book net worth of about $6,400,000, including approximately $2,500,000 in cash and equivalents, and a long history of earning high returns on capital, but with current earnings reduced by an industry-wide price war. Unfortunately, financial results in New America Electric's first year after acquisition are an embarrassment to us. In 1989, New America Electric earned only $168,000, after taxes (before adjustments under consolidated accounting convention incident to our purchase of stock), which is (1) only 2.6% on historical book value of shareholders' equity, and (2) only 1.6% on the price Wesco paid. After consolidated accounting adjustments, the total contribution of New America breakdown in the "all other normal net operating income" category). Electric to Wesco's 1989 earnings was even lower: only $59,000 (included in our earnings The year-to-year earnings decline at New America Electric was a stunning 77%. Part of the earnings decline was caused by high expense incurred in consolidating previously scattered operations in a large, newly leased building. Other factors were (1) escalation of the price war (3) at least one decision which, with hindsight, looks like an error. accompanied by a 2.5% year-to-year decline in sales, (2) a ridiculous, unfair result in a lawsuit, and New America Electric's 1989 troubles were limited to the income statement. Its balance sheet remained strong. For instance, at yearend 1989, despite major improvements of facilities and of the year: $2.5 million. purchase of new equipment, the same amount of cash and equivalents was on hand as at the start problems with his usual skill and diligence. We are impressed with the new building and new We appraise the 1989 earnings decline as temporary. We think Glen Mitchel is tackling the equipment, which will both reduce costs and improve quality of products and service. And we 64

[第 67 页]

[PAGE 67]

(转载自 Wesco 金融公司 1989 年年报)

我们不仅钦佩格伦·米切尔,同样也钦佩他的主要高管:托马斯·约翰逊、杰夫·莫里和托马斯……

非理性恐慌是那些选择与我们达成这类 80% 对 20% 交易的人应得的权利。不过,

在相关业务运营得到修复的过程中,我们定会力挺。我们之所以默默分担那些令人失望的时期,绝不意味着——

在致股东的报告里,无论时间长短,对于任何近期收购业务产生的糟糕财务结果,我们都不会加以粉饰。我们尤其会着意突出那些糟糕的结果,

无论它在会计术语中多么“不重要”——只要 Wesco 的董事长当初在这笔收购中存有利益。如果 Wesco 的股东未来没怎么听说新美洲电气的消息,

那么造成它被淡化的原因将是成功,而非失败。

合并资产负债表及相关讨论

Wesco 的合并资产负债表 (1) 保持着与一家公司相匹配的稳健,因为这家公司的合并净资产支撑着对他人庞大的未偿承诺;(2) 反映出进一步收购业务的步伐持续缓慢,原因是尽管不断搜寻,但站在 Wesco 股东视角,能以合理价格觅得的业务寥寥无几。

正如所附财务报表所示,1989 年 12 月 31 日,Wesco 持有的可流通权益证券总市值超出其账面价值总额约 9800 万美元,

较一年前约 5400 万美元的水平大幅增加。包括债券及其他固定收益证券在内的可流通证券的总市值

超出其账面价值总额约 1.03 亿美元。正如之前强调的,这笔未实现增值中,约有 1.01 亿美元存在于储蓄贷款子公司,其中包括

该子公司持有的普通股(主要是可口可乐公司股票)的未实现增值,以及 8940 万美元的房地美(Freddie Mac)股票增值。此外,Wesco 的保险子公司

还持有约 2900 万美元的普通股未实现增值。根据一项仅适用于保险公司的特殊会计惯例,扣除若出售股票应缴纳的所得税后,

这笔增值已计入 Wesco 的审计净资产,尽管该收益从未流经过任何经审计的损益表。

Wesco 在帕萨迪纳的房地产占据一整个街区,包括:(1) 位于一栋现代写字楼内约 12.5 万平方英尺一流的可出租净面积(包括 Mutual Savings 所占面积),以及 (2) 坐落于老旧建筑中的另外 3.4 万平方英尺经济价值有限的可出租净面积,

这些老建筑推倒可能比翻新更明智。这处房地产的市场价值远超其账面价值。以下两点印证了未实现增值的存在:(1) 抵押贷款(4,643,000 美元,固定利率 9.25%)的余额目前已超过它在 Wesco 1989 年 12 月 31 日资产负债表上的折旧后账面价值(2,862,000 美元);(2) 扣除抵押贷款还本付息后,Wesco 目前每年从中获得可观的净现金流(每年约 100 万美元)。

我们的现代写字楼,尽管帕萨迪纳地区写字楼空置面积过剩,出租率仍达 97%。我们收取略低于市场行情的租金,把大楼运营成一个面向我们欣赏的租户的“一流俱乐部”。事实上,

我们正准备翻新所有卫生间,尽管它们几乎没有任何毛病。(我们最近观察到不少别的楼宇管理不善的案例,在那里,

管理者宁愿粉饰财务记录,也不愿去粉刷大楼。我们尽量远离此类行径,偶尔出现偏差也会引以为戒,认为它既违反对租户的默示义务,也违背业主的长期利益。)凭借这些做法、黄金地段

和优越的停车配套设施,我们预期未来现金流会增长,但增速不会超过

通胀率。

将总负债与总股东权益及总流动资产作比较,Wesco 仍处于审慎的位置。Wesco 的做法是,在有具体需要之前就安排一定量的长期借款,

以便最大限度保持财务灵活,以应对风险和机遇。遵循这一做法,同时为降低利息成本,1989 年内 Wesco 以 65

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation Vogele. admire not only Glen Mitchel but also his chief officers: Thomas Johnson, Jeff Mowry and Thomas irrational panic is an entitlement for people who choose to make these 80%-20% deals with us. But We will be very supportive as operations are fixed. Our sharing of disappointing times without we will not obscure, in reports to our shareholders, poor financial results, temporary or not, from any recent business acquisition. And we will be particularly anxious to highlight bad results, no in the business acquired. If Wesco's shareholders don't hear much about New America Electric in matter how "immaterial" (in accountingspeak), in a case where Wesco's Chairman had an interest the future, it will be success, not failure, which causes de-emphasis. Consolidated Balance Sheet and Related Discussion consolidated net worth supports large outstanding promises to others and (2) reflects a continuing Wesco's consolidated balance sheet (1) retains a strength befitting a company whose slow pace of acquisition of additional businesses because few are found available, despite constant search, at prices deemed rational from the standpoint of Wesco shareholders. As indicated in the accompanying financial statements, the aggregate market value of Wesco's marketable equity securities was higher than their aggregate carrying value at December 31, 1989 aggregate market value of all marketable securities, including bonds and other fixed-income by about $98 million, up significantly from about $54 million one year earlier. The consolidated securities, exceeded aggregate carrying value by about $103 million. As earlier emphasized, about $101 million of this unrealized appreciation lies within the savings and loan subsidiary, and includes unrealized appreciation in common stocks (mostly stock ot the coca cola company) held by $89.4 million of appreciation in stock of Freddie Mac. In addition, there is about $29 million of Wesco's insurance subsidiary. Under a peculiar accounting convention applicable only to insurance companies this appreciation, after deducting income taxes which would be due if the stocks were sold, is already included in Wesco's audited net worth, even though the gain has never passed through any audited report of income. net rentable square feet, including Mutual Savings' space, in a modern office building, plus (2) an Wesco's Pasadena real estate comprises a full block containing (1) about 125,000 first-class additional net rentable 34,000 square feet of economically marginal space in old buildings, which it would probably be wiser to destroy than improve. This real estate has a market value substantially in excess of carrying value. The existence of unrealized appreciation is demonstrated by (1) mort- gage debt ($4,643,000 at 9.25% fixed) against this real estate now exceeding its depreciated current net cash flow (about $1 million per year) to Wesco after debt service on the mortgage. The carrying value ($2,862,000) in Wesco's balance sheet at December 31, 1989, and (2) substantial just-below-standard rents and run the building as a sort of first-class club for tenants we admire. In modern office building is 97% rented, despite a glut of vacant office space in Pasadena. We charge fact, we are about to refurbish all the bathrooms, even though there is almost nothing wrong with them. (We have observed many recent instances of mismanagement at other buildings where lapse, to stay a long way removed from such conduct, considering it contrary to both implicit managers prefer to paint the financial record, instead of the building. We try, with an occasional superior parking facilities, we anticipate future increases in cash flow, but at no better rate than the obligation to tenants and long-run interest of the owner.) With these practices, a prime location and rate of inflation. and total liquid assets. Wesco's practice has been to do a certain amount of long-term borrowing in Wesco remains in a prudent position when total debt is compared to total shareholders' equity advance of specific need, in order to have maximum financial flexibility to face both hazards and opportunities. Following this practice, and to reduce interest costs, Wesco during 1989 paid off at 65

[第 68 页]

[PAGE 68]

摘自西科金融公司 1989 年年报

西科按面值赎回了 1991 年 6 月到期的 2,500 万美元 10% 公司债,并新发行了 3,000 万美元 8% 公司债,于 1999 年 11 月到期。新债的低利率得益于西科 AA+ 的信用评级。预计合并后企业的资产负债表实力将在适当的时候用于一项或多项业务扩展。扩展活动需要耐心,至少对我们这样的人来说如此,原因如下。

许多商学院毕业生,以及几乎所有的顾问,都认为一家公司很容易通过收购无关或关联松散的生意来改善业绩。根据这种广为流传的观点,只要采取了明显的步骤,制定了正确的“使命宣言”,并聘用了合适的“专家”,那么每条铁路,就不会被新形式的竞争、过时而敌意的法律和工会规则锁住手脚,而会变成另一家联邦快递(Federal Express)、另一家联合包裹服务公司(United Parcel Service),甚至另一家像埃默森电气(Emerson Electric)那样表现出色的公司。

我们自己的经验,无论是亲身经历还是间接观察,都让我们对通过收购这种捷径持较悲观的看法。我们认为,过度乐观是由于成功的案例吸引了太多关注。许多人的推理方式,正像如果我只观察伊万·伦德尔(Ivan Lendl)和施特菲·格拉芙(Steffi Graf)便判断职业网球前景广阔,或者只观察中奖者便判断加州彩票前景大好一样。反过来也成立,而且更甚。人们太不关注那些最糟糕的收购案例对股东(或其他所有者)造成的可怕后果,比如 CBS-杜蒙(CBS-DuMont)、施乐-科学数据系统(Xerox-Scientific Data Systems)、通用电气-犹他国际(General Electric-Utah International)、埃克森-信赖电气(Exxon-Reliance Electric)、标准石油(俄亥俄)-肯尼科特(Sohio-Kennecott)、第一州际银行-联合银行(First Interstate Bancorp-Allied Bancshares)、美孚石油-蒙哥马利沃德(Mobil Oil-Montgomery Ward)、通用汽车-休斯飞机(General Motors-Hughes Aircraft)、雅芳产品-几乎任何人(Avon Products-Practically Anybody)、亚利桑那公共服务-梅拉银行(Arizona Public Service-MeraBank)、USX-德克萨斯石油与天然气(USX-Texas Oil & Gas)、保德信保险-巴奇(Prudential Insurance-Bache)。这个名单到此为止是因为篇幅所限,而非缺少更多的例子。名单中的收购公司都是伟大的企业,运营正直。事实上,它们的伟大增强了它们作为例子的效用,因为这说明,即使是在受人尊敬的公司中通过精英流程晋升上来的经理人,也很难通过收购来增进所有者的利益。

最差案例的全部影响之所以被忽略,部分原因是财务报告的惯例使经理人得以掩盖事实和影响。可怕的结果被掩盖,平庸的结果看起来不错。掩盖真相的手法包括:(1)将糟糕或平庸的结果混入其他本来会好得多的良好结果中;(2)通过“大洗澡”(big bath)手法,一次性将几个糟糕的结果扫下舞台。而“大洗澡”手法又常常伴随着其他地方发生的某些特殊收益,这些收益按刻意混淆的时间表变现。或者,将亏损混入“重组”(restructuring)中,使用的措辞足以将拿破仑在滑铁卢的结局解释为法国深思熟虑的加强。

在我们看来,通过收购来“解决问题”的企业模式,其结果远更常见的是像彼得·格雷斯(Peter Grace)那样平庸的“每年跟风潮流”的记录,而不是像多佛公司(Dover Corporation)那样的优异记录。而且,避免可疑的方法并不能保证成功。即使一个人(1)不依赖按交易推荐和成交付费的外部收购“专家”的估值判断,(2)不设立内部对应的、相当于必须靠收购才能生存的外部顾问的部门——即除了收购没有其他职能、常常被冠以“规划”甚至“战略规划”标签的内部部门——也很难在这一游戏中取胜。

或许比优秀收购记录之罕见更具启发意义的,是这些少数优秀记录中重要收购的惊人稀少。大多数赢家的做法,就像一个聪明的棒球击球手,如果规则允许他在挥棒前可以放弃尽可能多的投球,他便会那样做。

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation par its $25 million of 10%% debentures due in June 1991, and issued $30 million of new 8%% debentures due in November 1999. The low interest rate on the new debentures was made possible by Wesco's AA+ credit rating. be used in one or more business extensions. The extension activity requires patience, at least for It is expected that the balance sheet strength of the consolidated enterprise will in due course people like us, as explained below. It is assumed by many business school graduates, and by almost all consultants, that a nesses. According to this widely shared view, if only the obvious steps had been taken, if the right corporation can easily improve its outcome by purchasing unrelated or tenuously related busi- "mission statement" had been adopted and the right "experts" hired, then each railroad, instead of remaining bound in chains by new forms of competition and obsolete and hostile laws and union rules, would have become another Federal Express, another United Parcel Service, or even another brilliant performer in the mode of Emerson Electric. through business acquisition. We think undue optimism arises because successful records draw too Our experience, both actual and vicarious, makes us less optimistic about easy solutions tennis after observation limited to Ivan Lendl and Steffi Graf, or good prospects in the California much attention. Many people then reason as I would if I forecasted good prospects in big-time lottery after limiting observation to winners. The converse is also true, only more so. Far too little attention is given to the terrible effects on shareholders (or other owners) of the worst examples of corporate acquisitions such as CBS-DuMont, Xerox-Scientific Data Systems, General Electric-Utah International, Exxon-Reliance Electric, Sohio-Kennecott, First Interstate Bancorp-Allied Banc- Mobil Oil-Montgomery Ward, General Motors-Hughes Aircraft, and Avon Products-Practically shares, Arizona Public Service-MeraBank, USX-Texas Oil & Gas, Prudential Insurance-Bache, Anybody. The list ends here for want of space, not a shortage of additional examples. The acquiring utility as examples as they show how hard it is, even for managers promoted to power through corporations listed are great enterprises, honorably run. In fact, their greatness augments their meritocratic procedures at admired corporations, to advance by acquisition the interests of owners. corporate reporting cause managers to present data in a manner which obscures both facts and The full implications of the worst examples are lost, in part, because the conventions of implications. Horrible results are obscured, and mediocre results are made to look fine. Techniques for masking the truth include (1) mixing bad or mediocre results into other good results which would have been much better, absent the mixture, and (2) taking several poor results off the stage at once through the "big bath" technique. The "big bath" technique, in turn, is often accompanied by some extraordinary gain elsewhere which is cashed on a time schedule designed for obfuscation. Or a loss is mixed into a "restructuring," adopting word usage which would explain Napoleon'S outcome at Waterloo as a thoughtful strengthening of France. As we appraise it, the corporate mode of "solving your problems by acquisition" far more often ends in the mediocre "follow-the-fad-of-the-year" record of a Peter Grace than in the wonderful record of a Dover Corporation. Nor does the avoidance of dubious methodology guarantee success. acquisition "experts" paid per transaction recommended and closed, and (2) does not create the It is hard to win at the game, even if one (1) does not rely on the valuation judgment of outside in-house equivalent of the outside adviser who must buy to thrive, namely the internal department which has no function except acquisitions and often bears a label including "planning," or even "strategic planning." Perhaps more instructive than the rarity of good corporate acquisition records is the striking rarity of important acquisitions within the few good records. Most winners act as a wise baseball hitter would if permitted to pass as many pitches as he wished before swinging. 66

[第 69 页]

[PAGE 69]

以下内容摘自西科金融公司 1989 年年报:

举例来说,在并购方面成绩最突出的,当属大都会/美国广播公司的汤姆·墨菲和丹·伯克。然而,为持续股东创造经济价值的主要收购,在期末经济价值中占比超过 80%,发生频率却低于每两年一次——尽管他们完全掌控公司,是(过去和现在)业内最敏锐的学习者和行动者,亲自操办所有重要事务,而且身处一场利润丰厚且持久的传播革命(电视广播行业),这场革命中快速的变化为敏锐者提供了超常频率的机会。(作者不得不相信,墨菲和伯克抓住的机会只有敏锐者才能识别。这一点可以从作者本人多年前的一次经历中得到印证:墨菲和伯克因受法律限制无法购买一个电视台,便将其拱手相让,作者却拒绝了那个收购机会,其价格还不到现值的十分之一。)

对于偏好行动的人来说,从西科最终母公司伯克希尔·哈撒韦的收购记录中还可以汲取一个特别令人沮丧的教训。24 年来,伯克希尔将一家陷入绝境的新英格兰小型纺织企业,变成了一家大型多元化公司,且没有增发太多股份。然而,如果你从伯克希尔的记录中剔除六笔最重要的收购,平均每四年发生一次,那么这份记录现在就根本不会在这里——或者其他任何地方——被提及。

用公司现金匆忙进行不利的收购向来很容易(实际上,你会吸引一大批帮手)。而且,如果你不够明智,像通用电气在犹他国际合并案中,或施乐在并购科学数据系统公司时那样,对任何可达成的换股合并都极有可能转移比所获取的更多内在商业价值这一点缺乏足够敏感,就更容易造成损失。另一方面,有利的收购——不涉及竞争对手,也不涉及能通过收购方现有销售体系销售的品牌产品——则很难找到。

企业收购记录平均而言如此糟糕,并不仅仅是彼得原理在作祟——尽管这一原理在收购领域造成的伤害尤其严重。(这是因为,当你把全国销售总经理提拔为首席执行官去做不相关的收购时,自然比当初你把某个区域销售经理提拔为全国销售总经理时造成更大的实质性麻烦。)即便是一位判断力良好的首席执行官,在其剩余的职业生涯中,若能找到一个足以诱使他做出理性反应的大好机会,也算是幸运的了。

当然,好的收购交易稀缺并不意味没有优秀的公司待售。只是在一个有限竞争的世界上,没有哪家公司好到成为收购目标后,不会因提价而被毁掉。当这种情况发生时,许多公司还是会买——原因正如哥伦比亚大学伟大的哲学家查尔斯·弗兰克尔所深刻理解的那样:体系的设计(弗兰克尔会说不负责任地设计)使得即使股东受损,管理层也能获利。(顺便说一句,弗兰克尔在街头被抢劫杀害,这成为他对不负责任体系研究的最后一个无意贡献,提醒了许多保守的社会评论家想起苏格拉底。)

至此,最后一个问题依然存在:如果成功的公司收购如此困难,那么近来大多数杠杆收购(LBO)操作者收购企业后普遍取得的成功又该如何解释?答案的很大一部分来自所得税效应和其他简单效应。在一个典型的 LBO 中,当典型的大部分由股权构成的资本结构被 90% 的债务加上占资本 10% 的新普通股头寸取代时:(1)所有新普通股加上所有新债务的总市值,会远高于原所有旧普通股的市场总值,因为现有的税前收益流不再与公司所得税分享。

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation Capital Cities / ABC. Yet the major acquisitions, which accounted for more than 80% of ending For instance, among the best acquisition records is that of Tom Murphy and Dan Burke at economic value for continuing shareholders, occurred less often than once each two years. This learners and actors around, did all the important work themselves, and were located in the midst of slow pace occurred even though they were in full control, were (and are) two of the quickest change churned out opportunities for the acute at an above-normal rate. (The writer has to believe a profit-laden and long-lasting communications revolution (television broadcasting) wherein rapid from the writer's participation in rejecting a television-station opportunity, long ago given by Murphy that the opportunities seized by Murphy and Burke were recognizable only by the acute. This follows present-day value.) and Burke when they were barred by law from purchase. The price was less than one-tenth of business acquisition record of Wesco's ultimate parent, Berkshire Hathaway. Over 24 years, A particularly depressing lesson, for the action-prone, might also be extracted from the Berkshire transformed a small, doomed New England textile enterprise into a large and diversified Berkshire's record the six most significant acquisitions, extracting occurrences averaging one every company, without ending up with many more shares outstanding. Yet if you removed from four years, the record would not now be mentioned here, or anywhere else. business purchases in a hurry with corporate cash. And it has been even easier to cause It has always been easy (indeed, one attracts scores of helpers) to make disadvantageous Xerox in the merger with Scientific Data Systems, not to be super-sensitive to the probability that disadvantage if one is unwise enough, like General Electric in the Utah International merger, or any attainable stock-for-stock merger will transfer more intrinsic business value than is acquired. On the other hand, advantageous business purchases, not involving competitors or branded products which can be sold through the acquirer's present sales system, are difficult to find. although that Principle does especially intense damage in the acquisition field. (This occurs It is not just the Peter Principle which makes corporate acquisition records so bad, on average, because, when you promote the General Sales Manager to CEO making unrelated business substantive change by promoting the Sales Manager of some territory to General Sales Manager.) acquisitions, you naturally cause more trouble than you earlier did when you made a less Even a CEO with good acquisition judgment is lucky if, in his remaining career, he finds one large opportunity which tempts rational response. businesses are ever for sale. It is just that, in a finite, competitive world, no business is so wonderful The scarcity of good acquisition transactions, of course, does not imply that no wonderful corporations buy anyway, for reasons Columbia's great philosopher, Charles Frankel, so well that it can't be ruined as an acquisition candidate by increasing the price. When this happens, many manager gains even though the shareholder loses. (Incidentally, Frankel was mugged to death in a understood. The system is so constructed (irresponsibly, Frankel would say) that the corporate final inadvertent contribution to the study of irresponsible systems, reminding many conservative social critics of Socrates.) how does one explain the widespread recent success of most of the leveraged-buy-out ("LBO") At this point, a last question remains: If successful corporate business acquisition is so hard, operators who have purchased corporations? A huge part of the answer comes from income-tax effects and other simple effects. When, in a typical LBO, the typical mostly equity corporate capitalization was replaced by 90% debt plus a new 10%-of-capitalization common stock position: (1) the combined market value of all the new common stock plus all the new debt became existing stream of pre-tax earnings was no longer shared with corporate income tax much higher than the previous market value of all the old common stock, because the 67

[第 70 页]

[PAGE 70]

以下内容摘自西科金融公司 1989 年年报:

(1)股东;以及

(2)在很多情况下,这些收藏家此前每年收到的现金已超过收购方支付的金额。即使通过向原股东支付极高价格让他们退出,从而将公司税负降低带来的价值提升效应分享给他们,留存下来的价值提升税负效应,依然使得新发行的普通股(此时已变得很像一份条款优厚的投机权证)在墨迹未干之际,其价值便远超成本,这笔交易仅凭其产生的大量收购文件就对收购方非常划算;以及

(3)新的“所有者”随后采取了既不难以构想、也不难以实施的策略,包括以下方面:

(a)他们砍掉了大量容易削减的成本(主要是人员成本)以及表现不佳的业务板块,这些成本与板块以某种组合方式,一方面(i)以懈怠和愚蠢困扰着成功的公司(包括我们自己的公司),另一方面(ii)又创造了这些公司人性的优雅,并通过当下的牺牲,换来了良好的长期前景,从而让这些牺牲变得值得;以及

(b)他们以超高价格出售了部分业务,有时运用最简单的微观经济学洞见,将其卖给直接竞争对手,有时则卖给一个出奇容易找到的非竞争性公司买家,这种买家并非由管理层所有,却愿意支付几乎与竞争对手一样高的价格;

(4)新“所有者”随后在适当时机获利,不仅来自上述的税负效应和其他简单的重新洗牌活动,还来自在长期经济繁荣、股市同步上涨的时期,使用极端财务杠杆所带来的美妙上行效应。

这个国家是否希望其大型公司中有大量(甚至任何)拥有极度杠杆化的资本结构?除非偶尔遭遇逆境,否则这确实会引发一些有趣的社会问题。公司的一种社会职能,是不是作为减震器,保护依赖它们的员工、供应商和客户免受部分资本主义内在的波动性影响?本·富兰克林在《穷理查年鉴》中写下这样的民间智慧时,是否正确:“空口袋难以直立。”一个债台高筑的虚弱公司,在社会意义上是否等同于一座结构强度储备不足的桥梁?

即便承认杠杆收购在长期效率方面有一些有利影响(同时也有不利影响),我们究竟希望吸引多少能干的人投身这类公司资本重组活动?这类活动(1)减少了公司所得税,(2)常常试探反垄断法的边界,以及(3)将企业注意力集中在短期现金生成上,以偿还高到难以承受的债务水平。最后,正如哥伦比亚大学法学院的洛温斯坦教授(Lou Lowenstein)大致这样表述的:“我们真的希望整个企业实体——作为重要的社会机构——像猪腩期货合约那样被持续交易吗?”

无论这些社会问题如何回答,当前形势的三个方面是明确的。第一,公司税负效应在杠杆收购交易中如此巨大,以至于在此类交易中轻松成功,并不意味着在普通的公司收购中也能轻松成功。第二,如今成群结队的杠杆收购操作者,通过将借贷最大化来最大化税收利益,抬高了收购价格的总体水平,损害了其他潜在收购者(包括西科)的利益,这些收购者不愿这么做。第三,只要现行宽松的法律持续有效,杠杆收购操作者就不会消失。在这些法律下,操作者拥有真实的优势,而不仅仅是一片用来遮羞的无花果叶。即使失败和耻辱会减少他们的数量,而且杠杆收购交易中支付的价格也会下降,但减少公司所得税的资本化价值将依然存在。因此,交易仍将保有大量的理性动机。杠杆收购的精灵会遭遇挫折,但除非新法律命令它回去,否则它不会再回到瓶子里去。

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation shareholders; and collectors who, in many cases, had previously received more cash each year than (2) even after the value-enhancing effect of the corporate tax reduction was shared with former shareholders by paying them extra-high prices to leave, a retained residue of value- enhancing tax effect made the new common stock (which now became much like a on acquisition papers; and speculative warrant with good terms) worth considerably more than cost as the ink dried (3) the new "owners" then resorted to strategies, difficult neither to conceive nor implement, including the following: (a) they eliminated many of the easily removable costs (largely personnel costs) and sub-par segments which in some mix (i) bedevil successful corporations (including ours) with sloth and folly and (ii) create their humane grace and, through present sacrifice, good long-term prospects, justifying sacrifice endured; and (b) they sold off a few operations at super-high prices, sometimes exercising the easiest microeconomic insight by selling to a direct competitor and sometimes selling to a surprisingly easy-to-find non-competitive corporate buyer, not owned by its manag- ers, willing to pay almost as high a price as a competitor would; and (4) the new "owners" then profited, in due course, not only from the tax effect and other simple reshuffling activities described above, but also from the wonderful upside effects of extreme financial leverage during a long business boom accompanied by a rising stock market. extremely leveraged capitalizations, except through occasional adversity, presents interesting social Whether the country wants a large number (or even any) of its large corporations to have questions. Is one social function of corporations to be financially strong so that they act as shock implicit in capitalism? Was Ben Franklin right when he included the following folk wisdom in Poor absorbers, protecting dependent employees, suppliers and customers from part of the volatility Richard's Almanac: "It is hard for an empty sack to stand upright." Is a weak corporation, borrowed to the hilt, the social equivalent of a bridge with an inadequate reserve of structural strength? long term efficiency, how many thousands of able people do we wish to attract into promotional Granting that leveraged buy outs have some favorable effects (as well as unfavorable effects) on corporate recapitalization activity which (1) reduces corporate income taxes, (2) often tests the limits of antitrust law, and (3) focuses business attention on short-term cash generation to pay it (more or less): "Do we really want entire corporate businesses, as important social institutions, down oppressive levels of debt? Finally, as Columbia Law School's Professor Lou Lowenstein puts continuously traded like pork belly contracts?" First, the corporate tax effect is so large in LBO transactions that easy success in such transactions However the social questions are answered, three aspects of the present situation are clear. leveraged-buy-out operators now with us raise does not imply that success is easy in ordinary corporate acquisitions. Second, the hordes of detriment of other would-be acquirers, including Wesco, which are not willing to maximize tax the general level of acquisition prices to the benefits through maximized borrowing. And, third, the LBO operators will not go away so long as leaf aiding promotion. Even though failure and disgrace will reduce their number, and prices paid in present permissive laws last. The operators have a real advantage under such laws, not just a fig leveraged-buy-out transactions will fall, the capitalized value of reducing the corporate income tax will remain. Therefore, plenty of rational incentive will remain for transactions. The LBO genie will encounter reverses, but he is not going back in the bottle unless ordered to do so by new laws. 68

[第 71 页]

[PAGE 71]

以下内容摘自西科金融公司 1989 年年报

还应指出,杠杆收购操作者抬高报价的动机,并不止于来自税法的现实优势以及他们快速、不择手段重组业务的意愿。高价竞标的额外激励,源自一种典型的结构安排:杠杆收购合伙企业的普通合伙人自己投入的资金极少(扣除费用后往往少于零),却能在收益中分得很大份额。这种安排与赛马场拉客赌马的掮客制度如出一辙。又有谁见过一个不希望自己金主多下注的掮客呢?

对西科这样一家非杠杆收购操作者来说,优质企业的收购游戏向来艰难,而近年来,这场游戏已变得越来越像是在明尼苏达州利奇湖钓北美狗鱼——笔者最早的生意伙伴埃德·霍斯金斯(Ed Hoskins)曾与他的印第安人向导有过这样一段对话:

“这个湖里能钓到北美狗鱼吗?”

“这个湖里钓到的北美狗鱼比明尼苏达州任何一个湖都多。这个湖以北美狗鱼闻名。”

“你在这儿钓鱼多久了?”

“19 年。”

“那你钓到过多少条北美狗鱼?”

“一条也没有。”

当管理层持有我们的观点时,企业收购频率较低或许就可以被预见。无论这是因为游戏对几乎所有人来说都太难,还是仅仅因为对我们来说太难,对西科的股东而言结果都一样:更少的收购活动。当然,一次糟糕的收购结果完全可能发生。但一连串重大且无可挽救的收购麻烦,极少数是由那些认为收购游戏就像在利奇湖钓北美狗鱼的人造成的。凡事总有例外。例如,西科会很乐意明天就投入 7500 万美元,即使有 60% 的概率血本无归,只要获胜的回报足够大,使得统计期望值能提供可观的收益。

正如西科财务报表所附明细表所示,无论是储蓄和贷款子公司及保险子公司的投资,还是暂时持有以待出售来支持业务扩张的投资,都倾向于集中在极少数项目上。通过这种集中投资的做法,我们力求对所做的少数决策有更深入的理解。

西科年报披露的合并净利润与合并股东权益之比(1987—1989 年大约为 11%)在很大程度上依赖于证券收益,而证券收益本质上具有非经常性。

截至本文撰写之时,西科合并财务状况中相当充裕、甚至超出我们意愿的流动性,并非源自我们预测商业环境即将恶化、利率即将上升或普通股价格即将下跌。相反,原因仅仅是,我们未能找到让自己安心的更积极配置资本的机会。

西科继续努力更多地通过始终牢记显而易见之事来获利,而不是去钻研深奥难懂的东西。令人瞩目的是,像我们这样的人,通过努力保持一贯不干蠢事,而不是试图变得极其聪明,竟获得了如此之多的长期优势。想必有句民间谚语蕴含着智慧:“淹死的都是会水的。”我们的方法,虽然过去平均而言效果相当不错,而且很可能在长期未来仍相当有效,但是,这种方法注定会因限制行动而遭遇沉闷和不利的时期。

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation advantages derived from tax law and wilingness to reshuffle businesses with much speed and few It should also be noted that the LBO operators' incentives to bid high do not end with real of LBO partnerships risk little of their own money (often less than none after fees are taken into scruples. Additional incentives for high bids come from typical structures in which general partners account), yet share significantly in gains. Such arrangements are similar to the system of the race track tout. And who has ever seen a tout who didn't want his backer to make a lot of bets? ro Wesco, as a non-Lou operator, the good-corporate-acquisition game was always tough and that game in each recent year has become more like fishing for muskies at Leech Lake, ir Minnesota, where the writer's earliest business partner, Ed Hoskins, had the following conversation with his Indian guide: "Are any muskies caught in this lake?" "More muskies are caught in this lake than in any other lake in Minnesota. This lake is famous for muskies." "How long have you been fishing here?" "19 years." "And how many muskies have you caught?" "None." predicted. Whether this happens, as we like to believe, because the game is hard for almost When a management has our point of view, infrequency of business acquisition may safely be less worthwhile activity than we all would like. But there may be one consolation: A series of big, everyone, or merely because the game is hard for us, the result for Wesco shareholders is the same: incorrectable acquisition troubles, with no meaningful salvage, is seldom caused by people who of course, quite possible. For instance, Wesco would cheerfully invest $75 million tomorrow, with hink the acquisition game is like fishing for muskies at Leech Lake. One terrible acquisition result is, 60% chance of total loss, provided the pay-off for winning was large enough to cause statistical expectation to provide a handsome return. those in the savings and loan and insurance subsidiaries and those held temporarily elsewhere As indicated in Schedule accompanying Wesco's financial statements, investments, both pending sale to fund business extension, tend to be concentrated in very few places. Through this practice of concentration of investments, better understanding is sought with respect to the few decisions made. The ratio of Wesco's annual reported consolidated net income to reported consolidated Shareholders' equity, about 11% in 1987-89, was dependent to a significant extent on securities gains, irregular by nature. as this is written does not result from our forecast that business conditions are about to worsen, or The considerable, and higher than desired, liquidity of Wesco's consolidated financial position results, instead, from our simply not finding opportunities for more aggressive use of capital with that interest rates are about to rise, or that common stock prices are about to fall. Wesco's condition which we are comfortable. the esoteric. It is remarkable how much long-term advantage people like us have gotten by trying to Wesco continues to try more to profit from always remembering the obvious than from grasping folk saying: "It's the strong swimmers who drown". Our approach, while it has worked fairly well on be consistently not stupid, instead of trying to be very intelligent. There must be some wisdom in the average in the past and will probably work fairly well over the long-term future, is bound to encounter periods of dullness and disadvantage as it limits action. 69

[第 72 页]

[PAGE 72]

摘自西科金融公司 1989 年年报

此外,我们持续采取的策略并未建立在庞大基本盘之上。西科只在那些拥有足够商业优势以确保投入资本未来长期保持高回报的企业里,配置了自身内在价值的极小一部分。相比之下,伯克希尔·哈撒韦(西科的母公司)的内在价值中,有高得多的比例配置在那些能持久获得高回报的优质企业上。

上述对态度的阐述,以及下文对当前状况的历史说明,每年都会在年报中重复,并附上一则标准免责声明,旨在抑制不恰当的乐观情绪。在当年西科的母公司取得控制权时,西科的业务几乎完全局限于持有(1)一些冗余现金,外加(2)一家拥有多家分支的储蓄贷款协会,该协会持有大量期限极长的固定利率抵押贷款,资金来源则是计息活期存款。考虑到其他可选机会后,收购这项内在劣势明显的头寸是不明智的,原因是收购方(包括本函的签署人)在决策时,过分受到一个被视为略低于清算价值的价格的影响。在这类情形下,对于并非短线快进快出型操作者的收购方来说,收购活动平均而言往往只会带来低到中等的长期结果。之所以如此,是因为起步时源自“便宜货”的任何优势,都会被被收购企业固有的平庸——那种抗拒改变的平庸——所衍生的影响所淹没。尽管西科也开展了一些成功的业务活动,包括 1985 年从通用食品公司相关投资中取得一大笔收益,但这种正常效应并未被完全避免。西科至今仍像一场龟兔赛跑中的乌龟。而且,正如我们过去一年再次证明的那样,像西科这样内在价值中没有显著比例配置在卓越企业上的公司,我们这只特定的乌龟跑得并不怎么轻快。此外,它仅存的那点轻快劲儿,也常常被过去新业务活动的结果所打消,那些结果的糟糕程度,丝毫不亚于笔者的那条狗初次离开院子外出闯荡后一瘸一拐回家的经历:既(1)被车撞伤,又(2)因吃得过多垃圾而肚子鼓胀。(一些西科的长期股东或许会痛苦地记起一项曾经的新业务:在一个名字颇具讽刺意味的地方——“友好谷”——进行的山坡住宅开发。)

1990 年 1 月 25 日,西科将常规季度股息从每股 19.5 美分提高至每股 20.5 美分,股息支付日为 1990 年 3 月 13 日,股权登记日截止到 1990 年 2 月 28 日营业结束时。

本年度报告包含 10-K 表格,这是提交给美国证券交易委员会的报告,其中载有关于西科及其子公司的详细资料,以及附有大量脚注的经审计财务报表。同往常一样,恳请您仔细关注上述内容。

董事长

查理·T·芒格

1990 年 3 月 5 日

Reproduced from 1989 Annual Report of Wesco Financial Corporation tiny fraction of its total intrinsic value in businesses with enough commercial advantage in place to Moreover, our approach continues to be applied to no great base position. Wesco has only a Wesco's parent corporation, has a much larger proportion of its intrinsic value in durable high-return assure permanent high future returns on capital employed. In contrast, Berkshire Hathaway, businesses. The foregoing description of attitude, as well as the following historical explanation of the designed to deter inappropriate optimism. When Wesco's parent corporation acquired control, current situation, is repeated in the annual report each year, accompanied by a standard disclaimer Wesco's activities were almost entirely limited to holding (1) some surplus cash, plus (2) a multi- branch savings and loan association which had many very long-term, fixed-rate mortgages, offset by interest-bearing demand deposits. The acquisition of this intrinsically disadvantageous position was unwisely made, alternative opportunities considered, because the acquirer (including the signer of this letter) was overly influenced by a price considered to be moderately below liquidating value. Under such circumstances, acquisitions have a way of producing, on average, for acquirers who are from a starting "bargain" not quick-turn operators, low to moderate long-term results. This happens because any advantage purchased business. Such normal effects have not been completely avoided at Wesco, despite gets swamped by effects from change-resistant mediocrity in the some successful activities, including a large gain in 1985 from an investment in General Foods. continues to be like a tortoise in a race of hares. And, as we have demonstrated in one more year, A corporation like Wesco, with no significant proportion of intrinsic value in great businesses, by remembrance of past new-activity outcomes which were at least as bad as those of the writer's this particular tortoise is not very sprightly. Moreover, what sprightliness remains is often deterred dog when it limped home from its first foray outside the yard both (1) injured by a car and (2) one such once-new activity: hillside subdivision in the place with the ironic name, "Friendly Valley.") bloated from overeating garbage. (Some long-time Wesco shareholders may painfully remember to 20½ cents per share, payable March 13, 1990, to shareholders of record as of the close of On January 25, 1990, Wesco increased its regular quarterly dividend from 19½ cents per share business on February 28, 1990. Commission, and includes detailed information about Wesco and its subsidiaries as well as audited This annual report contains Form 10-K, a report filed with the Securities and Exchange financial statements bearing extensive footnotes. As usual, your careful attention is sought with respect to these items. Charks T Manger Chairman of the Board Charles T. Munger March 5, 1990 70

[第 73 页]

[PAGE 73]

来自美国储蓄机构联盟的协会。

本页转载的是互助储蓄与贷款协会 1989 年 5 月 30 日的退出函。

互助储蓄与贷款协会

地址:315 EAST COLORADO BLVD. • PASADENA, CALIFORNIA 91101-1954

美国储蓄机构联盟

地址:1709 New York Avenue N. W., Washington, D. C. 20006

先生们:

此函为互助储蓄与贷款协会正式退出美国储蓄机构联盟的通知。我们已不再愿意与该联盟保持联系。

互助储蓄是西科金融公司(在美交所上市)和伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司(在纽交所上市)的子公司。该联盟当前的游说操作存在严重缺陷,实际上堪称可耻,以至于我们不愿继续保留会员资格。

在加入该联盟多年后,互助储蓄并非轻率决定退出。但我们认为,该联盟造成的乱局有多种原因,我们在给股东的上一份年报中曾试图公允地总结这些原因。而联盟的游说行为使局面变得更糟。

我们的储蓄与贷款行业如今制造出了美国金融机构历史上最大的烂摊子。虽然乱局的起因众多,我们试图在给股东的最新年报中公允总结,但联盟的游说行为使问题雪上加霜。原因包括:(1)多年来联盟通过游说持续且成功地阻碍监管机构对由骗子与蠢货主导的少数受保机构采取恰当对策;(2)儿戏般的会计准则,使许多受保机构看起来比实际更稳健;(3)支撑受保机构储蓄账户承诺的实际股本资本水平严重不足。

现在,将国会面临的处境比作癌症,而将联盟比作重大致癌物,并不过分。如同癌症一般,如果国会缺乏明智与勇气切除那些引发问题的病灶,我们当前的麻烦将卷土重来。

此外,尽管明显需要真正的立法改革,涉及痛苦的调整,但联盟近期的游说努力却一贯抵制最低限度的改革。例如,联盟坚持推行宽松的会计准则、不足的资本要求,实际上导致许多受保机构在依赖联邦存款保险的全面运营中管理不善。联盟允许所谓的“商誉”(在金融机构语境中即“空气”)在与监管机构打交道时被算作资本,并尽量降低维持全面运营所要求的实际股本资本水平。

面对联盟游说显然助长酿成的全国性灾难,联盟仍顽固地坚持要求延续宽松的会计准则和不足的资本。联盟对储蓄与贷款危机的回应,就好比埃克森石油公司在瓦尔迪兹号漏油事件后,仍坚持允许油轮船长大量饮酒。如果联盟效仿另一个时代某制造商的明智榜样——该制造商在严重过失后向国会公开道歉,那会好得多。由于联盟长期误导政府,令纳税人蒙受巨大损失,它理应公开道歉,而非加倍努力继续误导。

我们知道有一种观点认为,行业协会不应被要求遵守高标准,它们在重大过失后无需做出解释或保持正常的人际礼仪,只需提供自私自利的废话和政治献金。按此观点,每个行业成立行业协会不是为了在立法环境中提供真相,而是为了提供利益集团的自私说辞。在联盟这种案例中,当这种自私废话和政治献金得到每个国会选区中声音响亮且富有的选民支持时,事实证据已摆在我们面前:此类行业协会行为对国家的危害能力极大。因此,联盟的公共责任是以完全不同的方式行事,就像大联盟在“黑袜”丑闻后改革棒球一样。此外,正如客户储蓄机构如今因联盟过去的短视而处境更糟,由于联盟当前短视造成的乱局加剧,客户机构未来也将被证明深受其害。

基于此信念,沃伦·E·巴菲特先生和我不仅促使互助储蓄退出美国储蓄机构联盟,还作为一项小小的抗议举措,将本退出函副本公之于媒体,以期引起关注。

此致,

互助储蓄与贷款协会

董事长

查尔斯·T·芒格

Association from United States League of Savings Institutions. Reproduced on this page is a copy of the May 30, 1989 letter of resignation of Mutual Savings and Loan LAGANINGS 315 EAST COLORADO BLVD. • PASADENA, CALIFORNIA 91101-1954 United States League of Savings Institutions, May 30, 1989 Washington, D. C. 20006 1709 New York Avenue N. W., Gentlemen: This letter is the formal resignation of Mutual Savings and Loan Association from the United States League of Savings which are no longer willing to be associated with the League. Mutual Savings is a subsidiary of Wesco Financial Corporation, listed ASE, and Berkshire Hathaway Inc., listed NYSE, current lobbying operations are so tlawed, indeed disgraceful, that we are not willing to maintain membership. Mutual Savings does not lightly resign after belonging to the League for many years. But we believe that the League's mess has many causes, which we tried to summarize fairly in our last annual report to stockholders, it was made much Our savings and loan industry has now created the largest mess in the history of U.S. financial institutions. While the to operations of a minority of insured institutions dominated by crooks and fools, (2) mickey-mouse accounting which worse by (1) constant and successful inhibition over many years, through League lobbying, of proper regulatory response underlying insured institutions' promises to holders of savings accounts. made many insured institutions look sounder than they really were, and (3) inadequate levels of real equity capital agent, And, like cancer, our present troubles will recur if Congress lacks the wisdom and courage to excise elements which It is not unfair to liken the situation now facing Congress to cancer and to liken the League to a significant carcinogenic helped cause the troubles. lobbying efforts regularly resist minimal reform. For instance, Moreover, despite the obvious need for real legislative reform, involving painful readjustment, the League's recent conventions allowing regulators and (2) minimization of the amount of real equity capital required as a condition of maintenance of full scale "goodwill" (in the financial institutions' context translate "air") to count as capital in relations with operations relying on federal deposit insurance. prescribing continuation of loose accounting principles, inadequate capital and, in effect, inadequate management at many In the face of a national disaster which League lobbying plainly helped cause, the League obdurately persists in from the Valdez if it had insisted thereafter on liberal use of whiskey by tanker captains. insured institutions. The League responds to the savings and loan mess as Exxon would have responded to the oil spill public apology to Congress. Because the League has clearly misied its government for a long time, to the taxpayers' great It would be much better if the League followed the wise example, in another era, of the manufacturer which made a detriment, a public apology is in order, not redoubled efforts to mislead further. We know that there is a school of thought that trade associations are to be held to no high standard, that they are reason or normal human courtesy following egregious fault, but merely to furnish self-serving nonsense and political In this view, each industry creates a trade association not to proffer truth.or industries' trade associations. But the evidence is now before us that this type of trade association conduct, when backed in the legislative milieu, the self-serving nonsense and political contributions of other as in the League's case by vocal and affluent constituents in every congressional district, has an immense capacity to do baseball reformed after the "Black Sox' harm to the country. Therefore, the League's public duty is to behave in an entirely different way, much as major-leaque the increased mess caused by League short-sightedness in the past, client institutions will later prove ill-served by present scandal. Moreover, just as client savings institutions are now worse off because of short-sightedness of the League. Savings Institutions; we are also, as one small measure of protest, releasing to the media, for such attention as may ensue, Believing this, Mr. Warren E. Buffett and I are not only causing Mutual Savings to resign from the U.S. League of copies of this letter of resignation. Truly yours, MUTUAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION CharkesT manger Chairman of the Board Charles T. Munger 71

[第 74 页]

[PAGE 74]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

过去五年的财务数据精选

(单位:千美元,每股数据除外)

1985 年

1986 年

1987 年

1988 年

1989 年

收入:

已赚保费

504,872

销售与服务收入

1,219,252

823,884

1,326,829

已实现投资收益

144,722

220,764

181,992

利息与股息收入

317,059

824,895

1,407,642

1,526,459

杂项收入

495,055

237,319

584,235

314,251

394,279

营业收入合计

1,930

2,452,208

6,316

13,901

28,838

131,671

223,810

331,452

盈利:

1,463,638

2,431,782

2,464,893

27,094

2,483,892

7,892

已实现投资收益前盈利

92,948

342,867

131,464

282,361

已实现投资收益

150,897

214,746

435,815

净利润

234,552

19,806

313,441

399,270

85,829

147,575

299,902

447,477

每股盈利:

已实现投资收益前盈利

298.95

81.04

131.57

114.62

187.24

净利润

379.99

246.19

17.27

273.37

348.23

已实现投资收益

74.86

127.55

262.46

204.51

390.01

年末数据:

总资产

3,480,789

1,885,330

117,879

4,931,354

2,377,797

260,170

5,863,235

2,841,659

289,886

6,816,848

480,009

9,459,594

长期债务及其他借款

3,410,108

4,925,126

1,007,516

股东权益

1,147

1,147

1,147

1,146

1,146

1,644

2,073

2,477

2,975

4,296

发行在外普通股股数(千股)

股东权益每股金额

普通股

股票过户代理人与登记处

公司普通股的股票过户代理人及登记处。与客户服务部门的通信可直接寄至:

The Bank of Boston Shareholder Services Division, P.O. Box 644, Boston, MA 02102

邮编:45-01-05。股票证书不应邮寄给公司。

重新发行或转让的证书应寄至:转让处理部,邮箱:45-02-09。

股东

截至 1990 年 3 月 1 日,公司约有 6,300 名普通股记录持有人。记录持有人包括代表实益而非记录股东持有至少 145,000 股的名义持有人。管理层认为公司的实益股东超过 13,000 人。

普通股价格范围

公司的普通股在纽约证券交易所挂牌交易,交易代码:BRK。下表列出了在指定期间内,纽约证券交易所综合报价系统(1988 年 11 月 29 日前为全国市场系统)及全国证券交易商自动报价系统报告的最高和最低每股销售价格:

1989 年

第一季度

最高:5,025

最低:4,625

第二季度

最高:7,000

最低:4,950

第三季度

最高:8,750

最低:6,600

第四季度

最高:8,900

最低:7,950

1988 年

第一季度

最高:3,500

最低:3,000

第二季度

最高:4,150

最低:3,400

第三季度

最高:5,050

最低:4,040

第四季度

最高:4,600

最低:3,400

股息

自 1967 年以来,伯克希尔未宣布派发现金股息。

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. Selected Financial Data for the Past Five Years (dollars in thousands, except per share data) 1985 1986 1987 1988 Revenues: 1989 Insurance premiums earned Sales and service revenues. $ 504,872 Realized investment gain Interest and dividend income 144,722 317,059 $ 1.219.252 823,884 $ 1,326,829 220,764 181,992 824.895 $ 1,407,642 $ 1.526,459 Total revenues Sundry ....... 495,055 237,319 584,235 314,251 394,279 1,930 $2,452,208 6,316 13,901 28,838 131,671 223,810 331.452 Earnings: $1,463,638 $2,431,782 $2,464,893 27,094 $2,483.892 7.892 Before realized investment gain Realized investment gain ...... $ 92,948 Earnings per share: Net earnings..... 342,867 $ 131,464 $ 282,361

  • 150.897

214,746 $ 435,815 $ 234.552 19,806 $ 313,441 $ 399,270 85,829 S 147,575 299.902 Before realized investment gain $ 447,477 Net earnings Realized investment gain $ 298.95 81.04 $ 131.57 114.62 187.24 Year-end data: $ 379.99 246.19 $ 17.27 273.37 348.23 74.86 127.55 262.46 204.51 Total assets 390.01 Term debt and other borrowings $ 3,480,789 1,885,330 117,879 $ 4,931,354 2,377,797 260,170 $ 5,863.235 Common shares outstanding, Shareholders' equity 2,841,659 289,886 $ 6,816,848 480.009 $ 9,459,594 3,410,108 4,925,126 1,007.516 Shareholders' equity per in thousands.. 1,147 1,147 1,147 outstanding share... 1,146 1,146 1,644 2.073 $ 2.477 $ 2.975 4,296 COMMON STOCK Stock Transfer Agent Registrar for the Company's common stock. Correspondence with the Division may be directed to Customer Service The Bank of Boston Shareholder Services Division, P.O. Box 644, Boston, MA 02102 serves as Transfer Agent and Stop 45-01-05. Certificates should not be mailed to the Company. Section, Mail Stop 45-02-09. Certificates for re-issue or transfer should be directed to the Transfer Processing Section. Mail Shareholders included nominees holding at least 145,000 shares on behalf of beneficial-but-not-of-record owners. Management The Company had approximately 6,300 record holders of its common stock at March 1, 1990. Record owners believes that the Company has more than 13,000 beneficial owners. Price Range of Common Stock following table sets forth the high and low sales prices per share, as reported on the New York Stock Exchange Composite The Company's Common Stock is listed for trading on the New York Stock Exchange. trading symbol: BRK. The System/National Market System prior to that date, during the periods indicated: List since November 29, 1988, and as reported by the National Association of Securities Dealers Automated Quotation 1989 ... First Quarter..... High LOW $5,025 1988 ..... Second Quarter 7,000 $4,625 High Low Third Quarter.... 4,950 First Quarter Fourth Quarter 8,750 Second Quarter.. $3,500 8,900 6,600 Third Quarter... 4,150 $3,000 Dividends 7,950 Fourth Quarter 5,000 3,400 5,050 4,040 4,600 Berkshire has not declared a cash dividend since 1967. 72

[第 75 页]

[PAGE 75]

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

董事

沃伦·E·巴菲特,董事长

伯克希尔首席执行官

查尔斯·T·芒格,副董事长

每日新闻集团公司(Daily Journal Corporation,在加利福尼亚州出版专业报纸)董事会主席

肯尼斯·V·查斯

已退休,原伯克希尔纺织业务首席运营官

小马尔科姆·G·查斯

已退休,原伯克希尔董事会主席

J·弗恩·麦肯齐

伯克希尔首席财务官

小沃尔特·斯科特

彼得·基威特父子公司(Peter Kiewit Sons', Inc.)董事长兼首席执行官,该公司在全球范围内从事建筑、采矿、包装和林业经营。

高管

查尔斯·T·芒格,副董事长

沃伦·E·巴菲特,董事长兼首席执行官

罗伯特·H·伯德,副总裁

迈克尔·A·戈德堡,副总裁

斯坦福·利普西,副总裁

J·威廉·斯科特,副总裁

J·弗恩·麦肯齐,副总裁兼秘书

马克·D·汉堡,财务主管

丹尼尔·J·贾克西奇,会计长

索取即寄:本公司备有两份早期年报致股东信汇编,一份涵盖 1977 年至 1983 年年报,另一份涵盖 1984 年至 1988 年年报。致函本公司(地址:3555 Farnam St., Suite 1440, Omaha, NE 68131)索取,即可免费获赠一册。

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC. DIRECTORS WARREN E. BUFFETT. Chairman Chief Executive Officer of Berkshire CHARLES T. MUNGER, Vice Chairman Chairman of the Board of Directors of Daily Journal Corporation, publisher of KENNETH V. CHACE specialty newspapers in California Retired, Former Chief Operating Officer of Textile Operations of Berkshire MALCOLM G. CHACE, JR. Retired. Former Chairman of Berkshire's Board J. VERNE MCKENZIE Chief Financial Officer of Berkshire WALTER SCOTT, JR. Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Peter Kiewit Sons', Inc., engaged worldwide in construction, mining, packaging and timberlands. OFFICERS CHARLES T. MUNGER, Vice Chairman WARREN E. BUFFETT, Chairman and CEO ROBERT H. BIRD, Vice President MICHAEL A. GOLDBERG, Vice President STANFORD LIPSEY, Vice President J. WILLIAM SCOTT, Vice President J. VERNE MCKENZIE, Vice President, Secretary MARC D. HAMBURG, Treasurer DANIEL J. JAKSICH, Controller Two compilations of letters from earlier Annual Reports are available upon 1988. Single copies are furnished without charge in response to requests received by the request. One is from reports for 1977 through 1983, the other, from reports for 1984 through Company at 3555 Farnam St., Suite 1440, Omaha, NE 68131.

[第 76 页]

[PAGE 76]

执行办公室 — 内布拉斯加州奥马哈市基威特广场 1440 号,邮编 68131

伯克希尔·哈撒韦公司

Executive Offices - 1440 Kiewit Plaza, Omaha, Nebraska 68131 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC.